Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Saw Stop

Posts

Saw Stop

#1

Saw Stop

Dwain

>I see that Saw Stop is coming out with a new cabinet saw and the price is just a little over half what they were asking for the original.

The new saw price is $2,899. I'm just curious as to what is making it possible to allow such a reduction in price.

I tried to find some info on the new saw but had no success. I wonder if anyone here has gotten the buz as to what is different, improved, missing, etc. on the new saw vs. the original that was around $4000.00 when all was said and done.

Is it the new Delta competition plus the economy?

Thank you,

Dwain

Re: Saw Stop

#2

Re: Saw Stop

Chuck in ND

>Did you try calling SawStop for an answer ?

Re: Saw Stop

#3

Re: Saw Stop

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>They found that if they could make the instant blade stopping mechanism to a standard that only had to achieve 90% reliability they could save a lot of money. ;-) Just kidding!

Tom

Re: Saw Stop

#4

JL

Re: Saw Stop

JL

>I've seen the contractor's saw that is about half the price. They are coming out with their "Professional" cabinet saw which is smaller than the Industrial Cabinet saw. The Professional is smaller, but it is only several hundred less.

Professional - http://www.sawstop.com/procabinet/procab_specs.php

Industrial - http://www.sawstop.com/cabinet/cab_specs.php

Re: Saw Stop

#6

Re: Saw Stop

Jesse Cloud

>I'm a big fan of Sawstop. They have them at the school I attend. So far, to my knowledge, there have been two incidents. One seems to have been a false result (at least no one will confess...) and the other went off when the user was doing something stupid and probably saved her an injury.

Beyond the safety, the saws are well made and highly accurate. Just a real pleasure to use. The riving knife is nice, but all new saws have that. Whether its worth the extra $$ is your personal choice.

From the comparison someone posted above, looks like one of the main difference is in the innards (cast as opposed to 'oversized tubular' structure and more than 100 pounds lighter. I would be curious to take one of the new ones for a test drive.

Re: Saw Stop

#7

Re: Saw Stop

Chuck in ND

>I see a 200 lb difference, not 100 lb. For a commercial shop setting I could maybe see an advantage, but if or when the brake goes off I'm just afraid that it's so loud that it could possibly set off a chain reaction of accidents of other employees. I also don't believe that it should be pushed onto the general public as the company has tried to do. If it was mandatory on all saws the hobby would get so expensive to get into that it would kill it off for most, and woodworking supply companies would suffer the consequences. Just my opinion.

Re: Saw Stop

#8

Re: Saw Stop

Brian in Ottawa

>I've been using a Saw Stop cabinet saw at work (Lee Valley) for the past three years. I absolutely love it ... solid and precise. We have never fired the brake.

I have spoken to Saw Stop reps about the differences with the new model, but other than size, I don't honestly remember. Call the company.

Brian in Ottawa

Re: Saw Stop

#9

proper education

McKay

>I have three SS's (2 rip and one dado). For students they tend to lower my blood pressure. However with that said, I would go with my unisaw and proper training any day. After three years, the raising mech.and tilt is stiff and not any better than any other saw out there. There is no substitute for proper education. It is my bet that there are many more injuries caused on other machines than on table saws.

Re: Saw Stop

#10

Re: proper education

Brian in Brighton

>I could not agree more. Proper education is a must. But, like driving, all the education in the world can't prevent an accident. Even professionals that use the saw all day have experienced kickback and that's all it takes. If it's a good saw, which it seems to be, and it has an added safety bonus, go for it.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Saw Stop

#11

Re: proper education

Chuck in ND

>Isn't it funny though that for how many years most people don't even unwrap and install the splitter and blade guard when they buy a new saw, and if they do, it usually doesn't stay on the saw long before it gets thrown onto a shelf and forgotten. But if it's something new and really expensive then it's a must have.

Re: Saw Stop

#12

Re: proper education - Unisaw

Norht of the Border

>I was disappointed that after all the waiting, the new Unisaw came out without the Sawstop safety feature (if saving a licensing fee was their reason why the new Unisaw doesn't have that feature, I don't think that was the best decision made). To me, it's like rolling out the best designed car for winter cities in terms of efficiency, comfort, etc. but lacking the Stability Control System. Proper education is very important, more so for SAWASTOP users as they also work with other equally, if not more, dangerous tools like a jointer. And education can't be replaced by a SAWstop just accidents can't be prevented by any ABS or SCS for reckless drivers. Yet, education alone can't replace the SAWSTOP feature either and the two are actually complementary. I hope one day all future woodworking machines will have the SAWSTOP safety net. I heard SAWSTOP is working on a prototype for mitre saws.

Re: Saw Stop

#13

Re: proper education - Unisaw

Chuck in ND

>I heard more than just miter saws. What a messed up world it's getin to be.

Re: Saw Stop

#14

Re: proper education - Unisaw

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Requiring by law the sawstop feature is just another attack on the freedom of the individual to be responsible for his/her own actions. Likewise, an attack on the freedom of manufacturers to offer a saw without the feature. The nanny state is not where I want to live.

The same goes for helmet laws.

Clint

Re: Saw Stop

#15

Re: proper education - Unisaw

steve mackay

>Just wait 'till OSHA gets involved. We'll have some sort of saw-stop mandated for utility knives and pencil sharpeners.

Re: Saw Stop

#16

Re: Saw Stop

Nelson

>As stated above the new saw is smaller and lighter and will only be avaiable with a 3hp motor.

Re: Saw Stop

#17

The weight caught my eye

Dan Mitchell

>According to the spec page, the new Professional Cabinet Saw model w/52" fence weighs 449 lbs (36", 426). I have a PM2000, after seeing this & out of curiosity I looked up the weight if the PM, specs in the manual says the net weight of the saw only (sans fence) is 540 lbs. I wonder what accounts for such a sizable difference. The PM does have built in casters, which are optional on the new SS, but still...

Re: Saw Stop

#18

Re: The weight caught my eye

Chuck in ND

>Dan, I'm thinking that that the Professional saw is a Hybrid saw. Which is another story, there doesn't seem to be a set standard in the machinery industry as to what a Hybrid is, some have cabinet mounted trunions and some have table mounted trunions. The cabinet foot print size on the Professional SawStop is smaller then the Industrial SawStop.

Re: Saw Stop

#19

Re: proper education - Unisaw

Jesse Cloud

>Hmmm. Utility knife with a brake... where can I get one?

I have cut myself many more times with utility knives than with tablesaws or jointers.

Just kidding...

Re: Saw Stop

#20

Re: We welcome you Clint

Brian in Brighton

>Clint, We live in a nanny state. My suggestion would be to get used to it. We have regulations and codes on more things for safety than you would want to know.

Some of the more onerous ones:

1- Airbags, all new cars got them and it isn't because the manufacturers decided to just have them installed.

2- Seat belts, see 1 above.

3- Table saw splitter and guard. Just because almost all of us remove the confounded things doesn't make it less likely to buy a saw without one.

4- Automatic blade guard on circ saws.

5- Safety Glass in cars.

6- Band saw upper blade guard.

7- Pulley and belt guards.

8- Overloads on motors to keep them from burning out or catching fire.

9- Automatic blade guards on jointers.

10- More lawnmower safety options than I want to list here.

11- Shields on bench grinders.

Without these, and an enormous amount of codes for building safe machines that don't catch fire or electricute you, do you honestly believe that companies would produce the best and safest products on merit alone? These things have to be mandated or they will never be done.

This is why we said that proper training is essential. However, since you and I can go buy a tool without questions about how to run it, and the American male attitude of "I know how to do it, so no training is required for me", manufacturers are forced to save people from their own stupidity and arrogance. You say you hate helmet laws. Great, don't wear one. If I was your insurance carrier I would refuse payment on any accident where you didn't have on a helmet. In the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary I know guys who won't wear a seatbelt. Why? They think that they are being nannied and told what to do. They put their lives at risk over such a stupid and foolish thing. I tell them to just grow up and get over it. More lives have been saved by seat belts than any other auto device, yet they won't use it. I can say for sure that if I had had the blade guard on my old craftsmen table saw when my friend used it and had a kickback that he would not have cut his fingers apart and required $80,000 worth of surgery and 6 months of therapy.

I don't have my blade guard on my saw because it is an entirely poor design from Delta on the old contractors saw. It's proven by many that the splitter is a superior design. Perhaps their blade guard is better too? Either way, if I decide to run the risk it would be nice to know that there is a backup safety device. I don't plan on driving poorly because I have airbags, but it's nice to know that if something happens I have a backup to my driving skills. The same can be said of a sawstop device.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Saw Stop

#21

Re: We welcome you Clint

Alex Grigoriev

>Often the difference between wearing or non-wearing a seat belt is: walking away from the crash, or laying on the pavement with your brains scattered around (that's a good outcome; the bad is living many years with broken neck paralysed).

Re: Saw Stop

#22

Who's rights were violated?

Neal in San Jose

>More years ago than I'd like to admit, before helmet laws, and my first motorcycle was still shiny and new, I read a story in the paper that convinced me to wear a helmet every time I rode.

According to witnesses, a non-helmet wearing biker was riding down a residential street, obeying every law in effect at the time. A gravel truck came down the same street in the opposite direction and a large stone flew off the truck and struck the biker squarely between the eyes. According to the article, he would not have been injured had he been wearing a helmet, but since we was not, he died instantly. His choice, right? The now out-of-control bike then ran off the street, jumped a curb and ran over and killed a little girl who was playing in her front yard. Put yourself in the position of that little girl's father and tell me that helmet laws are just a nuisance, intended to erode your rights.

P.S. I use a SawStop in my shop, and I always fasten my seat belt. Neal

Re: Saw Stop

#23

Re: Who's rights were violated?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Perhaps there should have been a law that required the truck to have some sort of enclosed dump, so stones couldn't fly out. The poor biker was an innocent middle-man.

You guys missed my point, and whether or not sawstop and helmits mitigate injuries is not the issue. The issue is the inherent right of the individual to act stupidly, which, as your examples highlight, cannot be legislated away. If there's a point at which the good of society overrides personal freedom, neither sawstop or helmets exceed it.

Clint

Re: Saw Stop

#24

Re: Who's rights were violated?

Fred Davis

>Cline ,

though I agree with many of your points I hate to tell you that the "greater good of society" has been overriding personal freedoms for years.

Thanks to the Supremes , if your state hasn't got on the ball and legislated against it , your home and land can been confiscated under the new and improved Eminent Domain law and given to a private concern like a developer to build condos on and sell for HIS profit.

Can't wait to see toilets come out with seat belts with interlocks that prevent them from being used unless your belted in. ;-))

FredD

Re: Saw Stop

#25

Re: Who's rights were violated?

Fred Davis

>I meant Clint ,sorry