Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Posts

OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#1

OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

wilbur

>Back in mid-March, my wife was making a left hand turn at an intersection when another car ran a red light and clipped the front corner of our car. Luckily, there were no injuries. She called the police, and a policeman came and filed a report, gave the other driver a ticket, and took a statement from a witness attesting to all of the above. The other driver paid the ticket, which counts as pleading guilty to the violation.

We filed a claim with the other driver's insurance company, Encompass, for the repair. Encompass told us that they needed to do their own appraisal and investigation. They took their sweet time with their investigation. They claimed at one point that their client wrote a letter saying that she did not run a red light. We went to the town courthouse and provided them with a copy of the paid receipt for the ticket. The insurance company finally made us an offer to cover 95% of the damages, since they determined that my wife was 5% liable for the accident, since she did not "take evasive action" when the accident happened.

We rejected that offer, since our position was that the other driver was totally responsible for the accident, and two weeks ago filed an appeal within the company, which was the next step. We were told that we would receive a reply within 10 working days. Today at work I gave them a call to see what was going on, since it had been longer than the 10 business days. I was told that we lost the appeal, and that three managers had determined that my wife should have been able to take evasive action. Also, she should have been paying more attention to the traffic, and not the color of the traffic light. Therefore, we were still liable for 5% of the accident, and 5% of the cost of the repair.

I asked if all the internal appeal processes had been exhausted, which they had been. I then asked what other recourse we had. I was told I could file a complaint with the NJ Department of Banking and Insurance.

I then asked them, "So, how do I go about taking Encompass to small claims court?"

One hour later, my wife got a call at home that they were cutting a check for the entire cost of the repair.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#2

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

mdclor

>I am glad that your wife wasn't hurt.

This type of thing really gets me irritated. Maybe I just had a bad day at work, but I would still file a complaint with the Insurance department. They put through extra effort and aggravation just to get your out of pocket expense covered, so I would return the favor by giving them a little aggravation if at all possible.

Rant mode off, I feel better now.

Merle

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#3

Re: I'd go farther

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>Once their check clears, I'd ask my attorney to write them a letter demanding whatever sum the repair claim amounted to as an extra payment owed to cover your "pain and suffering" for what they put you through.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Had a problem similar to yours...

Dale Lenz

>once. Called my insurance company, Allstate. Allstate sicked their dogs on the Other co. Go paid and all is well.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#5

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Fred Davis

>So, are you still using Encompass??

FredD

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#6

Re: Had a problem similar to yours...

wilbur

>Actually, Encompass, the other driver's insurance company, is a subsidiary of Allstate.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#7

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

wilbur

>Encompass was the other driver's insurance.

We use State Farm.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#8

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>What I don't understand is why you didn't have State Farm do all of this stuff for you. That's what you pay them for. And they know about your non-chargeable accident anyway.

There's no way one insurance company plays this crap with another one.

Addy protocol: My father was a State Farm agent for 34 years, now retired 18 years.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#9

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Fred Davis

>my thought also , we use State Farm for everything , home , rentals, vehicles, horses and if that happend to us , State farm would get the call, take our statement , check the accident report on file with the police and that would be the end of it.

FredD

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#10

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

wilbur

>You know, with all the friends and people involved that we talked to, filing the claim with our insurance and letting them deal with it is the one option that never was suggested. Besides, I'm under the impression that we would be responsible for our deductible, but maybe that doesn't apply in this case.

I'll definitely keep this in mind should we ever be in this situation again, but I also hope we never have to deal with this again.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#11

Dale Lenz

Re: The point...

Dale Lenz

>I was trying to get across was: Next time you might try to see if Your insurance company would go to bat for you.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>The point is that State Farm should have done the haggling with Encompass in your stead. AND, not a dime should have been paid from State Farm to you, nor you to them.

Insurance companies try to save money wherever they can. If they could have gotten away with keeping the 5%, that would have saved them money. Getting lawyers into the game would have cost them money on such a small claim, which is why they conceded in the end.

However, they probably made some interest income on the claim by drawing out the process and not paying you promptly.

Jason

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#13

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Kirk (KC) Constable

>I also have State Farm (for whatever that's worth), and got hit in a parking lot by a guy with 'no name' insurance. I tried for a couple weeks to get the 'no name' people out there to appraise the damage. When LOML got tired of listening to me whine, she called the 'no name' company and asked for the phone number of the insurance commissioner. It MIGHT'VE been 30 minutes before the phone rang. :-)

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#14

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Philip Berman (Montville, NJ)

>Here in NJ, they call it 'no-fault' but in reality it's 'everyone at-fault'. They try and pin at least part of the blame on anyone/everyone involved. It's also the nature of insurance companies to minimize their payouts, so consumers have to speak up when they've been done wrong. I was at a red light when a guy in an SUV made a left turn, cut it too close and hit me head-on. He was also traveling at what was estimated to be 40mph. The insurance co. tried to lay 10% blame on me. I pointed out that I wasn't moving, and at 40mph had no time to react nor any place to go if I did have time to react, and I too had to threaten a lawsuit. Eventually they paid my insurance company, who also was the other guys' insurance company!!!!! And then we wonder why NJ has the highest insurance premiums in the nation.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#15

Re: Had a problem similar to yours...

Charlie Self

>Something like 35-40 years ago, a guy rearended my mother's car at a stop sign. Allstate was the other driver's insurer. The guy got and paid a ticket. Allstate took so long to process the claim that rain got in around the trunk lid and rusted out the floor of the trunk--this was a '66 Barracuda fastback, so no partial fix was possible.

Allstate ended up paying about four times the original claim costs, but you really have to get mean to get results.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#16

Insurance companies are just plain sleazy...

John in NM

>Not the individual agents who have to deal with you face to face, the anonymous managers who make fairly arbitrary decisions that conveniently save them money, then fold when threatened with a situation where they know they'll lose.

We had a very similar event - but in a parking lot. Private property, thus no police, no ticket. Other driver was 100% at fault, would have been ticketed if it happened on a city street. Sparing you the long drawn out story, the other driver and their insurer, Metlife, effectively stonewalled because there was no accident report. They both knew they could get away with it and they did.

Its all about their profit, not about honoring their contracts. I'm sure we would have gotten the "partial fault" line too if it had gotten that far. As far as I know, there is no traffic law that requires drivers to take evasive action when they have the right of way and another driver is failing to yield. That would just make the whole situation more dangerous and potentially involve other vehicles or perhaps pedestrians.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#17

Ooops! Forgot to say...

John in NM

>I'm glad it worked out better for you Wilbur!

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#18

Not exactly true IMO

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>



The point is that State Farm should have done the haggling with Encompass in your stead. AND, not a dime should have been paid from State Farm to you, nor you to them.

Maybe it's different in Indiana, but it works differently in Illinois. Case in point: I was rear-ended on my motorcycle by a young lady driving her boyfriend's rental car. She was not authorized to be driving the car and did not have insurance. Police filed a report clearly indicating the other driver at fault. I contacted my State Farm agent and he said go ahead and have the bike repaired. They would cover the repair, minus the deductible and go after either the rental car insurance or the guy's company insurance. State law here requires that any money recovered by State Farm has to first go toward reimbursing the customer's deductible, and then covering their own expense.

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#19

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Wilbur,

My wife was rearended and her car was totaled. Our insurance company at the time wanted to settle early and cheap. We hired an attorney to go after our insurance company for what we thought was the right compensation. Our insurance company ended up paying us and our attorney four times what they could have paid if they had made a fair offer instead of trying to cheat us. We ended up with the wrecked car being paid off, a brand new car plus all expenses paid plus a good deal more for pain and suffering. My wife suffered a broken toe and whiplash. We have no idea or even care if out insurance company collected from the insuror of the other driver.

ALL insurance companies are down right dispictable! They all operate under the same rules....pay as little as they can get away with. When you get your attorney in the loop, they start to listen. Insurance companies don't do well in front of a jury.

Marv

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#20

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Good onya.

Up here we have state-owner insurance (ICBC) and they've recently been discovered to have been snooping into the claim history of jurors involved in other claims related lawsuits. So far they've found three instances of it. Our privacy commissioner is now going back through all such lawsuits back to 1993 to see if there's other occurrences.

This is the same company that recently got busted for having a rougue "training center". Seems they'd get written off cars inot the facility, "learn" how to rebuild them using ICBC labour and $$ for parts, fake the paperwork and put the rebuilt cars back on the road, either as their own, or to sell for personal profit.

Me thinks that for this company there's change in the wind - BIG change!

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#21

And Then

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There's the instance where a woman waiting in a toll booth line in New York City gets rear-ended by an elderly priest who was trying to get his wallet out. There happened to be a patrol car in full view, and the Irish cop immediately goes to the first car saying, "Now, don't you be a bit worried, miss. We were right there, saw i'tall, and we'll be takin' care o' this bozo straight away." Cop then goes to the second car only to find that the driver is, in fact, his very own parish priest. Paddy takes a look at the documents, takes a few measurments, goes back to speak to the woman, and finally comes back to the priest and asks, "Sure'n, Fahder, would ya have any idea 'bout how fahst she was goin' when she backed into ya?"

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#22

Re: OT - Not everyone's experience

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>While you may have had such a problem, we haven't. And neither have many of our friends.

I don't shop price, yet I don't pay much, either. Service and a personal touch counts for a lot. An unaccompanied 800 number is small comfort when there is a problem...

Re: OT - The usefulness of frivolous lawsuits

#23

I had kind of the opposite experience once

Henry Higginbotham

>Ten or 12 years ago, I was headed back to work from lunch. A 16-year-old coming toward me in his recently deceased grandfather's car made some sort of wild, sweeping left turn, barely missed one other car, and t-boned my '87 Prelude. Not much to argue--witnesses and all that. We both had State Farm.

I'd bought the car for $3300, replaced a front axle, and driven it maybe 45k miles. State Farm's adjuster called me a week or so later and started out by explaining that they'd decided to total my car, but as the car had well above-average miles and a torn seat, they were going to have to take off around a thousand dollars from book value.

Here it comes, I thought: I'm about to get $900 for my car. But the adjuster continued, " ... which bring it to $5050." I told her I thought I could replace the car for, uh, a bit less than that. She said she already had the check there in the file, and it would be simpler for me to just take it.

My arm CAN be twisted.