OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits
wilbur
>Back in mid-March, my wife was making a left hand turn at an intersection when another car ran a red light and clipped the front corner of our car. Luckily, there were no injuries. She called the police, and a policeman came and filed a report, gave the other driver a ticket, and took a statement from a witness attesting to all of the above. The other driver paid the ticket, which counts as pleading guilty to the violation.
We filed a claim with the other driver's insurance company, Encompass, for the repair. Encompass told us that they needed to do their own appraisal and investigation. They took their sweet time with their investigation. They claimed at one point that their client wrote a letter saying that she did not run a red light. We went to the town courthouse and provided them with a copy of the paid receipt for the ticket. The insurance company finally made us an offer to cover 95% of the damages, since they determined that my wife was 5% liable for the accident, since she did not "take evasive action" when the accident happened.
We rejected that offer, since our position was that the other driver was totally responsible for the accident, and two weeks ago filed an appeal within the company, which was the next step. We were told that we would receive a reply within 10 working days. Today at work I gave them a call to see what was going on, since it had been longer than the 10 business days. I was told that we lost the appeal, and that three managers had determined that my wife should have been able to take evasive action. Also, she should have been paying more attention to the traffic, and not the color of the traffic light. Therefore, we were still liable for 5% of the accident, and 5% of the cost of the repair.
I asked if all the internal appeal processes had been exhausted, which they had been. I then asked what other recourse we had. I was told I could file a complaint with the NJ Department of Banking and Insurance.
I then asked them, "So, how do I go about taking Encompass to small claims court?"
One hour later, my wife got a call at home that they were cutting a check for the entire cost of the repair.



