Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

Posts

Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#1

Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

Pete in Holland, MI

>We're having discussions about the merits of a spiral carbide inserted cutter head for jointers & surface planers. Haven't seen much discussion with this relatively new feature.

For those of you who have migrated from straight steel cutter heads to the new spiral carbide cutter heads, are they truly worth the extra cost, and why?

Just curious. Thanx !

Pete

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#2

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When we had a hardwood lumber business I put thousands of bdft of lumber through a planer. I rarely had any problem with poplar, walnut or oak. I had occasional problems with ash, and cherry, maple and birch were problematic. So if I was planning a lot of maple or birch a spiral head would have been nice.

There has not been more than 1 board in a thousand that I could not successfully joint on my 8" jointer (domestic hardwood only). In these rare cases I just saw the edge with a quality rip blade.

The most advantage of the spiral insert heads might be in replacing a nicked insert rather than regrinding the whole knife.

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#3

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi Pete,

I have a Byrd Shelix heads in both my jointer and planner. I first did it on my 8" General, it was a bit of a "testing the waters" feeling after a few here posted they made the conversion. It was remarkable the difference for me. I use a lot of highly figured woods in my work,, a lot of tear out issues. What I found on my jointer was that the tear out was gone and I could run reversed grain on the Shelix with almost no tear out at all.

Sold on that experience I put one in my General 130 planner, Actually I took my General to Federated Tool in London Ont a year ago and had them install it for me. Dave at Federated has done many of the planner conversions and did a great job on mine. My experience again with the Shelix in the planner was a continuation of the cut quality on highly figured woods with no tear out. The finished quality also is new perfectly clean, very little final work required after planning to to get my finished surface.

Is it worth it? Depends on your sense of economy. For me the two heads came to about $2000. That may be a deal breaker for some, for me it was a bit of a risk, but one I now consider one of the best upgrades I have ever made in my shop.

Aside from the quality of cut and the simplification of setting cutters etc, there is another factor, sound, so so much quieter than the knives.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#4

Other Benefits

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I now have helical cutterheads on both my planer and jointer. I use a lot of figured woods and the reduction of tearout and quality of cut is a great improvement. However, aside from the better performance the spiral cutterheads are also much quieter than knives. And if you feed stock through your jointer by hand then you will enjoy how much less resistance there is when feeding with a spiral head. And after a long day of milling that can be a real benefit.

Tom

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#5

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Pete, Aside from the spiral orientation of those carbide cutters, one of the things that reduces tear-out in wild grain, is a reduced cutting angle. Carbide will not hold as fine a sharpness angle as HHS, so this factor automatically reduces it.

If you are just trying to get rid of that, and if your cutter-heads hold the knives at a higher angle, which is good for soft woods, you can have your knives ground with a face bevel. This will eliminate tear-out without any added expense.

I sharpen my knives which are in a 30� head with a 20� face bevel, which reduces the cutting angle to 10�. This allows for great cuts against the grain in most uncooperative woods.

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#6

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost

Mike Fitterling

>I think having a spiral head in a planer yiels great benefits. Three immediate benefits are 1) tearout reduction to virtually zero; the worst I have had with a spiral head is a fuzzy surface, but that is where there would have been huge tearouts with straight knives. 2) MUCH improved chip collection 3) MUCH quieter operation.

On top of those benefits, each cutting insert is carbide so one can expect about ten times the life of each edge than HSS knives. Each insert is four sided, so you have four times before the cutters have to be replaced. That yields 40 times the life than with HSS knives. With my 15" planer a set of HSS knives cost about $50. 40 x 50 is $2000 if I replaced my HSS knives every time; if I sharpened them I could save maybe half or $1000. The Byrd head with a set of cutters costs about $550 for that machine.

A spiral cutterhead is nice to have on both planer and jointer (and one day I will have one on both) but it is better money spent to put one on a planer first. Any tearout on the jointer can be touched up at the planing stages and most workpieces coming off the jointer are somewhere before final assembly going to be cut, planed, etc. by some other machine, making elimination of tearout not as imperative for the jointer.

As usual, JMO. Cheers,

Mike

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#7

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost

David Yoho

>I replaced the cutter head in my 8" jointer with a Byrd Shelix last year. The finished cuts are dramatically better in curly maple and other figured woods now. I use a two-speed lunch box planer that does a pretty good job on the figured woods. If I owned a large planer, I wouldn't hesitate to upgrade it or buy one with the Byrd head already installed.

One thing I like about the spiral cutter is I really don't have to worry about which way I'm feeding the stock. With the grain or against, the cut is great!

I suppose it may boil down to the type of wood most often used. Someone working mostly soft woods may not find the cost as worthwhile as someone processing mostly hard or figured woods. However, I recently built a free-standing bench for a fellow from standard two-by material from the Borg. Even the knots were nice and smooth!

David

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#8

Additionally....

HC Sakman --- Victoria,BC. CANADA

>Besides other advantages others mentioned; Yes, carbide cutters stay sharp probably 6-to-10 times longer than steel blades. I'd say even at least twice as longer than carbide tipped straight blades due to the helical cutterheads' cutting geometry.

Briefly: Worth it.

Chico...

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: Byrd vs. Generic spiral cutters

Dale Lenz

>What's the verdict on that discussion. I'm convinced to go with a spiral cutter, someday(wish list), Byrd seems to be the top of the list, but is it necessary the brand to go with?

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#10

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I have one on my 8" jointer and like it a lot. I'd like to get one for my planer sometime.

Jay

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#11

Re: Spiral cutter heads Plus??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Been wanting to put a Shelix head on my JPM-13, but at $1,000 for the head just can't justify the cost for a 13" machine, especially since the Performax takes out most all of the tear-outs I get. But I've got a pile of highly figured walnut in the last stages of air drying so I may be doing some reassessment.

BTW, I seem to remember that there are 2 kinds of this head, one by Byrd and one by somebody else [Sunhill??] with the difference being the angle of attach of the cutters. Seems that stating "spiral cutter head" may not be what some assume. Anyone have any info in this????

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#12

Re: Byrd vs. Generic

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>For our 8" jointers, I have a Byrd and a friend has an older generic head bought from Sunhill a number of years ago. I have had discussions with him and even run some wood through his cutterhead when making my decision to buy. My opinion is that the difference between the Byrd and generic (if there is any) is minimal.

My reason for choosing the byrd was replacement insert availability. A quick perusal of the Grizzly catalog shows that they have numerous "generic" heads for their machines. It also shows that many of them have different inserts. My fear is that in the distant future it will be difficult to determine what to buy and to know if your generic cutterhead sold enough copies that someone will make replacements. With the popularity of Byrd, I'm hopeful that even if they aren't around someone will see a market for replacement inserts. There are numerous potential flaws with this reasoning, but that's why I went with Byrd.

Jay

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#13

There Was a Song

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"Everybody knows about the Bird,

Everybody knows . . .

The Bird is the Word!"

Never understood it until just now |;-}}}}}

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#14

I use them

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Pete,

The feedback I gave someone else is below.

Big advantage is noise, surface finish, small shavings that don't block machines, as well as something peculiar to the SCM MiniMax LAB300 - the fact that the outfeed table can't be adjusted after changing knives, which meant that you had to install 3 knives accurately to 2 thou by eye. Fiddly.

Cheers,

Andrew

---oooOOOooo---

I've got the same head installed in an SCM 12" over & under machine (Combination thicknesser/jointer.) Installed it for noise and surface finish considerations.

I can use the machine without a neighbour hearing any noise inside a house that's 20' from the machine. It's quiet and cuts figured wood well.

Makes chip collection easier - (they're all tiny shavings, not stringy ones,) and it cuts figured wood without tearout. (well, a tiny bit of tearout near knots where the grain is perpendicular to the surface.)

The surface needs a light sand and it's done. No chattermarks.

Another advantage is that if you nick a blade, you only need to rotate one insert, not resharpen/reset the blades.

The downside is the cost, but in the case of my previous cutterhead, each blade change took up to 6 hours as the outfeed table of the jointer was fixed/non-adjustable, so I had to set something accurate to 5 thou by trial and error - the blade setting jigs were useless in the case of this machine.

If it was a thicknesser only, this wouldn't have been a problem.

The inserts are throwaway, can not be resharpened. ie: ongoing costs are a bit more than usual. Advantage is that the changeover is quick and painless, and there's no need to reset the machine. As well, they're proprietary cutterheads - long term cost of spares???

Inserts got a bit blunt after about 300 lineal metres of she-oak, but it did machine the ray figure without tearout.

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#15

Re: There Was a Song  *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>


Bird

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#16

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost

Fred Davis

>Pete ,

check out the article on Steel City's new 13" portable planer with a helix head in May's edition of Workshop News.

They give some information about Shelix heads I hadn't heard before and what their take on it is.

Since this a good brand of tools , and for 599.00, it is worth thinking about getting one of these for less then a upgrade on a existing planer.

This is considerably less expensive then upgrading my Jet 20" planer and I may go that way.

Just a thought mind you.

FredD

FredD

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#17

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost

mdclor

>I think the finish coming off the planer is roughly equivalent to 100 grit sand paper with the Griz spiral cutter. Therefore, I start sanding with 120 grit saving a sanding step or two depending on the wood. Since I don't really enjoy sanding all that much, this is another benefit from my perspective.

HTH,

Merle

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#18

Re: The Bird

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>Mark "The Bird" Fidrych, the Detroit Tigers pitching sensation of several decades ago, who died recently, was the inspiration for that offering, I believe.

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#19

Rick L

Re: You have it backwards on generic

Rick L

>Generic inserts will be around. There are only a handful of companies making the inserts. The generics will be around a long time and I'm willing to bet the Byrd are generic inserts and modified. I buy a lot of other insert tooling for planer heads and router bits.

Re: Spiral cutter heads - - benefits outweigh cost ?

#20

Re: The Bird

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Kneale,

You're messin' with my belief system. That ain't nice. Here I had this whole story lined up about a 1963 rock band doing a tribute song about a woodworking machine part that wasn't invented until 40 years after their song came out as being evidence of either psychic powers or alien abduction with time travel (or both), and YOU have to go an' blow it all over a BASEBALL player?

Sheeeesh. Ain't invitin' YOU to any parties. Nuthin' like a know-it-all to kill a really good b-s session!

|;-}}}}}}