Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT-Political Correctness

Posts

OT-Political Correctness

#1

OT-Political Correctness

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>"Political correctness is a doctrine, fostered by a delusional, illogical minority, and rabidly promoted by an unscrupulous mainstream media, which holds forth the proposition that it is entirely possible to pick up a turd by the clean end."

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#2

Re: Someone got up on the wrong side today

Brian in Brighton

>

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#3

maybe, but I agree 100%

john lucas

>

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#4

Re: OT-Political Correctness

Jerry Nicholson

>It would appear to me that your analysis is not politically correct ;)

Jerry

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#5

I needed THAT one today ! Thanks !

steve mackay

>

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#6

Re: maybe, but I agree 100% ++1,000

Ralph in Huntington Beach

>

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#7

Amen to that ! *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I agree 100% on that.

Ken, you're my role model. You and those two guys from the movie "Second Hand Lion"

Happy Woodworking!


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzElnBgsr0s

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#8

Re: Amen to that !

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Golly! I'm calling NetFlix and getting that video. Robert Duval is one of my favorites. I have watched Lonesome Dove and Goodfellows a thousand times.

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#9

Re: OT-Political Correctness

Alex Grigoriev

>There is no constitutional right to never be offended

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#10

Great movie.

Dan Donaldson

>

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#11

Political Correctness - another view

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I am reluctant to step into this conversation, since politics is not what this forum is about, but I'd like to offer this:

The impulse that led to political correctness was responding to usually unconscious stereotyping, exclusionary words/phrases, or bias in language. Most of us are conscious of the extremes of this, such as the use of "boy" in referring to a black man, regardless of age; but even in its more subtle forms, language that defines insiders and outsiders can be corrosive for people who have been outsiders.

Alex Grigoriev makes the statement, "There is no constitutional right to never be offended." That's true. But I see choosing not to use words that will exclude as simple civility. If you want to offend, the constitution gives you that right (although Wood Central might choose not to permit it here); but why would you want to do that?

Example: there are a lot of women who are members of this community, many of them far better woodworkers than I. Is it civil for the men of this community to choose not to use words that will signal to them that they're not really welcome here, or that they're the "ladies' auxiliary" and not really equal? I think it is.

Yes, at its extreme, political correctness is pretty silly; but consider where it came from. When I was young, it was quite common for people, even in public settings, to use words - I won't use them here - that denigrated certain ethnicities and cultures; that has faded from the mainstream conversation, and "political correctness" is why.

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#12

Well stated Bill, thanks

John in NM

>

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#13

Re: Political Correctness - another view

Fred Davis

>Bill,

I don't use those words that "denigrate " people different from me either and I firmly believe that "all men are created equal", even though we haven't achieved that state of bliss yet.

But it seems to me , that the whole premise of "Political correctness", however well intentioned it may be , runs the danger of uniform mediocrity becoming the norm.

But that's just what I think,

FredD

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#14

Why?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Fred: I don't mean what I say below to be attacking you, or anyone else here. I'm going to try hard to phrase this in a neutral way; I may well fail.

If political correctness is interpreted to mean tolerating whatever quality of work is done by someone who's not "mainstream" for that kind of work/schooling, then, yes, mediocrity will result. But it's not because someone traditionally excluded from those settings has been brought into the setting; it's because s/he's not fair, constructive criticism and the chance to improve or, failing that, to be invited to leave.

It's kind of like the situation where the company owner's nephew is brought into a job he can't do, but everyone's afraid to say anything because, after all, it's the big boss' nephew: nepotism can lead to mediocrity, too.

I see no problem with telling someone who doesn't do good work that the work's no good. That has nothing to do with political correctness. Someone who's afraid to critique the work of someone who's different from him/her, or who's unable to separate judgments on the work from judgments of the worker based on whatever irrelevancy (gender, skin color, accent, whatever) may say it is; but it ain't. In fact, a situation like that works against the person (including the boss' nephew), who thinks the work s/he's doing is OK when it's junk.

On a related topic, people make the same kinds of statements about affirmative action leading to mediocrity. Not affirmative action as it was originally intended: that focused on how to open up the recruitment and selection process to welcome competent applicants (jobs, school) and encourage the success of people who hadn't traditionally felt invited to apply and, where appropriate, to assist them to be competent.

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#15

Re: Political Correctness - another view

Fred Davis

>I understand your point of view and it is admirable and this forum is not the place to fine tune our views but.........

In San Mateo county Ca. the largest hospital in the Bay area about 1976 or so fell victim to Political Correctness when it stopped referring to Death as Death, but started calling it "negative patient care outcome"

This is in line with the Internal Revenue at about the same time referring to tax collection as "Revenue Enhancement".

The housing industry at about the same time ,probably at the urging of the Feds, started calling cookie cutter developments which I as a builder had some experience with , PUDS.

This stood for Planned Unit Development and as you have probably noticed , peas in a pod would fit the bill and the Architectural deficiencies became obvious to even the most casual observer.

So , one could easily draw the conclusion from many examples, that any given situation or appearance if it appears to or sounds slightly uncomfortable to some , under the Political Correctness view, may instantly be elevated to a higher status , simply by calling it something else.

Of course I could be wrong ;-))

FredD

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#16

Hard to argue that point

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I guess we've been talking past each other - different definitions of political correctness (I shoulda learned - I spent much of my career getting the question straight before answering, having learned that people often were thinking something else than what I thought I heard them say). I see the examples you offer as bureaucratic...well, this is a family friendly community, let's say "nonsense."

After 30 years in human resources, I jump in just one direction when I hear the phrase, "political correctness."

I also spent a lot of my career struggling to say things as they were, in an environment that didn't always encourage it, and I agree: plain words are much clearer than euphemisms.

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#17

Re: Political Correctness = Newspeak

Ralph in Huntington Beach

>My view on PC is that it is a way to try to control our very thoughts and to make people of the "wrong" political view to be afraid to speak their mind for fear of "offending" someone (anyone). When you start to make people in a free society afraid to speak their mind, no matter the subject, you are in essence controlling their freedom of speech, which is the sole purpose of PC.

Political Correctness = Newspeak.

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#18

Different motivations - not all is PC talk

wilbur

>Hi Fred,

I think there is a big difference between the examples that you gave and what is referred to politically correct speech.

In your examples:

death = negative patient care outcome

tax = revenue enhancement

crap housing = PUDS

it is clear that the intention behind using substitute terms is to obfuscate what is really being talked about. There are a multitude of other examples I'm sure that we all could come up with, and I bet a lot of them would be corporate-speak.

On the other hand, "politically correct" speech, in its original sense, is the substitution of terms in order to minimize offense to gender, ethnic, racial, cultural, disabled, sexual-identity, aged or other identity groups. This is an entirely different motive than the corporate-speak examples mentioned above. To take a personal example (I'm of Chinese descent), if Asian Americans in the 21st century would rather be referred to as Asian rather than Oriental, nothing is being hidden by the substitution of the one word for the other, and to use the term Asian instead is extending a courtesy at a really minimal cost to oneself.

Over the years, the term "politically correct" has spread to include many examples beyond its original meaning, such as the examples that you gave. To me, that is not "politically correct" speech. That's obfuscation, as you rightly point out. But the motive behind "politically correct" speech is not really obfuscation -- it's really an act of courtesy.

It is interesting to me that people who try to use politically correct terms in its original sense never seem to use the term "politically correct" to describe what they are doing.

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#19

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Politically Correct = Oxymoron

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I think there's a lot of areas that fall under the umbrella of "political correctness"--whether it's the corporate world, the government, the media, or our general interactions with one another.

My first exposure to it was probably in the late '80s, and it was humorous--as a jab at hypersensitivity, people would substitute "vertically challenged" for "short". At the time, I remember that renaming disabilities was coming into fashion, such as "mentally challenged" was replacing "retarded", which had mostly become a derogatory term. We also saw a move from "shell shock" to "battle fatigue" to "post traumatic stress disorder".

The problem is, we all know what shell shock, short and retarded mean.

Personally, I'm sick of this renaming, if for no other reason than it results in using much longer words or phrases to described something for which we already have a length-challenged lexeme or complexity-challenged verbiage.

I'm not into hyphenating people, either. Either you're American or you're not. If you were born here, you're American. If you immigrated and became a citizen, you're American. I was born here, and my heritage is about 99% German, but I don't go around calling myself German-American.

The only people I know who subscribe to PC language are either elitist, or due to their employer's legal departments are trying to avoid the lawyers of the thin-skinn...er...easily offended.

Jason

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#20

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Fortunately......

Jesper, Denmark

>Politically correct does not have anything to do with politcs. It is also not well known in some parts of Europe, so when I asked the buyer in a German company I sell to if his new project engineer was black, the answer came back: "Not really, he is more like a medium brown."

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#21

Re: Fortunately......

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>That was funny Jesper... I know working with my biggest European customer that they are very direct in responses, some times it's also in the translation, but it's not hurtful or mean spirited.

I find that some use "Correctness", especially in North America, can be used to dig the knife in deeper over a difference of opinion, feeling so ... clever.

I rather deal with direct thoughts than the hidden message that leaves too many interpretations open.

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#22

Re: Politically Correct = Oxymoron

Fred Davis

>Exactly Jason, your comment about lengthy terms replacing the older , to the point language is well taken and is one of my pet peeves.

The examples I gave while true only touch the surface.

For instance it used to be a cliche, that you

could not escape death and taxes."

Now I suppose that has been supplanted with you can't escape "negative patient care outcome and revenue enhancement".

Now isn't that so much better? Takes out the sting doesn't it?

PUDS or Planned Unit Development is actually a government euphemism for uniform mediocrity which in my limited view is where Political Correctness leads us as a nation.

To my way of thinking and this is the last I will comment on this subject I promise, Political Correctness was invented to lessen the perceived impact of terms some would say had painful or demeaning connotations.

Corporate speak , double speak , forked tongue English and "carefully worded claims" of a products excellence are merely subdivisions of the aforementioned Political Correctness. ;-))

FredD

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#23

Re: Different motivations - not all is PC talk

David Hammelef

>Oh but Wilbur, I think you missed it. The substitutions have gotten so bad as to hide the truth..

In particular, "African American" in America is used to describe people who are neither African in decent or American in citizenship, while at the same time not describing people who are decedents of Africans, and are American Citizens. I work with a very Caucasian coworker who is African and now a US citizen. At the same time the Brazilian that I worked with well I think you get the picture.

In the end they are just words and only we give them power. Growing up when I did it has become impossible for me to even know what the PC wording is now some ethnic groups because every 5-10 yrs the word used to describe them becomes non-pc and new one was dreamed up.

I may not be PC but when I tell you to go the Red headed lady in a wheelchair who talks with a lisp you know who I mean.

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#24

The term is excessively elastic these days....

John in NM

>For example, you've extended "politically correct" to encompass all sorts of corpo-nonsense and general political spin. Great example of this is labeling the Korean War a police action for reasons of political expediency. This one example predates the coining of "politcally correct" and I'm sure this practice is about as old as civilization, governments and wars. Many of the examples listed are undoubtably silly and misleading, and perhaps motivated by a misguided desire to "sanitize" unpleasant things like death and taxes. But they are not necessarily politically correct.

What Bill and Wilbur are referring to is, I think, a much narrower concept. Practiced voluntarily, its really nothing more than good manners - recognizing that there exist demographic groups in any society that attach a different and often negative connotations to words that are in either common or recently common usage, and avoiding the use of those words because one does not wish to be offensive. This is nothing more than a broad view of the world around us and a desire to behave in a civilized manner.

When this practice is enforced by the threat of job loss, election defeat, or some other official type of sanction, it then becomes "political correctness" as the term was originally coined. Why employers, schools, governments, or other institutions should find this necessary is entirely beyond me - it simply doesn't work well.

A matter of semantics perhaps, but I find semantic points are fairly important in maintaining a clear view of the world.

Re: OT-Political Correctness

#25

Re: Different motivations - not all is PC talk

wilbur

>Hi David,

Well, let's try to look at this logically, as you seem to be suggesting.

First of all, to get rid of the term "African American" because it doesn't encompass some extreme examples really doesn't make much sense, unless you can provide some data to show that Caucasian American citizens who were born in Africa make up a significant portion of what is commonly referred to as the African American population. But I think that you're going to have a hard time doing so. Based on the 2000 census, 36 million people identified themselves as African American. Only 881,300 people total identified themselves as being born in Africa. 40% of foreign born people are naturalized citizens, which would drop that number to 352,520 people. Based on these numbers, it seems that you want to toss the term "African American" for slightly less than 1% of the cases, and that is assuming that every single one of those 352,520 African born American citizens are Caucasian, which seems like a bit of a stretch to me.

To toss the term African American because of a very small percentage of cases that don't fit the literal definition is like saying that we can't be called "woodworkers" because some of us use brass hinges when we make boxes.

Secondly, as far as having to learn new terminology for ethnic groups, let's assume that the various minority groups actually did change their self identification every 5 years. The first time this happened was in the 60's, when African Americans wanted to drop the term Negro and be referred to as black. Based on what you say, over the period from 1965 to 2005, the term for the African American population would have had to have changed 9 times from 1965-2005, which I don't think is the case.

But even if it was the case, and you wanted to deal not just with African Americans, but also Latinos and Asian Americans changing their term of self-identification every 5 years, which again is a gross exaggeration, that's a total of 27 new vocabulary words that you would have learned over a 40 year period. I'm sorry that's such a burden for you, since I'm sure you would have also had difficulty picking up words and terms that came out over the same time period such as:

big box store, borg, call waiting, cell phone, compact disc, detox, downsizing, DVD, email, floppy drive, garden burger (or veggie burger), going postal, hard drive, HDTV, hybrid car, identity theft, internet, laptop, LCD monitor, mouse (as used in computers), personal computer, pop up ad, ringtone, snail mail, spam (as in email), spyware, televangelist, virus (as in computers), voice mail, and web page.

(To save everyone from counting, yes, that is a list of 27 terms that have come into use over the past forty years.)

Again, I don't see what the problem is for using terminology that groups of people want to put in use for the purposes of self-identification. As far as I can see, it's not an undue burden on the part of those who don't belong to that particular group, even if the name is changing every 5 years, and is simply common courtesy.

And this is what the term "politically correct" really refers to --not the intentional disguise of meaning that the other corporate-speak examples represent. Trying to imply otherwise is exactly the same deliberate alteration of meaning that occurs when people want to substitute terms like "negative patient care outcome" for death.

Like Fred, this is the last I will comment on this subject, I promise.