Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Health issue with finish strippers

Posts

Health issue with finish strippers

#1

Health issue with finish strippers

BobP

>Good day folks,

I am curious to know if anyone has any first hand experience with any serious health issues directly related to the use of "paint strippers" such as the popular "Zip-Strip" where Methylene Chloride is the active ingredient. Anyone know of any instances where prolonged use resulted in hospitalization because of its improper use or of one needing medical intervention?

Thanks for any comments about your experiences.

(Just trying to gain some real-world perspective)

BobP

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: No personal experience, but check this:

Jesper, Denmark

>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dichloromethane

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#3

Check the MSDS

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#4

Re: Check the MSDS

BobP

>Thanks Clint,

The MSDS was the first thing I checked but I am looking for "real world" encounters and how they manifested themselves.

BobP

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#5

Re: No personal experience, but check this:

BobP

>Jesper,

Thanks for the link. This is pretty much what is in the MSDS.

I am looking for info on actual issues that may have come about from the use of paint strippers (real world stuff).

Thanks.

BobP

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#6

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

Howard Acheson

>When the health issue first came out relating to MC, there was lots of controversy. Finishers have been using MC containing strippers for many years. Used in accordance with the instructions, a stripper containing methylene chloride is considered fairly safe. If there were truly immediate and significant health issues, it would be banned.

That said, there is no such thing as a "safe" paint stripper. Some chemicals are less hazardous but those strippers are less effective. In many cases, it takes a lot more stripper and/or multiple treatments to completely remove the finish. The longer time and multiple uses add up to as much danger as a single application of an MC containing paint remover.

Of course, each person needs to make their own decision. If the cautions cause you concern, don't use it.

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#7

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Bob,

I stopped using the stuff entirely. I used to do a lot of hand stripping when I was in the furniture repair/restoration business. I noticed that prolonged exposure resulted in my feeling dull and spaced out. Now that I am older, I experience angina pain every time I so much as open a can. I won't use it any more.

George

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#8

Sounds like a legal question,.. maybe.

DonSTL

>Your questions sound suspicious.

I sure am tired of the legal ads looking for people who have "suffered" from use of a product so that an attorney can threaten a class action law suit. The manufacturers pay-up to avoid the legal mess, the "victims" collect a pittance per person, and the attorneys reap huge rewards. Example: Sen. John Edwards didn't really get his $40M mansion being a good guy fighting for the poor.

Just my opinion.

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#9

Re: Sounds like a legal question,.. maybe.

BobP

>Sorry, but no legal stuff here.

The quest for information is quite sincere to help rule out causes of some symptoms experienced by a friend. Sometimes people do not tell the Doc enough about what they have been into and sometimes the Doc does not know what to do with the information. When someone becomes ill and a bevy of tests do not immediately reveal the root cause the family believes it is worthwhile exploring all possible avenues, hence my offer to consult those that I suspect have worked with these paint strippers.

BobP

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#10

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

BobP

>George,

Thanks for the comment. I guess it is a good idea to avoid harsh chemicals as much as possible. I guess I feel that if one wears the proper protective gear these chemicals could be used without personal harm (don't know about the enviroment though. There should be more insistance on wearing protective gear, gloves, respirator, etc. ...just my opinion here.

BobP

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#11

Isn't that a moral issue?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>And does it matter what country they come from?

;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#12

Re: Health issue with finish strippers *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Bob,

No first-hand expeerience here (thank goodness), but let Mr. Google be your friend. Search Methylene dichloride (or methylene chloride) poisoning and you will find loads of stuff describing the acute and chronic symptoms. Here is a link to one case study with a nice list of references you cluld follow up on. PubMed (an amazing resource)likely has other referencesas well, but I did not search further. Hope this helps.

Jim


Methylene Chloride Poisoning in a Cabinet Worker

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#13

this isn't the place to get data

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This is a common industrial solvent used to decaffinate coffee, make film and numerous other applications that result in exposure, and generate exposure data, way beyond its occasion use as a stripper. The chemical literature will contain data more reliable than the hearsay opinions of a forum.

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#14

Re: this isn't the place to get data

BobP

>Hi Bill,

Sent you an e-mail.

I understand that there are tons of "data" out there.

I was not really looking for "opinions" but wanted to see if anyone had ever experienced bad effects from use of paint strippers. My experience so far is that the occasional "home-owner" type use of paint strippers, even if the safety rules are not totally adhered to, will not land you in the ER.

Thanks to all for your comments.

Perhaps the lack of any personal stories showing up (other than George's) makes a bit of a statement itself.

I was just checking.

Thanks again.

BobP

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#15

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

Howard Acheson

>That article presents nothing new. The dangers of using MC without adequate ventilation has been well documented since the 1960's. All the labels on strippers containing MC--and most that don't contain MC--warns to provide adequate ventilation.

For that matter, almost all finishing products, including some waterbornes, contain chemicals that can affect health if the used is exposed long term and/or does not take adequate protection.

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#16

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

Jim Dillon

>Howard,

I never said the example article contained anything "new". But I do believe it contains an excellent description of the potential symptoms an otherwise healthy person - exposed to methylene dichloride in an unfriendly work environment - might display on examination. Those potential symptoms include: persistent headaches, nausea, vomiting, sensitivity to bright lights, dry/thickened skin, impaired vision, auditory problems, psycho-motor problems, eye and respiratory problems, and cardiac disturbances.

As Bob stated in his followup post, "The quest for information is quite sincere to help rule out causes of some symptoms experienced by a friend." Hence, without addtional work environment information concerning Bob's friend, I thought it would be helpful to find an article that thoroughly discusses the potential symptoms - new or not. And I still do.

Jim

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#17

the problem with "personal experience"

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It takes some sophisticated work to differentiate cause and effect from correlation. Somebody uses something, and something happens to them. Is it cause and effect, or would what happened have happened anyway, or did worrying about it cause it to happen? It is not uncommon to encounter the latter situation.

Hence, it is best to get your information on toxicology from peer reviewed scientific studies. Some years ago there was concern about methylene chloride exposure and it was studied extensively. Given its wide use as a solvent it could be studied in situations where exposure was greater and for far longer than how wood refinishers would ever be exposed. I never read how it all came out, but given that you can still buy it I suspect that following label instructions will result in safe work.

My recommendation would be to work in well ventilated space, wear gloves that provide a barrier and safety glasses to keep it out of your eyes.

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#18

PS on usage

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you get a hole in a glove and it leaks in and sits on you skin a while you will get an irritation, AKA a red sore spot. It boils just above body temperature, so if spilled on exposed skin it will evaporate so fast that it will chill the skin and other than leave the skin dry from removing the skin oil I have not has an irritation from this brief exposure. I never wore a ring when using it because when it got under a ring it would irritate because it wouldn't be as exposed to evaporation. .

Re: Health issue with finish strippers

#19

Re: the problem with "personal experience"

Jim Dillon

>Bill,

"My recommendation would be to work in well ventilated space, wear gloves that provide a barrier and safety glasses to keep it out of your eyes".

Couldn't agree more. Unfortunately, sometimes an employee has little say in how their employer is running the show. But the casual woodworker should be able to use methylene dichloride containing strippers in a safe manner, per your suggestions. Personally, I would chose something else, but that is just me (plus 32 years experience respectively using of a variety of toxic/carcinogenic/spontaneously flammable chemicals).

Jim