A Question on Compressor Explosion
HC Sakman --- Victoria,BC. CANADA
>Hi Everybody,
Anybody here ever heard of exploding air compressor(s)?
TIA,
Chico...
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
A Question on Compressor Explosion
HC Sakman --- Victoria,BC. CANADA
>Hi Everybody,
Anybody here ever heard of exploding air compressor(s)?
TIA,
Chico...
Re: A Question on Compressor Explosion
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.
>Yes-- a big one exploded at a company I worked at in the early 80's. Luckily it was in a room at the rear of the building. Did set off the fire sprinklers because of the smoke from the oil. Not sure if the tank or the compressor itself exploded.
Re: A Question on Compressor Explosion
JL
>I was working at a plant in the late 70s. The tank went and split at the weld lines near the end. Blew the end right off. It was in a concrete containment area so there was no real damage except to that area. The compressor was history (as was all of the hardware).
Which Type?
Dustmaker Mike
>I watched a show on DIY called Deconstruction. They took a nail gun compressor and tossed it off a three story high building onto a bed of spikes and blocks. It just let the air out. I am not sure of the big one but the little ones are made to just release the air. In the same show the busted off the neck and it did the same just let the air out. That is my story and I am sticking to it.
Really what kind would help in finding out the truth.
Re: A Question on Compressor Explosion
Dale Stansbery
>Yes, that's why they install a safety pressure relief valve, in case the pressure switch doesn't turn off the compressor when the pressure reaches the preset level.
Re: There's a reason
Glenn Madsen near San Francisco
>The compressors for shops, large enough to be a big problem, are set to be out of the way, and behind walls. It's caution, but not an excess of caution.
Does it happen often? No. Does it happen? Yes. That's why there are safety rules as to how these things are plumbed. And it's why there are drain plugs on the bottom, so the condensate can be evacuated, and not rust out the tank.
Re: A Question on Compressor Explosion
GalenV in Iowa
>We provided compressor as a part of some water treatment equipment packages for over 50 years and I do not recall in the 39 years I was there that a compressor exploded. Some really old units may have broken a rod and in turn split the head but no explosions. Only leaks in rusty receivers and no tank explosions.
Compressor Magazine put out by Ingersoll Rand would cover some failures of compeditors units and how they saved the day but right now do not recall of major explosions. You may be able to still get to their old issues on line but I think they dropped publication maybe 5 years ago or at least I just did not get them.
Now explosion of 12 inch pvc low pressure air pipe did happen in Florida water plant when they painted down the big pressure relief valve bonnet that was to be set at 6 psi. Like a bomb going off and sharp pieces of PVC went flying. Nobody hurt.
Galen
Re: A Question on Compressor Explosion
Chuck in ND
>I've never seen one explode, but finding a experienced welder to repair a leaky tank because of a cracked weld is next to impossible, that tells me the liability is too high. Why do you ask this question ?
Tank or compressor?
GolfSteve in Calgary
>Tanks rarely blow up because they are designed to very high ASME standards. When failure does occur it is usually just a leak caused by corrosion. If you're smart you will then throw the tank away and not JB weld up the pinhole. This does not mean that tanks do not blow up - they can - but it is now rare due to appropriate government regulation and improved engineering knowledge.
Anything on an industrial site will receive regular inspection by the local pressure vessel regulator and anything old will require periodic non-destructive testing (e.g. wall thickness measurements). We have a 25 hp air compressor at work feeding into a WWII era, riveted construction, air receiver that is still in service. The steel on the tank must be 1" thick.
I've heard of (and seen one) air compressors that blow up for a variey of reasons - such as water in the intake. I saw the results of water entering a compressor - a 2' diameter piston head was blown 100 feet across a refinery where it dented the naphtha hydrotreater reactor (with 3" thick steel walls). No fires, no explosions, no people flattened; the company just had to buy everyone new underwear.
I've also heard of massive air compressor failure on in-situ combustion projects, with very high compression requirements, where the lube oil reaches an unpredicted auto-ignition temperature and the compressor rapidly deconstructed itself. :-) oops
Thanks again. The unit in question is......
HC Sakman --- Victoria,BC. CANADA
>Eagle brand 18.5cfm 3 piston, 5hp upright 60 Gallon tank compressor which most often runs my ROS and occasional pinner.
My neighbor is concerned explosion possibility (after 3 years) because her kids' rooms are 15' away from the shed (well insulated) that the compressor is in.
I don't think I push this thing to its limits and it's only 3 years old, though its pressure gauge on the tank is not working (kinda stuck, it moves when I hit it with my finger tip) but other than that no problems.
Thanks again for your responses.
Chico...
Thank you all.
Re: Thanks again. The unit in question is......
GalenV in Iowa
>You could tell your neighbor the air tank is built and stamped to ASME code and there are fewer cases of the air receivers exploding than the hot water heater tank in their own home. Ask them how old their hot water heater is and how often they have it tested.
Your tank has a safety valve just like I hope their hot water heater does. Their valve has a better chance of sticking than your air tanks valve. Let's hope neither tank ever is a problem.
I would replace the pressure gauge just so you can insure that the pressure switch is set and stays right on. I always cycle the relief valve too to insure it is not froze.
Are you just using your ocmpressor late into the night and the noise is the problem? Must be something setting them off.
Galen- normally just called the Grump.
With any luck
Bill Howatt
>your neighbour has a gas stove, furnace or whatever.
Many, many, more people have been turned into astronauts from gas leaks than air compressor failures.
Bill
It will explode Chico!
Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level
>I can assure you that compressor is capable of exploding. And I can prove it. I'll need your assisatnce first. Is there a way you can get your hands on any sticks of dynamite? I'd say 5 or 6 ought to do it. Well need some fuse too. Once you get those items, e-mail me and I'll walk you through the rest.
Tommy
I agree
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>The ASME stamp on the side of the tank insures they design is adequate as long as no alterations have been made. I would lift the pressure relief, safety valve, by hand to make sure it isn't stuck and continue using it. I would also make an effort to get a replacement gauge, they don't cost all that much for 0-100 pound types where you don't need precision.
As others have stated, furnaces and hot water heaters pose a much greater risk of bad things happening. Is her hot water heater located under a closet like code requires??
Lee
Thx. I'd expect nothing less from you Tommy
HC Sakman --- Victoria,BC. CANADA
>
Re: Thanks again. The unit in question is......
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada
>I that the same neighbour who you blow your cyclone dust onto across that fence?
:-)
They called....,,,,you'll be hearing from their lawyers this week...
:-)
Jim
Re: Me...Think the bottom line....
Dale Lenz
>is: are you in a commercial zone? With neighbors 15' away, I'd guess not. I'd satisfy the lady: move the AC, put 1/2" steel plate on neighbor's side of inside wall if need be, she could shut your shop down. Need to keep this low key.
Good luck
Re: Me...Think the bottom line....
Chuck in ND
>Yep you gotta watchout for those Lenz's, it's all about satisfyin the lady. (-;
Re: Just...
Dale Lenz
>passed our 30th wedding anniversary, yesterday. Took the Mrs. to Red Lobster, she seemed happy! Probably should of taken her on a cruise, but let's not go there, : ' >.
Re: Congrats Dale
Chuck in ND
>It will be 28 GLORIOUS years for us June 1st.
The problem is . . . .
Pete in Holland, MI
>That most all compressor tanks, ASME rated or not, are pressure tested at the factory. New ones rarely blow up. It's the older ones that do. Age is not necessarily the factor. Care & maintenance to the tank is. Keep the water out of it. That is the biggest contributor to tank rupturing, as it causes rust & thins the metal.
In the field of steam boilers, the boiler has to be hydrostatically tested on a regular basis, in a controlled enviroment, to a pressure greater than the maximum operating pressure. Steel rusts and thus, gets thinner over time. Most people, businesses and governments don't require testing of these non-heated pressure vessels. Thus, unless they are properly & regularly tested by the owner, it will some day blow up.
Hopefully for all of us compressor owners that don't test tanks, if some day, you see a leak of air or water coming from your tank, shut it down & bleed it immediately! Your tank is shot. Time for a new tank or new compressor. Any use after this leak develops, or continued use, puts you and anyone nearby at risk.
Pete
Re: Tank or compressor?
Tom MacGregor
>I found a hairline crack developing in an old compressor tank two days after the State Pressure Vessel Inspector tagged it as in compliance. There is no substitute for knowing and regularly inspecting your own equipment.
Re: A Question on Compressor Explosion
Dave Paine
>I have not heard of an explosion, but I expect this has happened to some units at some time.
If the tank has a "U" stamp, it means the vessel complies with the ASME code for vessels which operate at pressures greater than 15 psig.
Some air compressors units can be sold with tanks which are not "U" stamp rated, due to small volumes.
A "U" stamp does not mean the tank will last forever, it just means it is designed to the present ASME code, and certified as such.
Every pressure vessel is designed for a finite number of pressure/depressure cycles. If the vessel experiences more cycles than designed, then a failure can occur. This does not mean explosion, but that some aspect of the vessel may fail. Depending on the failure, this may be more, or less, "explosive".
I expect that in a normal home or business environment, a "U" stamped vessel is not likely to fail.
Now if the vessel has excessive condensation which is not drained, then an early failure due to corrosion may occur.
If the vessel is drained regularly, then it should provide long years of service.
I have a 60 gallon tank on my compressor, which is rated for 135 psig. I drain the tank every few months. This is for personal use, so does not get a lot of use. Mostly blowing dust before finishing, or filling car/machine tyres.
Keeping It Dry *LINK*
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>As several in this thread have noted, the key to a long tank life is keeping it drained. This also benefits the user in that you get cleaner/dryer air to use. Most, however, do not remember to drain the accumulated condensate nearly often enough. This is where a small investment can bring big benefits.
The link is to an air-activated condensate drain sold by McMaster-Carr and others. Made by Wilkerson, the X51 automatically drains water from your tank every time the pressure varies by more than 10psi. It works down to 35�F. The McMaster item # is 4919K13 and price is $50. That translates to at least 1 drain function for each pressure/depressure cycle
Mine has been mounted for 7 years without a hitch. Once a year I take it apart to clean and check it.
Drain
PS:
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Forgot to mention that even after this period of time, the condensate that gets exhausted is still clear with only a slight bit of oil residue and no rust color or flakes. The valve is connected to the original bottom tank drain (old petcock removed, of course) with 3/8" brass pipe. The 12" of pipe needed to bring the valve out clear of the tank acts as a mini reservoir for condensate so the water doesn't sit in the bottom of the steel tank and start rust.