Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

Posts

Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#1

Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Got the notice today. They are not refunding my money for the rest of my subscription... but sending me issues of American Woodworker to make up for it.

I for one do not understand why you buy out a great magazine only to kill it.

But I have never been accused of being a great business man.

But I sure will miss my favorite magazine.

Dave

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#2

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

Tom Hintz

>I have been "on the inside", on staff of two racing magazines that were bought out and essentially killed. Circle Track Racing (bought with the Petersen Publishing deal) and then Stock Car Racing. Both were doing very well with advertisers and both with large subscription bases. Both are in the process of going away.

I know the ad market is terrible but that was happeneing when these titles were bought. I still don't know exactly why people do this other than to scarf up cash on hand and perhaps to take advertisers to other titles they may own. It may just be a waste of time trying to find common sense in stuff like this.

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#3

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

Jim Dillon

>Dave,

That's a shame as it was a very nice woodworking magazine with high production values. I always enjoyed the interviews/profiles of well-known woodworkers. It was perhaps a little to "artsy" for my taste, but that is just me and not meant to be a reflection on the mag. RIP.

Jim

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#4

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>That's a shame. Woodwork was a magazine that would cover more than just traditional design.

American Woodworker kept sending me copies long after my free subscription ran out. After a while they went straight from the mailbox to the recycle bin.

Tom

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#5

All printed media ...

Mike Farinella

>are really going through tough times. Newspapers and magazines may be on their way out thanks to electronic media. I too will miss Woodwork.

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#6

American Woodworker? That's not an even exchange!

Craig Daymon

>I love Woodwork magazine. The long interviews were a special high point. American Woodworker is not even fit for toilet paper! I haven't received the notice yet, but I will fight this. Woodwork was a class magazine with quality articles and diversity that kept it interesting. American Woodworker has just been recycling old articles for several years now. It's crap!

I'm deeply upset.

-Craig

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#7

The business decision made good sense

North of the Border

>to me. Most woodworking magazines cover similar stuff over and over. I like Fine Woodworking, for example, but I found its coverage of the mitre gauge in its June issue more an attempt to fill pages than anything else. Almost nothing new is given in those four (?) pages other than very well taken photos. If I were the editor with the kind of readers FW has in mind, I'd only allow no more than two pages for that particular article. The same can be said of other magazines now and then ....

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#8

Re: The business decision made good sense

Charlie Self

>That doesn't mean the folding of Woodwork makes good busiiness sense. It was decidedly a bit different, so we now head towards a more complete homogeniety of subject matter in all magazines. That's probably great for the magazines, as it simplifies production, but, as you've noted, it ain't so hot for the readers.

Which would you rather have, American Woodworker now, or American Woodworker a decade or so ago?

Conglomerates exist to make money. They don't give a hoot what they do to make the money, so everything becomes a press fit, a stamping, of what seems to be selling best. Eventually, the public gets fed up and quits buying any of it.

I don't know if the cycle ever starts up again, though. Today's print media difficulties, a lot of which are their own fault, not a real part of the on-line battering they're taking, present an awe-inspiring barrier against starting new versions of old ideas. And conglomerates are not going to even attempt to make the swing back until it's far too late.

But, oh, will the money for shareholders and execs roll in, until it stops.

If we're lucky, CD magazines will prosper, so we don't have to keep a laptop in the shop and another in the john, but can make do with a reader.

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#9

Just don't drop it in the water

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"...CD magazines will prosper, so we don't have to keep a laptop in the shop and another in the john, but can make do with a reader." Even so, at some expense and periodic replacement expense when the reader fritzes and isn't worth repairing.

Feeling oooooold and curmudgeonly....

Books/magazines are still the appropriate technology for long-lasting, simple to maintain, information transmission. It's a shame that they're becoming increasingly uneconomic.

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#10

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>and I shall miss it also. However, I found it more of a lesser copy of Fine Woodworking.

AWW is obviously not an even trade, Its content and writing is somewhere below Wood and Shop Shots, both of which I enjoy. AWW's writing and content is perhaps at the 6th grade level.

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#11

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

Chad Pearson

>What horrible news. I really enjoyed that magazine and in particular their pictures of reader work and their in depth interviews. I can say I didn't have a full appreciation for the mag when I first started woodworking but as my skills increased so did my appreciation for this well written magazine.

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#12

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

BobS

>A lesser copy of FWW, they were totally different. Woodwork covered things FWW would never let in the front door, that was the appeal of Woodwork, it covered such a vast area of woodworking, not just dovetails and tablesaws. I think American Woodworker just wanted to eliminate some competition and narrow the marketplace to sell more mags. Personally I haven't looked at an issue of AM since the long before the current owners and before Readers Digest, you know, the Ellis days.

Bob

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#13

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>It was a New Track Media corporate decision. The AWW editorial staff, especially Tom Caspar, AWW Editor, who was going to be Editorial Director of Woodwork, were really disappointed in the decision. They had already started ramping up to publish Woodwork when they were told "not so fast."

Re: Woodwork Magazine RIP :(

#14

Alan, can you drop me a PM?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I want to ask you a question.

Thanks.

Rod