Re: Different motivations - not all is PC talk
wilbur
>Hi David,
Well, let's try to look at this logically, as you seem to be suggesting.
First of all, to get rid of the term "African American" because it doesn't encompass some extreme examples really doesn't make much sense, unless you can provide some data to show that Caucasian American citizens who were born in Africa make up a significant portion of what is commonly referred to as the African American population. But I think that you're going to have a hard time doing so. Based on the 2000 census, 36 million people identified themselves as African American. Only 881,300 people total identified themselves as being born in Africa. 40% of foreign born people are naturalized citizens, which would drop that number to 352,520 people. Based on these numbers, it seems that you want to toss the term "African American" for slightly less than 1% of the cases, and that is assuming that every single one of those 352,520 African born American citizens are Caucasian, which seems like a bit of a stretch to me.
To toss the term African American because of a very small percentage of cases that don't fit the literal definition is like saying that we can't be called "woodworkers" because some of us use brass hinges when we make boxes.
Secondly, as far as having to learn new terminology for ethnic groups, let's assume that the various minority groups actually did change their self identification every 5 years. The first time this happened was in the 60's, when African Americans wanted to drop the term Negro and be referred to as black. Based on what you say, over the period from 1965 to 2005, the term for the African American population would have had to have changed 9 times from 1965-2005, which I don't think is the case.
But even if it was the case, and you wanted to deal not just with African Americans, but also Latinos and Asian Americans changing their term of self-identification every 5 years, which again is a gross exaggeration, that's a total of 27 new vocabulary words that you would have learned over a 40 year period. I'm sorry that's such a burden for you, since I'm sure you would have also had difficulty picking up words and terms that came out over the same time period such as:
big box store, borg, call waiting, cell phone, compact disc, detox, downsizing, DVD, email, floppy drive, garden burger (or veggie burger), going postal, hard drive, HDTV, hybrid car, identity theft, internet, laptop, LCD monitor, mouse (as used in computers), personal computer, pop up ad, ringtone, snail mail, spam (as in email), spyware, televangelist, virus (as in computers), voice mail, and web page.
(To save everyone from counting, yes, that is a list of 27 terms that have come into use over the past forty years.)
Again, I don't see what the problem is for using terminology that groups of people want to put in use for the purposes of self-identification. As far as I can see, it's not an undue burden on the part of those who don't belong to that particular group, even if the name is changing every 5 years, and is simply common courtesy.
And this is what the term "politically correct" really refers to --not the intentional disguise of meaning that the other corporate-speak examples represent. Trying to imply otherwise is exactly the same deliberate alteration of meaning that occurs when people want to substitute terms like "negative patient care outcome" for death.
Like Fred, this is the last I will comment on this subject, I promise.