Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

How Decay resistant is Poplar

Posts

How Decay resistant is Poplar

#1

How Decay resistant is Poplar

Barry Irby

>Compared to Ponderosa Pine is poplar more or less decay resistant?

I am repairing an Exterior door made of Ponderosa Pine. Would poplar be suitable? I have some is the reason I am asking.

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#2

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>It'll not rot unless it gets wet. Then it'll rot rapidly. I wouldn't want to use it in an exposed exterior door.

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

Jesper, Denmark

>Not!

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#4

depends on where it is from

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The dark green heartwood was commonly used around here for window and door frames. Even exposed it seems to last in the old cabins in these parts. On the other hand, the sap wood seems to be the least decay resistant of anything I have seen. If there is a way for it to get wet it seems to stay wet and rot at miles per hour.

I have painted poplar trim. The bulk of the boards are fine. But where ever there was a scarf joint in sap wood water has entered and that area rotted in about 10 years.

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#5

Re: depends on where it is from

Fred Davis

>We used Feather River doors out of Oroville ,California in million and up homes in the BlackHawk section of Danville, and they used Poplar exclusively for paint grade interior, I never saw a exterior door from them in Poplar.

On the other hand on a knockoff of Terra , the southern mansion in Gone with the wind, they came out with a double entry set of 4/0 doors laminated with six layers of 3/8ths exterior plywood and banded with solid wood and we didn't know it until we bored the lockset.

I have wondered over the years how they held up.

FredD

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#6

It'll rot before your eyes

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>A standing dead poplar is like a smorgasbord to a pileated, full of all kinds of tasty bugs and worms.

Clint

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#7

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I agree with Bill. Depends on whether it is sapwood or heartwood. We live in a log cabin that was originally built in 1814. These poplar logs have been around a long time.

If the door is located where it will stay dry, poplar should work. If it will be damp a lot, you should probably choose a different wood.

Gary

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#8

Thanks Guys, went with heart Pine.

Barry Irby

>

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#9

Now I'll add my 2 cents.

Basil

>An old mountaineer once told me that poplar siding would last for a hundred years with no paint. The stipulation was that it had to be put on vertically (depot style) and not let it touch the ground. He said poplar was like red cedar in that the top layer of cells will absorb the first few drops of rain, swell and seal the surface against any further penetration by the rain.

I know for a fact that they'll only last about 3 years as floorboards on a deck.......if you're real skinny.

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#10

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

Howard Acheson

>Both Poplar and Pine is rated by the Wood Handbook from the Forest Products Lab as "slight to no resistance" to rot.

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#11

Ellis Walentine

I've taken down a couple old barns...

Ellis Walentine

>... that had poplar siding -- nice 16' rough 1 x 12s, vertical, as Basil mentioned -- and they were beautifully silver in color and just slilghtly rounded at the edges from 100+ years of full exposure. The only place where they were rotted was where moisture had been able to pool up and sit there. As long as the boards were well drained, they aged very nicely.

Ellis

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#12

Our Old Farm House

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Used wide Tulip Poplar boards in the way that plywood is used today. It was a full 1" thick and didn't have a bad spot anywhere...BUT it didn't tough the ground.

We dismantled a house that was built before the Revolutionary War (it had fallen down). The Tulip Poplar floor joist are now being used in our house.

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

#13

Re: How Decay resistant is Poplar

Greg Young

>Don't even think about it!