Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

Posts

OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

#1

OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

Luke Herzberg

>I have a question for the collective WC intellect.

What does the eave/top plate detail look like when using pre-fab trusses with tails with regard to blocking between trusses and ventilation baffles for the attic insulation. In this application, there will soffits framed separately off the truss tails. Thus, the distance from top plate to roof sheathing is only 3 1/2"+.

Would there typically be 2x4 blocking between each truss? The typical poly insulation baffles that would run in this hole will take up part of the space, allowing blocking of maybe 2 1/2" or less in height. Is shorter blocking, or blocking in every other space a common practice?

Thanks for any input.

Re: OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

#2

Re: OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

Barry Irby

>If you use "standard" trusses you are correct. The height of the space at the top of the plate will be the height of the top chord. Actually, it will be the diagonal height of the top chord, the diagonal being established by the pitch or slope of the roof. That is, the height will be greater on a steep roof than one with a lower pitch. You can install cardboard baffles to keep The insulation from blowing into the soffts. You would leave enough opening at the top of the baffles for air flow. You would put troughs under the roof sheeting to be certain there was an opening for air flow.

These answers are climate specific to a certain extent. My knowledge is based on Central VA (Richmond area). Our climate here reverses and we have both heating and cooling period that are fairly long. Also, the times they are a changin. What we thought was standard wisdom is being called into question. I just heard an ad for spray foam insulation under the roof sheeting and a conditioned attic. Recently, conditioned crawl spaces have come into vogue. As a Home Inspector, I am skeptical. I am also turning into an old fuddy duddy and no longer want to be the first kid on my block with he new toy. I will stick with the old school stuff that worked and let others lead the way on the new experiments and when I am sure it works for them, I'll give it a try, but only after mocking it for a while.

The short coming in using trusses as you have described is that it leaves a thin spot in the insulation. If you are trying for twelve or more inches of insulation in the attic, the roof sheathing will in effect "Chamfer" the edge of it on both the front and rear. Right at the edge, the insulation may be only about 3" thick.

There are at least three solutions that I can think of. You could spray in insulation foam for a foot or two around the perimeter. Foam has a higher R value per inch of thickness and that would be better than fiberglass or cellulose. Or, you could order trusses that had been thickened at the ends. The truss manufacturer can insert blocks of 2 X 8 (or more) and make the trusses taller, allowing for more insulation. And, Back in the day when I was building energy efficient houses, we ordered the trusses two feet longer than necessary (allowing for a one foot over hang on each side.), but without tails. thus we had the trusses themselves to use for the soffits and they were taller at the walls to allow for more insulation. We used what was called Arkansas Framing. There were 2 x 6 studs on 2' centers, a single top plate and the studs sat directly over the studs. (there were many more details, but I digress) Making the trusses longer had the effect of raising the height of the soffits over the windows, but it was not terribly noticeable, and adding the blocking would raise the soffits too.

Re: OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

#3

Re: OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

Luke Herzberg

>Good info, thanks.

My main inquiry was if the blocking was required structurally, and if so, what is the ventilation path? I've been doing some searching elsewhere, and it seems this is a relatively undefined area, either by codes, engineers or truss manufacturers. Some details are relative to structural blocking, but don't mention ventilation. Some details are relative to ventilation and neglect the blocking.

It seems like the trusses with an integral heel vs. tails simplify things, but as the height to the top chord over the shear wall increases, so does the need for blocking.

Looks like a reduction in insulation at the eave is going to be the only feasible approach here.

Also, I like conditioned crawlspaces. Everything about them makes sense to me. Those same things are what makes me not like a conditioned attic. If I can have access to my subfloor, plumbing wiring, etc...I also want access to the underside of my roof. Cathedral ceilings are already a compromise for aesthetics vs. maintenance. Conditioned attics give you the worst of both worlds.

Re: OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

#4

Re: OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

Barry Irby

>The sheet metal plates engineered to anchor trusses are excellent. Mush better than the old way of toe nailing them. They may help eliminate the need for blocking. If you must block them for structural purposes, there is no reason you could not notch them to allow for air flow.

Condition crawl spaces require some forethought and care. I've seen several that were allowed to get wet during construction and were not dried out. Can you say Mold Factory? If you are building one, take care to keep it dry or dry it out quickly. They are emerging technology. The early ones had several supply vents but no return. That set up a situation where there was an imbalance between supply and return in the house and a pressure differential across the floor.

Check out BuildingScience.com (I think). Run by Joe Lstiburek, he may be the best building scientist in the country and has advised the code writers on this.

Locally, termites are a huge issue. Conditioned crawl spaces tend to make termite inspections difficult.

What I want to know about conditioned attics and insulating the roof deck is what does it do to the life expectancy of asphalt shingles. The roofing companies were reluctant to offer any guarantee for shingles installed over structural insulated panels.

Re: OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

#5

Re: OT: House framing, trusses & attic insulation

Fred Davis

>Luke ,

with or without trusses . roof overhangs are divided into two styles.

No soffit and Frieze blocks ,with every third one a Frieze vent or every other solid block with two or three 2" holes in them for venting.

This style is the cheapest and most ineffective way of treating the roof overhang.

The style I use here is a enclosed soffit with a continous running screen or soffit vents every four feet.

If you go this route and it sounds like your familiar with it ,attach the trusses with truss clips to the top plate, that's what they are for and required everywhere I have built as a builder.

You will find that the insulation will need to be blocked backed from the eves (FHA requires 18" back) so air flow will rise from the soffit to the ridge vents if you use them.

I like in conjunction with Turtle vents or continous ridge vents, a gable vent at each end of the house with the vent that is on the hottest end being a powered gable vent fan , thermostat controlled.

This arrangment will draw col air from the soffit area and the shady end of the house that has a gable vent.

You will find , any fairly easy way to do this will result in thinner insulation at the plate line and I seriously doubt , will have more then a minimal impact on the total insulation effect.

Probably more then you ever wanted to know ;-))

FredD