Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Making a residential door Questions

Posts

Making a residential door Questions

#1

Making a residential door Questions

Barry Irby

>A customer wants an odd sized exterior door. 34" X 74".

What he wants is vertical 1 X 6's on the exterior side and diagonal 1 x 6's on the inside. How would you fasten this? What would you do for edge banding? If I use 3/4 planks the door would be 1 1/2" thick. Would you adjust the thickness to 1 3/4" for an exterior door? How? What about a layer of 1/4" plywood sandwiched in the middle? What wood would you use? Any help is appreciated.

Re: Making a residential door Questions

#2

JL

Re: Making a residential door Questions

JL

>"What he wants is vertical 1 X 6's on the exterior side and diagonal 1 x 6's on the inside. How would you fasten this?"

Glue would be my preference. Locally, we've got a blacksmith who makes some very attractive hand forged nails though. They REALLY look good in a door.

"What would you do for edge banding?" - Whats wrong with a contrasting wood? Or the same wood that you use for the door.

"If I use 3/4 planks the door would be 1 1/2" thick. Would you adjust the thickness to 1 3/4" for an exterior door? How? What about a layer of 1/4" plywood sandwiched in the middle?" Plywood should work fine. Another thought is a thin piece of foam insulation - if you can find it that thin. That would increase the "R" value somewhat.

"What wood would you use?" - Again, locally I've seen pine, poplar, red oak and white oak.

The most attractive door I've seen is of white oak. It has hand forged nails and a hand forged opening latch. It unfortunately also has a commercial deadbolt lock.

Re: Making a residential door Questions

#3

Re: Making a residential door Questions------WebKi

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Barry, I would mill the outside planks to ~ 1/2" with T&G, and use something 3/4" inside.

When you fasten the planks on the faces, you could use brads located in the corner of the tongue side, leaving the other side free to move. I would be inclined to run a big bead of liquid nails down the first two inches of the tongue side of each plank also.

If you don't allow those inner and outer planks to move freely, I will assure you that this door will twist. Just because the customer wants it, doesn't make it a good idea.

I would be tempted to use OSB, or exterior MDF for the core, and then coat it with epoxy beforehand, then allow that to cure before attaching the board skins.

I would offer the customer the suggestion to do a herring-bone pattern on the inside. This would be more balanced than the diagonal.

Re: Making a residential door Questions

#4

Re: Making a residential door Questions

Kirk (KC) Constable

>What I'd do is send him to somebody who makes doors on a regular basis. Now, that's just me... but IMO, a door needs to be 'right'. Especially an exterior door. And there are plenty of folks out there set up to build doors.

I understand folks wanting to learn, and pushing themselves to new levels... but there's nothing wrong with passing on something that somebody else can do faster and/or cheaper and/or better.

Re: Making a residential door Questions

#5

Re: Making a residential door Questions

Barry Irby

>Actually, I tend to agree. I have suggested everything I can think of to not build this door. I went to a shop that I thought built doors to get a quote. They don't build them. They would sell me the wood, but don't do doors. I tried to find a manufactured door we could cut down and they had one designed just for the purpose, but it was a slab door with flush or smooth sheets of thin plywood on each side and a lumber core. They nixxed the idea of routing grooves in it. The grooves would cut though the skins.

The guy that wants the door took a standard six panel door and cut it down. Cut so much off the rails that it fell apart. Nice try, but is you think education is expensive, you should try ignorance.

I still think I should be able to find a manufactured door that already has grooves and cut it down.

Interestingly, the house is one of the Sears Kit houses from back in the day.

Re: Making a residential door Questions

#6

I think you should build it for him...

John in NM

>But with the caveat that you can't guarantee there won't be problems due to design. Trying to find a commercial door that can be modified to fit is just a waste of time - your customer wants an unique product, and most commercial suppliers do not do unique.

As to your specific questions, I'd use internal battens - like a standard board and batten door, only set in dados on the inside of each face - and use cut nails or something similar to hold them together. I think I'd try to avoid glue in this sort of situation. Before building, I'd contact Schlage or another good hardware supplier and find out about locksets for thinner doors, then make the door 1 1/2" if I could get hardware. There's no rule that exterior doors have to be 1 3/4", it just makes it easier to use any old hardware you can find. If there's no plywood sandwiched in there it will look fine without edging, making the job considerably simpler. You could also use 5/4 material planed to 7/8" to get the desired thickness.

I think in this case, I'd avoid using softwoods. There is the advantage of less weight, but shrinkage could really be a problem unless you have several months to go from kiln "dry" to actually dry. Maybe that's less of a problem on the east coast, but here its a fairly big one for me. Depending on budget, I might be looking at some of the mahogany family woods for something like this, or if softwood is required, incense or western red cedar.

Good luck with it!

Re: Making a residential door Questions

#7

Re: Making a residential door Questions

Greg Young

>I would make the door but as others have said I would be careful with warranties.

This looks to me like a torsion box solution. Exterior doors are commonly 2 1/4" thick. If there is an exiting jamb with a 1 3/4" rabbet, extend it 1/2", deal with it with the casing and add a sub strike to avoid damage from the latch.

Make a frame of 2" wide X 1 1/2" thick w. pine or better yet mahogany to the finished size of the door. Biscuit this frame together with cold cure epoxy. (Make sure to match both stiles for crown.)

When this frame is cured rabbet both sides 1/4" deep X 3/8" wide.

Cut 1/4" marine mahogany or fir ply to fit the rabbetted opening on both sides.

Fill the frame with 1" styrofoam insulation, (don't forget a wood block for locks). Generously use water based contact cement and complete the "sandwich". You can use some brads to fasten the ply into the rabbet. Assemble it on a very flat surface and roll, roll. this will produce a very rigid core. You might want to research an alternate adhesive as direct sun will often cause contact cement to fail. You could , as well, use kraft honeycomb and epoxy for the sandwich but you will lose R value.

You can then laminate your finishes, (3/8" thick), I would try flexible PVA, Helmitin makes it. Do you know someone with a veneer press? Otherwise, brad and sandbag it. This may sound a bit complex but you can have the core made in the morning. You could also just chop a steel door and laminate over it but we're woodworkers aren't we?

Good luck, go for it but investigate the adhesives.

Re: Making a residential door Questions

#8

Re: Making a residential door Questions

Greg Young

>Sorry if I sounded like I was trying to reinvent the slab door but it really made me think about how I would do it. Cheers.