Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT lawn tractor

Posts

OT lawn tractor

#1

OT lawn tractor

Claudia Hayward

>This is the only place I can get honest opinions! I need to buy a new lawn tractor, my old Husquevarna is done. I've got an acre of grass and I live in the Pacific northwest (wet grass!) Need to keep the price down around $2k and I want a 42" deck. Don't need a bagger or any other attachments other than mulching capability. What would you suggest? Craftsman? Don't really want another Husky..love their chainsaw but not crazy about their lawn tractor.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT lawn tractor

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>In your price range, I've had really good service from my John Deere. I've had mine for about five years, and it has been very reliable, needing only the routine service.

I mow 1� acres with it, and often use it to pull a small trailer of mulch or soil.

In the winter, I plow my 150' driveway with it. I do keep it in a heated garage during the winter, and it stays, covered, in the barn during the Summer months.

All that said, if I'd had a few (a lot, actually) more bucks to spend, I'd have gotten a Kubota, with a diesel engine. Thay're a much beefier tractor than the JD.

Jim D.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#3

LOL ! . . .

steve mackay

>Don't even have one and don't know the prices but my dream has always been TO need one and it would be a Deere. Funny eh ?

Re: OT lawn tractor

#4

Re: OT lawn tractor

Gene Gauss

>I've had two Craftsman mowers. Ran the first (12 HP, 42") from 1968 'til 1996 and finally gave up on trying to keep the Tecumseh engine running. Bought a 14 HP, 42 inch then and have been running it ever since, mowing about three acres of ground that isn't very smooth. It has taken a fair amount of repair to accommodate some abusive treatment, but on a well maintained 1 acre suburban lot, ought to be ok, and quite a lot less expensive than the John Deere.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#5

Not a DEERE!

RobV

>The low-end John Deere models, those that sell for under $3,500 are not manufactured by Deere, but are rebranded models made by either MTD/Yard Machine. Now, that doesn't mean it won't do the job and last a long time, but this is one case where shopping purely by brand doesn't mean anything... anymore.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#6

Re: OT lawn tractor

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>Look in your neighborhood for a lawn tractor store with service that has been in business a dozen or more years. Anything under two grand is going to require some extra maintenance to keep running after the fourth or fifth season.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#7

Re: OT lawn tractor

GalenV in Iowa

>May make a difference if your land is flat or hills for size of tractor/ridding mower.

First old mower was a John Deere gear drive 12 hp B&S 42" deck ridding mower and just below the garden tractor versions at the time.

Ran for many years on a good 40 degree slope hill lot of 1 acre. This was not even pressure lub so surprised me I got many years of life.

For wet heavy grass never get a mower with high lift blades as they take more power and will load the deck with wet grass.

The Cub Cadet Hydro transmission unit I got later had a B&S twin and the worst thing was to apply the brake it shifted drive through neutral. On the hill I had it could run away with you and the tiny disc brake could not hold the tractor. Wild rides down the hill so never get out of low speed range and hope you never need to brake on a hill. I hope they do not make that type of drive/brake pedel system anymore.

Depending on your need look at if the unit has turf tire as they can be good on flat wet grass but like greese on a hill.

I had to defeat the seat safety switch as going down hill my weight shifted to feet and off seat and it wanted to cut out. Not a real good idea but could not find a better way to keep it from cutting out.

Old info but some things may not have changed.

Galen----------I mow no more!

Re: OT lawn tractor

#8

Re: OT lawn tractor

Fred Davis

>Like Jim , I have a John Deere, nine years old and still going like new.

Had the good fortune to have a classmate that owned the John Deere dealership in Abilene and he pointed out things I wouldn't noticed like a much heavier frame then most ,a Hydrostatic drive,etc.

The seat is the most comfortable of any riding mower I have owned.

Like Jim I mow a lot of grass , this time of the year it hardly cools off , keep it shedded and serviced and it will outlast me .

I don't abuse it with snow removal, that's the Bobcat's job ;-))

FredD

Re: OT lawn tractor

#9

JL

Re: OT lawn tractor

JL

>I picked up a nice older model John Deere by going into the dealership. I got a very substantial lawn tractor for a reasonable price. It may be 10 years old, but it was well maintained and they serviced the tractor before they delivered it to me.

I would look at the used tractors. You can get a reasonable price for a sturdier machine.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#10

Re: It's just a lawnmower for crying out loud....!

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>For reliability and longevity, go for a simplicity or john deer from a real JD dealer (not Home Depot version). If sevicing and maintaining small gas engine equipment is not your thing, then find a local dealer who has a good reputation and purchase from him, new or used, doesn't matter. While you may pay what seems like a premium up front from a local dealer as compared to online or Home Depot etc, what that premuim will provide is a source of reliable service for your machine for the next 20 years or so, which is how long one of these machines should last. If on the other hand you are not averse to servicing and maintianing this sort of equipment yourself, then, "It's just a lawnmower" buy one that fits your cost/features requirements and if it is not a Simplicity or John Deer, pay close attention to engine and chassis running gear maintenance and you will be fine, I don't know yet if it will go 20 years, only time will tell.

Bob in NJ who decided that 3500+ bucks to replace my 20 year old simplicity was too much and is now on maybe year 4? for a Home depot John Deer and have had no problems, but then I like to tinker with this stuff, and decided that the 1500 bucks saved would pay for parts if the HD mower turned out to be a mistake, so far the gamble has payed off....

Re: OT lawn tractor

#11

Re: Cutting wet grass ?

Chuck in ND

>Cutting wet grass just seems like a bad idea to me, and then to mulch wet grass ? I would think that would be hard on ANY mower.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#12

PNW you mow in the rain

Dustmaker Mike

>if you didn't you would not mow from Sept till June. Kind of long to let the grass grow.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#13

When I lived out there

Dustmaker Mike

>I had two Craftsman LT 1000 models. I paid for one and got the other for free from the Sears repair center (it had fallen off a truck). Both worked great. I owned about 3/4 acre on a hill the mower I bought did the mowing and bagging. The one I got for free was put to the task of pushing stuff with a 4'push blade on it. I kept the oil changed and fixed the parts that had broken when it fell off the truck and never had a problem with them. I sold them both a few years ago because I didn't need them any more and the person who owns them now is using them. They are 8 years old and counting. The only thing if any to complain about is if you need parts you have to go to Sears to get them. But Sears is every where for now.

I did buy a Borg store JD last year because I bought a house with a bigger lawn. I could not beat the price at Sears or I would have bought another one.

I would recommend either one.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#14

Re: Perhaps a reel type mower is the answer

Chuck in ND

>Like whats used at golf courses.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#15

Simplicity

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>We love our simplicity mower. I'm not sure if you can keep in your price range you are looking at with a 42" cut though.

Otherwise one of these has at least a 42" cut.....

Lee


img

Re: OT lawn tractor

#16

Another vote for Deere

Frank Orfanello

>I too have a Deere. I cut about 1.5 acres and have had this mower about 4 yrs. It replaced a Deere I had for about 12 - 15 yrs. I'm sold on these machines.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#17

Re: OT lawn tractor

Claudia Hayward

>Thanks everyone for your help. Seems like the machine of choice is a Deere!

Re: OT lawn tractor

#18

Re: OT lawn tractor

Pete in Holland, MI

>I ended up with a Cub Cadet 7 years ago. It was between that and a Deere after looking at many of the non-big box store tractors.

Maintenance and how hard you push your machine is directly tied to the longevity of the machine. Dull, even slightly dull, blades require much more work on the engine to cut grass. Out of balance blades shake the deck to create fatigue cracks. Running the engine at full speed under a very heavy load puts a lot of wear on you engine. I sharpen the blades at least once year. Changing the oil is critical too. My Kohler engine has a filter on it. Many now offer that. Without a filter, most books recommend running oil no longer than 25 hours.

Good luck on your decision.

By the way, do a search for MTD lawn mowers. MTD, Yardman, Troy-built, Bolens, Yard Machines, Poulan and many specialty brands at Tractor Supply & Sears are all built by MTD. They did buy Cub Cadet several years back, but that company was run as a seprate entity during the time of my tractor purchase.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#19

Didn't John Deere Marry

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Alice Chalmers? :<)

George

Re: OT lawn tractor

#20

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT lawn tractor

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Sharpen once a YEAR, Pete?

I must be a fanatic, 'cause I have four sets of blades, and I resharpen and replace them after every four mowings - that's less than once a monthe in the Spring, and about once a month throughout the Summer and Fall.

Also, My Kohler (17.5 hp) has a filter, too, but I still change the oil and filter at 25 hour increments, and the air filters at 50 hours.

YMMV, as they say...

Jim D.

Re: OT lawn tractor

#21

Re: OT lawn tractor

Pete in Holland, MI

>Hey Jim -

Once a year works fine for my application at home.

There are many folks though that never sharpen. When I was new to the neighborhood, and recently, as new people move in, as I hear their lawnmower struggle in relatively thick grass, I wander over, shut their lawnmower off, and drag it back to my house for a good blade sharpening.

Has been a good way to get to know new neighbors, and teach them how to keep up their equipment. Once they see the transition between a very dull blade, they understand and either do it themselves next time, or show up at my door step with dull blades in one hand, and a beer in the other.