Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

End table design: Too "tippy"?

Posts

End table design: Too "tippy"?

#1

End table design: Too "tippy"?

Dan Mitchell

>I'm planning to build a couple end tables to go with a new couch we're getting. The couch (all our furnishings) is very contemporary, and so is the design I came up with for the tables. Here's a sketchup drawing of design. They will be made of a pine frame, with 1/2" or 3/4" MDF (haven't decided which) covering all sides, and veneer (likely cherry, to match the tone of the couch legs) applied over the MDF. I'm wondering though if the foot, being only 12" wide, might make the tables a bit "tippy". Not really sure this is an issue, and since the tables will be open on the bottom, I could always insert some weight of some sort to make the table more stable. Any thoughts?

TIA

Dan


img

Re: End table design: Too "tippy"?

#2

Re: End table design: Too "tippy"?------WebKitForm

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>Probably not.

I recently built a table for a flat panel TV that is long and skinny, with 6/4 legs 11 inches O.D. on the ends. Perfectly stable. these are legs and not a continuous flat piece but I don't know if that makes any difference.

One concern could be where it is going to live. If it is on a thick soft carpet with a fluffy pad under, it could be tippy on that account. If so, perhaps 4 of the adjustable spikes found on most better Hi-Fi speakers would give the box a firm anchor to the floor.

------WebKitFormBoundaryjIZsaYXWwmeSr+3g

Re: End table design: Too "tippy"?

#3

Re: End table design: Too "tippy"?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Dan,

It's not tippy.

Draw a line from the lower right corner of the base diagonally to the upper left corner of the cabinet. If the cabinet weight is symmetrical around the diagonal*, and making some reasonable assumptions to simplify the calculation, the cabinet will tip over when that diagonal is vertical.

arctan of tip angle = 13 / 23

tip angle is approximately 30 degrees.

* I think symmetrical weight distribution is a reasonable assumption for the form you are making. If the cabinet is top-heavy this is not a good assumption. For a silly example, if the cabinet top is made of mdf and the rest is made of a light wood like pine, the cabinet will tip over at a smaller angle.

Re: End table design: Too "tippy"?

#4

Thanks for the helpful replies

Dan Mitchell

>The tables will be on carpet, but nothing unusual in terms of depth/softness.

I didn't really think tipping was an issue with the proportions, but hey, since I ALREADY spill enough drinks, I wanted to make sure ;-)

Dan

Re: End table design: Too "tippy"?

#5

Gravity is at its best with MDF.

Bricofleur

>Since MDF is quite heavy, your tables shouldn't be tippy. I would certainly trust the natural gravity. I made several pieces with MDF and gravity is at the "Rendez-vous", everytime.

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com

Re: End table design: Too "tippy"?

#6

Ellis Walentine

A tip for you

Ellis Walentine

>Couldn't resist. Seriously, it would take some serious leverage to tip that table, as Ed so eloquently explained. The tip I have for you is to consider laying a fillet of hardwood into the corners of the main veneered part of the table. I'd do the vertical edges first, square them off and then do the four edges of the top. It is quite demanding to get a perfect veneer corner, especially with the 1/42" or so veneer they're selling nowadays. Even if you get them right, they are too sharp for your own good, and the first vacuum cleaner ding or other assault will mess it up for you. If you lay in a 1/4" x 1/4" fillet into those edges, you can round them over to yield a nice smooth and resilient edge.

Ellis

Re: End table design: Too "tippy"?

#7

You've been taking lessons from George...

Dan Mitchell

>in the pun category ;-)

Thanks for the tip, Ellis. I'm having a bit of trouble visualizing what you mean. To clarify, do you mean cutting a 1/4 x 1/4 groove on the outer edge of each piece of MDF, and gluing a hardwood strip into the edge, then applying the veneer over this, so as to provide a firmer substrate than the MDF would provide, or do you mean applying the strip & stopping the veneer 1/4" inboard, up to the strip, allowing the strip to form the edge?

Up to this point I have only done a bit of veneering, and that was a couple small pieces using veneer I had cut on the bandsaw, ~ 1/16" thick, not the commercially available variety.

Thanks,

Dan