Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Door Design for Entertainment Center

Posts

Door Design for Entertainment Center

#1

Door Design for Entertainment Center

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I'm in the process of making an entertainment center and have reached a decision point on the interior doors where I would like some other opinions on appearance. There are four doors which will be sliding doors. I have made the carcase and face frame. The face frame has the rails running continuous across the front. My question is should the doors be made with with the stiles extending all the way top to bottom on the doors like the picture below or the rails and stiles to match the face frame or should them be made like the picture in my second post below?? Which way will look the best in your opinion and why?


img

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#2

Alternate Design for Entertainment Center

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Here's the other design.


img

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#3

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Pic 1 pleases my eye better, and I think the doors would work better, too. I think they'd be stronger.

And if you had my grandchildren, that would matter greatly.

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

Dale Lenz

>I normally run the stiles all the way up, but in your design I'd like to see the the rails on top made from one attractive board so the grain would "flow", left to right. Do the same with a complementary board for the bottom rail.

Good luck

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#5

Ellis Walentine

Deja vu

Ellis Walentine

>Back in the late '80s, my partner had a job with this exact design problem. He opted to run the rails full width, and I think it was the best way to go. Your eye doesn't want to see the random interruptions of the stiles across the face of the composition. There's no law that says stiles must run full height.

Ellis

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#6

Re: Deja vu

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Great Point Ellis,

I agree, it looks seemless that way...

Take care,

Jim

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#7

Re: Deja vu

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'm thinking we're assuming different grain pattern presence here. What I assumed, probably incorrectly, is a strong grain pattern, because that's what I've been looking at lately.

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#8

Ellis Walentine

More basic than that

Ellis Walentine

>Grain is an important element, but the visual effect I'm referring to is one of an uninterrupted strip (rails) across the top and bottom. Personally, I wouldn't want to see those horizontal lines broken up by vertical frame members.

The less visible the grain pattern, the less this matters.

Ellis

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#9

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

Pete in Holland, MI

>Your design looks cool, but are there any supports now along the front to support the top deck? Assume there will be a heavy TV on top and it will cause the top to sag over time without some sort of support.

Something to think about....

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#10

Re: Alternate Design for Entertainment Center

GalenV in Iowa

>I think I would go with the stiles full height. You say these will be sliding so you eye will also see a right and left pair that overlap.

I think the full height stiles will look better overlaped. I'm not sure if you will make the stiles all the same width in which case the overlaped stiles will be slightly less exposure then what you see at the center.

Galen

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#11

Besides the grain....

HC Sakman --- Victoria,BC. CANADA

>Hi Lee,

Since all of the doors are sliding, full rails will provide -more likely- stick-free operation. So, for structural reasons, as well as the visual, I think your obvious choice is the #2 drawing.

Chico...

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#12

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>The EC is actually a corner unit that will hold the components and also have storage space for tapes and DVD's.

To answer the questions, yes there is more structure behind the doors to hold components and to support the top deck where the TV will sit. It isn't shown in the drawings I posted because I didn't want to make the drawings overly complicated. All the weight from the TV will be transferred through vertical members down to the floor.

I'm leaning heavily toward making the rails on the doors match the rails on the face frame. Strength is not going to be an issue because the railes and stiles are joined with half laps instead of a coped joint.

When the four doors are closed, they will not overlap excpt at the two sides of the main opening there is a slight overlap. The two center doors will normally be open so the components can see the signal from the remotes and for cooling. The two side doors will be able to slide to the center to reveal tape/DVD storage.

The componets will actually be mounted in a pull out drawer arrangement in the center so that I can access the connections in the back.

Lee

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#13

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

AZ, Colorado Springs

>Just be sure to anchor the stiles at the outside edges, so wood movement of the stlies will be inward. Otherwise the ends of the rails will not be even with the edges of the stiles in the dry and wet periods of the year (becuase the rails will not change length when the stiles change width). Be sure to leave sufficient room at the sides of the panel to accomodate this movement, as well as movement of the panel, if that be an issue.

Re: Door Design for Entertainment Center

#14

Not going to be a problem

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>The stiles are only about 1-1/4 wide so there shouldn't be much movement due to seasons.

Lee