Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT- String Trimmers

Posts

OT- String Trimmers

#1

OT- String Trimmers

Don Orr

>My old string trimmer finally died. I've been nursing it along for a couple of years now, but it is time for a new one. I am looking for opinions on brands, straight vs. bent shaft, 2 vs. 4 cycle engines, etc. What ever you care to share. I have always used a bent shaft since that is what was given to me by my father. I fondled-I mean tried some at the Borgs this weekend-not running though. Also I would like one that is direct drive if possible-I often run at idle speed around delicate plants. I have an older Weedeater that has a clutch head that I have to run nearly full speed and I don't like it (cost me a dollar at a garage sale). I looked at some on the Net like Stihl, Echo, Husqvarna. Leaning toward Stihl so far.

Thanks for any input,

Don

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#2

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Grant in Iowa

>Don,

I have used a John Deere(Mitsubishi) for several years now and it works great. It is the bent shaft style. I do lust after a friends Stihl machine, however.

I would say that *if* a guy wanted to glean more capability from the tool, and *if* you can justify the cost, Stihl makes some units midrange in price that can accept other attachments such as limb trimmers, sweepers, and hedge clippers. Might be worth a look. This is the direction that I will go if and when the John Deere dies.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#3

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>All I'll say is that a trip to the shop that supplies the lawn and garden service fellows is in order. Having a tech available who can on site repair what you buy will save much more than any savings made by buying a home center model.

And Stihl is a very good brand.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#4

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Don Orr

>Grant-I noticed that on the Stihl website. Pretty cool feature. It's one of the reasons I leaning that way.

Glenn-good advice there. I'm going to stop at the shop where I got my Stih chainsaw this Thursday-they're open later that day so I can get there after work.

Keep it coming folks !

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#5

Stihl for tall grass

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you mow a lot of tall grass there is but one choice, the Stihl. I have had Echo for years. I like it better in almost every way over the Stihl except in tall grass. You can not wind tall grass around the Stihl head. Because most of my trimming is around the farm and it is mostly tall grass, the Stihl was the preferred choice. In my year of mowing with this new machine I have never had it wind grass around the head and I mow stuff knee high regularly.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#6

Re: String Trimmers - I prefer a straight

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>shaft. I've used both bent and straight but prefer the ease of use of a straight shaft for both edging and weed knock down. It's really personal preference. I've owned everything from a K-Mart McCulloh to an Echo to my current Stihl. The Stihl is not a high end model found by landscapers but is very well built and runs like a champ. Line change is relatively easy.

I agree with some of the others, visit a local tractor/lawn equipment type of store if one is available and get a proffesionals opinion.

Definitely shop around. That's what I did when I bought the Stihl.

My 2 cents worth.

Ray

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#7

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I've had Stihl trimmers for 15 years or so now. Two years ago I bought the one that you can change heads on. I mostly bought it because my older Stihl leaked fuel. Still ran like a champ though. Just would leak the remains of what was in the tank onto my shed floor every week. My two year old Stihl also runs like a champ, but leaked slightly from the start and was getting worse. I replaced all the tank fittings this year in an effort to slow it down (even though they look brand new). We'll see, just did it last week. Motor is great. Ergonomics are just OK. When shopping I preferred the handle layout on one of the Huskys and Echos. The fuel leaked into the grip, which was never real solid, but now slides around very annoyingly. If the fuel leak is fixed, I will try to fix that later. Fuel system is definitely the weak point. The tool changeover is a little more time consuming than I would prefer and requires a tool. So, I still edge my driveway with the string most of the time even though I have an edging attachment. Overall, I think Stihl makes great motors. Fuel mix compatibility with my other Stihl stuff was a concern.

I'd probably give something else a shot if I had to do it again. The puddle of two stroke fuel on my plywood shed floor just drives me crazy.

I prefer a straight shaft trimmer, I think it is easier to tilt the head and "edge" around everything sideways as opposed to using the front on the bent shaft version. The Stihl (as with most on your list) will run at any angle, so it allows you to do that.

Jay

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#8

Re: OT- String Trimmers

John McGaw

>For me there is no question about it -- get one of the heavier-duty Stihl straight-shaft units. Look for one that has the cross handle and is rated to use a metal brush blade. Actually the regular straight-shaft units will do the metal blade too (I do it regularly) but the cross handle makes it safer. I've had mine for years after trying several types and brands and the Stihl is so superior to the others it always amazes me that some of the competitors are still in business.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#9

Ellis Walentine

While we're on the subject...

Ellis Walentine

>...I just picked up a mid-range Husky last summer and it worked fine (but not as well as I hoped, so I wouldn't necessarily recommend it). Then I left some gas in it over the winter and now it's showing all the symptoms of clogged fuel lines -- runs, stutters, runs, chokes... Is there any way of running a cupful of stabilized gas through it to open it up or would it be best to just take the fuel line out, change the filter and blow out the lines?

Any secrets here?

Ellis

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#10

Re: While we're on the subject...

Doug Ridley

>There are 3 brands I recommend, Stihl, Stihl, and Stihl.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#11

Re: While we're on the subject...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I don't think stabilized gas will do the trick. Motorcycle owners run into this problem all the time, especially those of us who still have carbureted models and forget to treat the gas before we put them away for the winter. If gas will flow at all, add some injector cleaner to it, maybe a little stronger than the can prescribes. That might do the trick. It will likely take a few tanks of treated gas to clean out the lines.

However, if it doesn't, then there is a product available at a Yamaha motorcycle shop that will work. It's called simply "Yamaha Carburetor Cleaner." Follow the directions on the can.If the guys at the shop want to sell you "Carburetor Cleaner DIP", then ask for the old stuff. It's a different formulation, less green and all that, but much more effective.

Good luck.

Bruce, owner of an old carbureted Goldwing.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#12

If the lines are accessible, I'd remove things

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>and clean them out that way. Sounds like it varnished up - I can say that because I've conducted some of those same experiments (!) myself - and you want to get as much junk out as possible.

The North Coast California climate is such that any given tool may be used in any given season, so I use a lot of gas stabilizer. Expensive at first glance, cheap in the long run. The only exception is the chain saw, which mostly sits until some big chainsawyery is needed, when I tank up, after which I empty it.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#13

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Bill White

>I have a "bicycle" handle Stihl that is a beast. Straight shaft.

I would buy a Stihl again.

Bill

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#14

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I don't cut the grass short enough for my wife, so I let her do it. Instead, she hired a guy. He does it for a living, and swears by Echo.

Clint

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#15

Re: While we're on the subject...

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>Usually varnish on the clunker filter in the tank. It's a two dollar part, but takes 15 minutes to replace. Stabil doesn't work that well anymore with new gas formulations. There's a marine fuel stabilizer that still works pretty well, but I can't remember the name right now. 2 strokes are always a pain for storage. I've learned to dump the fuel back into the can after each use once October rolls around ... just in case it's the last use.

Jay

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#16

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Fred Davis

>My wife managed to either wear out or break a trimmer , nearly every year until I asked the guy who owns a tool rental in Abilene what he reccommeded and he sold us a Echo which he services and also rents them.

Then last year I bought a after market head which is thick heavy steel and has a button to push , to replace the precut line which is a heavy 130 thousandth line. This feature is one you would love , if you had it.

Have used this machine for five years and counting and it never gives up.

I agree Stihl is great and I wouldn't have any other brand chainsaw, but this Echo is light and sturdy which a Woman will appreciate.

FredD

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#17

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Buddy F

>I worked for a local school board for years. We had real good luck with Echo.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#18

Re: OT- String Trimmers

Thomas S Stockton

>first off buy from idependent dealer that also has a good service department. I had one of the larger husqavarna trimmers and killed it by overworking it, I think it was a little underpowered to run a blade for hours on end. I replaced it with a stihl fs 250 which is the biggest trimmer they made at the time that had a normal grip . I got this on the recommendation of a friend who ran a maintenance crew for the state parks dept and said it is what the workers liked the best.

The things a beast and cuts through grass much faster than the old one. If your cutting really coarse thick weeds and small woody stuff the sell some nasty looking strings that will cut through much tougher stuff than the regular stuff.

Tom

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#19

4 strokes are great

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I have a 6 year old 33cc Honda 4 stroke and it has been a great trimmer. I have 3/4 of an acre and it gets quite a work out. The current line of epa approved 2 stroke trimmers are all very high rpm engines and their power band is such that they need to be turning at near max rpm to have enough torque to cut through tough weeds. 4 stroke engines have a much wier torque band and you can run them at low rpm and still have enough power so they don't stall out when cutting.

I am a huge stihl fan and have a trio of big cc chainsaws that I use to mill all the wood I use, but for weeds Ill stick with Honda.

Robin

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#20

Thanks !

Don Orr

>I really appreciate all the input. Lots of good info. I liked the feel of the Echo at the orange borg so far. I'll be checking out the Stihls on Thursday. I think I'm looking for a straight shaft, low end of the Pro line so far.

Thanks again !

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#21

Re: OT- String Trimmers

IEW

>Don:

I have a straight shaft Echo, bulletproof. I also have the chainsaw and tiller attachment for it. The chainsaw on the pole is terrific for trimming trees.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#22

But maybe not the cheap ones

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I have a TroyBilt, which turns out to be a Ryobi design, and it's a bear to start - makes starting an old one-cylinder English motorcycle look like starting an electric motor in comparison.

Re: OT- String Trimmers

#23

4-stroke PROPANE powered *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I love 4 stroke engines as much as I hate 2-stroke engines. The feelings runs deep for both.

Perhaps I equate 2-strokes with hot,smelly,smokey yard-work, and 4-strokes with fun mbike riding ;)

Either way, I won't buy another 2-stroke anything, and have my eye open for some of these newer 4-stroke yard tools.

I was surprised to find this 4-stroke propane powered trimmer. I have only seen it on the web and it has me curious.

Happy Woodworking!


http://www.acehardware.com/sm-lehr-propane-straigh