Re: staing 2 x 4's
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>I made a coffee table from 2X4 20 years ago, because that's the only dimensional lumber I could afford at the time. It was actually a fairly nice design I borrowed from one of the FWW Design Books.
Anyway, over the years and with several moves, it became banged up, gouged and worn. So, my darling LOML informed me last summer it needed to be refinished and that instead of the natural pine that it was, it now needed to look like the walnut Morris chair and walnut mission-style couch that inhabit the same room.
I tried stain and didn't like the results -- too much variation in the grain.
Tried gel stain -- better, but not good enough.
Tried dyeing -- very difficult for me to do, unpredictable results.
Ended up using Minwax tinted polyurethane, brushed on, multiple light coats. It worked the best of the methods I tried, and while I didn't like it, LOML did (very much), so what can I say.
I don't have spray equipment, but if I did, I would have put on a base coat of shellac and then sprayed a toner over that for the most even effect.
Bruce