Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT - Car starting problem

Posts

OT - Car starting problem

#1

OT - Car starting problem

Joe Pack

>To briefly summarize, I left the dome light on on Thursday night and ran down the battery. I put a charger on the battery for an hour, then tried to start the car, but with no luck. I then tried to jump start it, again with no luck...not so much as a click from the starter. I then charged the battery for another 5 hours. I had bright lights, horn, buzzers, etc., but, again, not so much as a single click from the starter. I then called AAA for either a jump start or a tow to your shop.

Using their much stronger battery jump pack, AAA was at first not able to start my car either - not even able to activate the starter . Then, for no apparent reason, with no additional action or energy, I was able to start the car, running it for only about 15 seconds. I turned it off and immediately tried to start the car again. It started immediately, and did so 5 more times within one minute and another 5-6 times as I drove around on errands the rest of the day. Obviously, there was nothing wrong with the battery charge.

To verify this, I stopped at Advance Auto where they put a load on my battery. The battery tested as perfectly good. I then tried to start my car, but it would not start...again, not even the first click from the starter. I turned the key to off, then back on. There was a very slight delay, then the car fired as if nothing was ever wrong. It has since started several more times.

I know something is not right, but have no idea what. Do you have any suggestions as to what to look for or check? At this point the problem is intermittent. If my car is operating correctly when a mechanic checks it, what is the likelihood of finding what was wrong when the car would not start earlier? Would I simply be chasing gremlins?

This is the first time this situation has ever occurred. I have never had starting problems previously, except when the dome light was left on accidently on a couple of prior occassions. When this did happen, an hour on the charger and the car started immediately.

Any suggestions or advice would be greatly appreciated.

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#2

Re: OT - Car starting problem

Mark Nowicki

>Check the connections on the starter. Look for pitting, loose connections or corrosion. I had a similar problem with my truck, it was a loose and corroded connector on the starter solenoid. Engine heat made everything tighter, cold starts were a problem. Repeated cranking will sometimes heat the connection sufficiently to make contact, a weakened battery will not.

Hope this helps

Mark

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#3

Beware ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>I hate things that fix themselves. It is hard to fix if it ain't broke, and you can bet that if it did something weird once, it will do it again and at the worst possible time.

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: OT - WAG

Dale Lenz

>Next time the problem surfaces, try tapping on the solenoid with the butt end of a screwdriver. Just a hunch. Carry your cell phone at all times. Good luck

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#5

Re: OT - Car starting problem

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Joe,

Automatic transmission? If so, the neutral safety switch may need adjustment.

Ignition (key) switch damaged and makes intermittent contact internally.

Bad/poor electrical connection(s). Start at the battery connections and continue through the ignition switch to the starter motor, making each electrical connection clean, bright, and tight.

Good luck, Joe.

Al

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#6

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - Car starting problem - me too

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Just had the same problem with my 97 Toyota truck. Went through everything Al suggested, along with checking for corroded cables, bad connections, etc. Turned out to be the starter itself. Brushes were worn, and so was the commutator. It was a $400 repair...

Jim D.

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#7

More Information Needed

Kneale Brownson..In MI Awaiting Return To CO Snow

>What kind of car and how old/many miles????

For example, VAG (VW, Audi, Porsche products) are famous for failing ignition switches, and many cars from the 1990s have starter wiring that corrodes badly inside its insulation so you can't see the deterioration that makes for poor conductivity. If it's an older/high mileage car, the starter insides can need overhauling (or replacement in today's throw-away society).

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#8

Re: OT - Car starting problem

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>I had a 97 Tahoe that would do that. Finally one day it wouldn't turn or for nothin. Figured the starter was bad and put in a new one. Same problem. Turned out those side mounted battery cables were not making good contact no matter how much I tightened them. Did some jury rigging on the cable ends and worked fine from that point on.

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#9

Re: OT - Car starting problem

Claudia Hayward

>I had the same problem with my Nissan pickup. Turns out it was a bad connection where the battery ground came in contact with the frame.

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#10

Re: More Information Needed

Joe Pack

>2002 Chevrolet Impala, 75K miles

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#11

Wife's car did that.....long winded.

Basil

>First time it happened, she was at church. She called me to come start her car because she left something on but called back in a minute to say it had started. A week later it wouldn't do anything and the battery wasn't dead. I fooled with it a little and it started. The next week it cranked and she pulled out into the road and it quit. ...wouldn't do anything. ....called a rollback and when they got it to the shop, it started. They kept and drove it a few days, no problem. Got it back and a month later it pitches another fit. This time starter would spin it over but no fire to electric fuel

pump. ...rollback. ...shop. ....blah-blah-blah . ...security system light on. ....turn signals doing funny stuff and computer showing ZERO problems.

3 days, interior stripped out and $450 later they found the problem. It was a bad ground for the electric seat controls under the carpet on the drivers side.

Dang modern cars! Sometimes they almost make a fellow want to go back to hand cranks and magnetos.

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#12

I HATE cars!

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#13

She is a goner then..

Mark Nowicki

>...kidding

Mark

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#14

I can relate...

Tony - Memphis

>I'm on my second and last Chevy. Anyway, my last S10 had a very similar problem and it was the neutral safety switch. I could jiggle the shifter and it would then start.

Tony (actually, I am on my third Chevy, but the second one is a '54 that I'll keep forever - it was Grandpa's)

Re: OT - Car starting problem

#15

I gave up.......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Interestingly enough, I gave up my "career" in automechanics and entered into the computer industry about the same time that they replaced carburetors with computers in cars.

As much as I loved computers, I hated that they were used in cars. Today I ride/fix motorbikes because they are so uncomputerized.

Happy Woodworking!