I use them
Andrew F in Australia
>Hi Pete,
The feedback I gave someone else is below.
Big advantage is noise, surface finish, small shavings that don't block machines, as well as something peculiar to the SCM MiniMax LAB300 - the fact that the outfeed table can't be adjusted after changing knives, which meant that you had to install 3 knives accurately to 2 thou by eye. Fiddly.
Cheers,
Andrew
---oooOOOooo---
I've got the same head installed in an SCM 12" over & under machine (Combination thicknesser/jointer.) Installed it for noise and surface finish considerations.
I can use the machine without a neighbour hearing any noise inside a house that's 20' from the machine. It's quiet and cuts figured wood well.
Makes chip collection easier - (they're all tiny shavings, not stringy ones,) and it cuts figured wood without tearout. (well, a tiny bit of tearout near knots where the grain is perpendicular to the surface.)
The surface needs a light sand and it's done. No chattermarks.
Another advantage is that if you nick a blade, you only need to rotate one insert, not resharpen/reset the blades.
The downside is the cost, but in the case of my previous cutterhead, each blade change took up to 6 hours as the outfeed table of the jointer was fixed/non-adjustable, so I had to set something accurate to 5 thou by trial and error - the blade setting jigs were useless in the case of this machine.
If it was a thicknesser only, this wouldn't have been a problem.
The inserts are throwaway, can not be resharpened. ie: ongoing costs are a bit more than usual. Advantage is that the changeover is quick and painless, and there's no need to reset the machine. As well, they're proprietary cutterheads - long term cost of spares???
Inserts got a bit blunt after about 300 lineal metres of she-oak, but it did machine the ray figure without tearout.