Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

Posts

How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

#1

How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

Pete in NVa

>I was asked to build a replacement for an exterior tongue and groove bulkhead door - the kind that lies on a sloped wooden frame and used to be common for exterior basement entry. I copied the design of its predecessor, using 1x6 pine T&G boards screwed to a 1x4 pine Z frame. I also edge glued the T&G boards, based on a "how-to" article I read in Fine Homebuilding. Overall door dimension was 37 wide x 57 long. Painted the whole thing and installed it with hinges on one side. It looked fine on installation.

After 1 month, the T&G bords buckled, stripping out from its screws, and the door width had expanded considerably. It was clearly a moisture induced problem. I hadn't allowed much room for expansion, thinking that the Z frame screws would contain movement, since no other example I had seen had made any allowance for movement, e.g. expansion slots for screws. I was clearly wrong.

But I still don't know how the old timers did it. If you don't edge glue the T&G boards and try to leave expansion room in all the grooves, the door will leak in the rain. If you screw the boards to the Z frame, as I did, they will bust out the screws with moisture changes. Yet I've never seen a single installation where expansion slots in the Z frame were used to accommodate wood movement.

If any of you have built a door like this, I'd appreciate any tips. Certainly, using a more stable wood, like cedar, would help, but I don't think that's the whole story. I could epoxy the T&G boards to the Z frame, but I fear that might cause the door to rip itself apart from the stresses of moisture change. What am I missing, short of going to a metal bulkhead?

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

#2

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

mike mcnerney

>I would imagine a door like this would always leak around the perimeter even if you got the t & g selaed perfectly which is a trick in itself. I would guess the woods moisture content will vary a lot. So I would paint all the boards thoroughly including the tongues & grooves so enlarge or reduce said t & g so they will fit. Assemble with a 1/8" or more, expansion allowance, for each board.

Then after assembly I would try something more flexible like silicone or even a good quality exterior caulk. I think you also have to make your Z boards with slotted screw opening 3/8" or wider & maybe round head screws with washers even if the oldtimers didn't. I have made a normal exterior door with this design (no Z boards) as a frame and panel door. That is, a 2 x 5 frame with full mortise & tenon joints & the panel is the t & g with a gap, pre finished & caulked after.

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

#3

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>The article you mention is in FHB #173. The author used West system epoxy to edge-glue T & G cedar and to glue the T & G cedar to the Z-frame. He then finished both sides of the doors.

There are two questions in your post. First question, why did your door expand while apparently the FHB door did not. Second question, how were these doors constructed traditionally.

The FHB author used cedar. Door dimensions are not given but a photo shows a double door, each approximately 20 to 24 inches wide. You used pine which might have approximately 50% more dimension change than cedar. If your bulkhead door is a single door it might be twice the width of the FHB door. Moisture content of the wood in the two installations is unknown. Dry wood would expand, of course, causing the problem you describe. Wet wood would contract and perhaps split. So, you might experience as much as triple (2 x 1.5) the wood movement of the FHB door!

Regarding traditional construction methods, I�m guessing a cheap door would have been nailed together, clenched from the back, no glue. For best weatherproofing I�d paint everything before assembly. It might leak a drop or two but nothing serious. I once owned a home with a cedar shingle roof. You could stand in the attic and see the sky through the gaps in the shingles. Yet, it didn�t leak! According to my old Audels carpenters� guide, the best garage doors were constructed of double or triple layers of T & G but the weight might be too much for a bulkhead door.

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

#4

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>If decor is a dominant consideration you will be stuck with the troublesome T&G

If function is the goal, why not go with exterior plywood panels?

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

#5

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

Pete in NVa

>I re-read the FHB article and found that each of the 2 doors was 28" wide. Given cedar's properties, and assuming a reasonable seasonal moisture content change of 15 percentage points, I calculate each door would move about 5/8". The author says that he edge glued the T&G boards and then glued and screwed them to 4-sided frames with a diagonal member in each (all 1 x stock). His strategy apparently was to resist T&G movement with the strength of the frame. But a 5/8" dimensional change seems to me to be very difficult to contain, even with such a formidable frame. I certainly wouldn't try it for my 37" door, which even if made of cedar, would try to move more than 3/4". (1 1/4" for my current pine version, which explains why it buckled.)

I'm leaning now towards remaking the door with T&G cedar, not edge gluing the boards but leaving expansion room in each groove. The boards would be finished on all sides, although I'm not sure yet whether to use stain or paint. They would be screwed to a Z frame at positions that didn't interfere with individual board motion. The price I'll pay for this is the possibility of leakage through the joints, but your experience with cedar T&G gives me hope. Many thanks for your comments.

Re: How To Build A T&G Bulkhead Door?

#6

Second thoughts

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>In my earlier post I wrote that I would prepaint everything before assembly but the roof shingles I mentioned were naturally unpainted. Paint would slow down the swelling process. I think it best NOT to paint the T & G joint.

Good luck with your next attempt. If the unglued T & G cedar leaks unacceptably, a small batten on each joint should fix it.