Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

Posts

Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

#1

Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

Gary Smyth

>I usually use various wooden tools (cherry, birch, soft maple)for scraping, stirring, draining off liquid, grease, etc. For a long time now after something is made I take it to the garage and soak it in mineral oil for a week or two. I let it dry for a similar amount of time. I rub it down by hand until burnished and not slick. By the time it is ready for use as a utensil it weighs about 50% more, and I won't need to "season" it again for about two years even if placed in the dishwasher. So here is my question. Is the wood stronger with an oil bath? More flexible? It seems to me that it is both (which is why I do it) but is it a fact? I know that around here farmers and miners used to soak their handles. I thought it was for strength and shock prevention when striking something, but is it a wifes tale or is there science behind the practice?

Re: Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

#2

JL

Re: Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

JL

>Interesting thought. I can see mineral oil penetrating into the pores of the woods. I can see it acting to dampen out vibration (sort of like a dead blow hammer). I don't see it really making the wood stronger.

I once worked for a company that impregnated wood products (mostly flooring) with monomer and then polymerized the monomer while it was in the wood. In this case, it definitely made the wood stronger. I've done similar things on a much smaller scale with thin CA glue. In both cases the polymerization of the monomer makes the wood harder, more resistant to breaking and a lot heftier. The polymerization interacts with the wood fibers - sort of creating a unified structure. Mineral oil on the other hand won't polymerize. The lighter fractions will eventually ooze out. The heavier fractions may be trapped in the matrix of the wood - but there wouldn't be an incorporation into the "complete structure".

How about an experiment? Take some doweling. Cut it up into lengths. Randomly assign the lengths to the control group or the experimental group. Soak the experimental group in oil per your procedure. Measure the deflection and breaking of the dowels - say by fastening an end into a vise or jig and putting weights on the end. If you have an Instron it would make it easier :). If it makes the wood stronger - then it can be measured. If it makes the wood more flexible - then it can be measured. If you are really curious...

Re: Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

#3

Re: Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>I use linseed oil on my tool handles. I kmow it makes them less brittle. It also keeps out water which will definitely shorten the life of a handle. another plus, the handle sheds dirt more readily.

on a kitchen utinsel It would keep oils that may turn rancid from penetrating as well as resisting water.. It's a practice worth keeping.

John

Re: Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

#4

I am skeptical

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When wood dries the water between the cells is first lost and then the water in the cells is lost and the cells collapse. While about half the weight of a live tree is water, immersion of a once dried piece of wood in water will result in a relatively small weight regain. The collapsed wood structure (shrunk wood) never regains much of the original moisture.

Wood likes water much more than mineral oil so I would presume wood would soak up more water than mineral oil, and that is not very much. So I would conclude that it is not likely that wood will weigh 50% more after a mineral oil soak. Furthermore, I am skeptical that the mineral oil would even penetrate into the wood very far. These questions can be easily answered by experiment.

I think the main role of oils on wood is that the oil retards penetration of water. Wet/dry cycles in wood leads to stress cracking which weakens the wood. If the oil penetrated deep into the wood, highly unlikely I think, it could plasticize the wood and make it more flexible.

Re: Kitchen tools, yard tools too.

#5

Just as an aside,

Gary Smyth

>the weight difference between the oiled and non-oiled wood as stated originally is a bit ambitious. I took a similar item of "dry" wood to what has been oiled and the weight difference is more like 30%. Not a direct comparison between identical pieces of wood, but a comparison used as a benchmark for this message. Also, about two years ago I took a walnut ladderback chair missing a woven rush seat (I thought I'd get to two years ago) and placed jars of mineral oil underneath all four legs. It's been collecting debris in a corner of a shed. Over time the oil level has dropped from the original levels in the jars and the walnut turned legs now have a noticible darkening on three of the legs almost to the seat, the fourth leg somewhat less, and the cross braces on the sides, front, and the back have also absorbed the oil several inches in. When I first noticed the migration through capillary action I determined to leave it as long as I could just to see the result. Right now I'm thinking that if I leave it long enough the oil traveling from the bottom of the legs will eventually travel to all wooden parts that are connected. What that means for wood strength is anyone's guess. What it will do to the glue joints is also unknown. Wood swelling is imperceptable. I'll give it more time as long as the space is not needed.