Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Magazine Ramblings

Posts

Magazine Ramblings

#1

Magazine Ramblings

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi,

I had some time today waiting for an appointment and took a magazine to fill the time.

It was a recent copy of FWW, a magazine I used to subscribe to but in recent years found was drifting away from my points of interest. I had not bought a copy of FWW in a long time but the recent copy had an article by Michael Fortune on Hot Pipe Bending and I have wanted to try this for awhile. While reading a few other articles I learnt 7 new things that will help me with my current woodworking projects. Hmm, I started to think, had I discounted the value of FWW�s changes over the years or just was in that teachable moment when the information presented to me was more easily appreciated?

It came to me that not every magazine is every thing to every one, we have explored that topic here and elsewhere ad-nausea. But what also came clear to me was that we should not always take a magazine for granted in some of its potential offerings.

I was an avid fan of Woodwork and now with its demise feel I will have a loss for its information and spirited explorations of wood, art and people. I am a regular reader of Pop Wood and anything Robert Lang and Chris Schwarz write. I will even buy a copy of my first wood magazine Woodsmith from time to time, I am always amazed at the clarity of detail they can present that allows me to expand my own thoughts on. I think that is where FWW has fallen into place for me now, much like I see Woodsmith as a magazine I allow to teach me what I want on an issue by issue purchase, I think FWW is now more of that for me too. I am glad I bought the last copy, I have the first 200 on CD and can see how amazing it was in the first 100 issues compared to the last 30-40 issues, maybe it�s just me, but a lot of us spend a ton on magazines, nice to know the last $8 I spent taught me something I could use right now, perhaps browsing the news stand to see what the topics are in the current issues is still a valued way to spend some time. Anyway a nice find today before seeing my specialist.

By the way, Michael Fortunes article is excellent

Take care,

Jim

Re: Magazine Ramblings

#2

Re: Magazine Ramblings

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think FWW has somewhat returned from the darkness lately, although, as I commented a couple of days back, their error and safety-issue rate is higher than I'd like to see.

I was very close to letting my FWW subscription lapse when it began to feature some decent stuff again. I realize that some of my perception of the quality of the early FWW is based on how little I knew then, so that each issue was crammed with revelations for me. I'm still ignorant as can be, but have reached a sort of intermediate beginner stage, instead of pre-beginner, as I was then, so a larger percentage of what I see in any given magazine isn't a surprise. Still, for two or three years there, it was an embarrassingly repetitive, simplistic, rag.

Magazines change over time, sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse. I have some early Popular Woodworking issues, and they're nothing like as good as now. I also have some early American Woodworker, which I will retain (looking forward, if my sons ever produce grandchildren or if we find some to "adopt," to making the locomotive featured in one issue); but, from the one recent issue I've seen, I wouldn't subscribe, even at 10 cents an issue (though I'm going to get two issues as remnants of my "Woodwork" subscription; for two issues, it's not worth hassling) - the Handyman Club mag might be better.

At its core, of course, woodworking's not that complex: wood behaves differently along the grain than across the grain, and design and construction needs to take that into account. But that's like saying music consists of making a noise at a particular pitch, in sequence, and in relation to a beat. In both disciplines, it's the subtleties that go on forever.

Re: Magazine Ramblings

#3

Re: Magazine Ramblings

john lucas

>I get almost all of them. The reason is simple. Usually there will be some little tip or idea in one of the articles that I find useful. It's also nice to get different points of view on the same subjects, since they tend to run some things over and over (think pins first of tails first)

I do get tired of the "make this" articles because I never "make this". I always redesign if I actually want to build something.

Re: Magazine Ramblings

#4

Re: Magazine Ramblings

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>Jim - You echo some of my thinking. About a year ago, I was beginning to wonder if I wanted to renew my FWW subscription. There were a lot of articles that were pretty basic and I keep seeing most of the same tech tips over and over. I was beginning to wonder if I had outgrown the magazine (it is a really weird feeling to type that). However, like you, when I realized that I picked up something, however small, in each issue, I decided to re-up my subscription. I do enjoy it and usually read it from cover to cover. I also get Wood and Shop Notes, but I rarely look at the step-by-step articles except from a technique standpoint.

I have found over the years that I prefer to design each project to fit my requirements. I can only think of one project where I followed the step-by-step directions closely (a crib for my grandson). Even there, I changed the look of the spindles just because I liked my design better.

I have to admit that FWW was a major trigger to my getting back into woodworking as a craft with precision. I picked up an early copy back in the black and white era (I think it was number 7) and devoured it. I then went back and bought every previous copy I could find. I used to love the "build your own tool" articles from when the Taiwanese tools weren't available. I still have, and use frequently, a 12" disk sander I made from a 1/2HP motor, some scrap steel and aluminum.

Robby W.

San Marcos, CA

Re: Magazine Ramblings

#5

Re: Magazine Ramblings

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Well, Michael Fortune is simply a genius, under any circumstances. He taught a session at a woodworking show in Sacramento some years ago that still rings true, whenever I need to bend or shape wood into something non-rectilinear. And his sense of art is among the top 1% I've come across.

That FWW got him to present something says that they are not total fools.

On the other hand, it is also clear, that, as we progress in our personal capabilities, the articles that help us with the basic shapes, processes and tools may not resonate as they once did. That doesn't make them less useful, just less useful to us as individuals.

And that's one reason I enjoyed Woodwork. There were few articles that I thought were more basic than I currently appreciate.

With FWW, I don't sense the same desire for exploration. Maybe it's just me. I pick up a copy every once in a while...

But Mr. Fortune is a real treat.

Re: Magazine Ramblings

#6

Re: Magazine Ramblings

Bricofleur

>Each and every idea worths to pay for. This is what woodworking magazines are for - teaching.

When I stop to subscribe to a woodworking magazine I soon regret it and start a new subscription within a short period. I feel like missing something.

Beside that, reading a woodworking magazine on my favorite lazyboy is unbeatable!

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com

Re: Magazine Ramblings

#7

I read almost all magazines every issue

North of the Border

>not because I subscribe for all of them. Many are available at my various local library branches. A few that aren't available (AW and Shopnotes) can be had at the newsstand and I buy selected issues only. I've read AW - the old days' issues as well as current issues) - and they are, of course, not the same but I'm surprised that some forum members think AW under the current editorship is trash. I don't see it that way at all and judging from its strong circulation figures, most of its readers don't feel it that way either. Many of its tips are actually more practical (so were the tips in the old days) than some of those we see in FWW, and PWW for example. Only the tips in WOOD, WS, and Shopnotes are as practical in general.

Re: Magazine Ramblings

#8

Re: I read almost all magazines every issue

Bricofleur

>As I see, you read all the good ones!!! This is great! LOL

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com