Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

Posts

B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#1

B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

North of the Border

>Owner of LV has this insight to share with us in an earlier thread:

"Our preference is to always manufacture in North America - and we do a lot of it. There just aren't always manufacturers that are willing to do the work though. To get small runs done, China is the place to go...they're quite happy to have the work, while many domestic manufacturers won't even quote.

Cheers -

Rob "

The Chinese has a saying to the effect that big chickens don't pick up small rice! (i.e. they go after big meals only) Do we all see ourselves as big chickens?

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#2

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & busi

John L. Blue

>Good question! Lift that bale!

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#3

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & busi

Dave's Not Here

>While I don't necessarily disagree with Rob Lee's quote, I think there might be more to it than that. I have to wonder how many of those domestic manufacturers that won't give a quote have quoted in the past only to loose out to a foreign quote. It doesn't take a business long to figure out that they're wasting their time and money when certain businesses ask for quotes but always award the work to someone else.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#4

Re:I don't blame China

Chuck in ND

>I blame American CEO greed and our goverment for allowing it to happen. A prime example is SawStop, a very expensive line of table saws that are made in Taiwan. If the CEO wasn't so greedy, the saws could be made here in the USA.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#5

Re:I don't blame China

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Or Canada!

;-)

Costs of doing business are all about opportunities. Why some shops will not quote on a job often has more to do with what is their core business model and related cost to volume. Many shops are driven by labour rates and set up costs, so little to do with materials.

At the end of the day the world is getting smaller and smaller, finding center's of excellence has more to do with a companies business plan and ability to produce quality to a predictable level, cost center's also are key, but perhaps the centers of excellence for some of the products we desire are best produced elsewhere now, the value proposition for any product is complicated, but it is also global, time to get on that train or miss it.

It's Economics 101, Supply vs Demand.... The industrial age was born in the 1860's, here we are now 150 years later... the issues are similar, locations have changed..

:-)

Off to buy a German made violin in KW!!

Whoo Whooo!!

Jim

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#6

Re:I don't blame China

Dave's Not Here

>I agree with 99% of what you said. I do disagree with your "Economics 101, Supply vs Demand" though. The current pricing structure of gas plainly indicates that the supply and demand theory can be manipulated. Currently there is a very large over supply of gas to feed a diminishing demand yet the price of gas keeps rising at the pump. A complicated situation indeed but a glaring example that there is much more to pricing than just supply vs demand.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#7

buying a violin?

GolfSteve in Calgary

>It pains me to hear that you're buying a violin. You should be making it. Your lovely daughter would be sure to enjoy it when it's finished in time for her 30th birthday.

:-)

Cheers,

Steve (who wants to build a guitar and a harp some day).

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#8

"Some Chicken! Some Neck!"

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#9

Cycles

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Hi Steve,

Well we bought a hand made Japanese violin, made in 1940, the sound is incredible! The place is owned by a maker as well, but like furniture makers know, the demand for your work can vary and he makes a full time living selling and repairing violins in Kitchener Waterloo, for 34 years now.

He said it's funny, other makers miss the final details in customizing the violin for sound, they bring their work to a repair person like himself so he can finalize their work for them...a circle from maker to repair, it's one set of skills feeding the other, and it goes on, making either focused profession that much better...sound familiar?

I feel great about the Japanese violin, it was made by hand in a time when the demands on that society in Japan were about skill and quality, pre war and pre modernization.

Take care,

Jim

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#10

Overly simplistic...

John in NM

>Most if not all US branded table saws are made overseas, even those that had been made in factories here and were already tooled up to do it. Just another opportunity to bash the Sawstop guy. If you don't like him or his product, thats fine, but keep the objections based in reality.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#11

Re:I don't blame China

Charlie Self

>"A complicated situation indeed but a glaring example that there is much more to pricing than just supply vs demand."

Bet on it. My wife told me this morning that Verizon has a charge of $5 per month on one of our phone lines. Why? It's for NOT making long distance calls on that line.

Come Monday, Verizon can kiss all the income from that phone line goodbye.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#12

Re: Overly simplistic...

Charlie Self

>Very, very few table saws, or other heavier tools, are U.S. made these days. The new Unisaw is said to be one. The Powermatic 66 was another some eight or nine yers ago. Whether or not it still is, I don't know. I know of no others, which doesn't meant there aren't any, but does mean there aren't many.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#13

Re: Overly simplistic...

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>True, guys. But, I have the Shopsmith...bought in 1978...manufactured in Dayton, Ohio....still in very good working condition.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#14

Re:I don't blame China

Charlie Self

>SawStop is still close to being a start-up company, with smaller resources than many others, yet you're not taking a shot at the others who also produce tools overseas. Why not?

It is not CEO greed, anyway. It's consumer choice. The Chinese manufacturers are good businessmen, who saw an opportunity (or a thousand), made an offer, won the deal and produced, while U.S. producers stumbled, without knowing what to do. Before they figured out an answer favorable to the U.S., they found it easier to move production overseas, shut plants down and wave goodbye to the workers.

For several years, the consumer had the option of going for the more costly U.S. version, or getting the Taiwanese version at 2/3 the price with somewhat lower quality.

Guess what happened?

It's senseless to jump on a new company for going overseas with production when old line makers like Delta, DeWalt, Powermatic, General, et al., went offshore long before. Even that is an over-simplification, but it's far more complete than blaming it on one or two or a dozen CEOs.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#15

Re: Reality ?

Chuck in ND

>What was it that I said that wasn't reality ?

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#16

Re:I don't blame China

Chuck in ND

>A new American made Unisaw doesn't cost as much as a SawStop cabinet saw.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#17

Re: Reality ?

Chuck in ND

>And for those who still don't get it, if I have to work at a poverty wage, or worse yet, don't have work, guess what ? I have no money to stimulate the economy. But then again, how do I expect people that insist that every woodworker should have a industrial cabinet saw in their shop, no matter if all they do is build cutting boards, or that everyone should have a $150 or more miter gauge for the table saw when a miter saw is much safer, or that table saw blade alignment should be set to machinist standards. Theres not much reality in woodworking forums it seems, or should I say common sense ?

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#18

Clarity????

John in NM

>Wow, really can't quite follow your syntax. Who insisted that everyone has to have all that stuff you list?

My point was that you single out one manufacturer to scorn for the greedy practice of manufacturing their product in Taiwan, when in reality almost all of them do it. Even those that still make a premium product or two domestically have a cheaper line that is identical to every other vendor's but for the color of the paint.

So why choose this one guy in particular? The implication is that he and his company are somehow worse than all the others who engage in the same practices. Is there a real justification for this implication?

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#19

Re: Clarity????

Chuck in ND

>Price out a newly designed, made in the USA Delta Industrial Unisaw and a Industrial SawStop cabinet saw thats made in Taiwan.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#20

Apples and oranges...

John in NM

>You are comparing two vastly different products in terms of features. Take off the Sawstop's brake and you'd have a point. Unless the new Delta has a similar braking technology?

Your comparison is similar to comparing the new Delta with a Griz or the like that doesn't share its improvements and costs around half as much.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#21

Re:I don't blame China

ted Wong

>In the beginning Sawstop tried to have the saw made in the U.S. They tried unsuccessfully to work with an American Saw manufacturer. The overwhelming response from the greedy ceo's was no way could we retool and produce that saw. So Sawstop set out on their own to make the saw. With the capital they had on hand and the price point they were shooting for foreign production was their solution.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#22

Re:I don't blame China

Howard Norman

>"The overwhelming response from the greedy ceo's was no way could we retool and produce that saw."

I would guess that the decision to license the Sawstop technology never got to the ceo's desk. Of course I am not privy to the details of the discussions but that would be my guess anyway.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#23

Re: Apples and oranges...

Chuck in ND

>I guess the new design of the Unisaw doesn't count, interesting.

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#24

Don't blame the CEO's

Ralph in Huntington Beach

>I remember that debate going on at the time he was trying to get it started and it seemed to me that the greedy one was the guy that invented the saw stop. He wanted huge percentages from the new saw from any manufacturer that he could suck in. He is also an idiot.

And what's with all the class envy here, GREEDY CEO's??? Get over it.

Look in the archives, if that's possible, and you'll see that the SS guy wanted the world from the Mfg's. He might have a great saw, but I'm not selling my 66 to go and buy anything from that company.

If this isn't all about greed, then why are the SS saws SO expensive??? Why doesn't the Greedy CEO just sell them for cost?

Re: B4 we clame China for stealing our jobs & business

#25

Re: Don't blame the CEO's

Chuck in ND

>I don't think anyone is asking that CEO's sell stuff at cost, thats rediculous. But, if the CEO is doing well, shouldn't the rest of the employees atleast deserve a respectable liveing ? Henry Ford got it right many years ago when he wanted to raise his employees pay. His reasoning was that the employees could then afford what they built. It was a win, win situation for him. He got happier loyal employees that put more pride into their work, probably more production, and turned his proud employees into part time salesmen, which ment more sales for Ford.