Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

French polishing/shellac bubble problem

Posts

French polishing/shellac bubble problem

#1

French polishing/shellac bubble problem

Jeff

>I have a bit of a problem with a shellac finish that I'm attempting to French polish. I am refinishing a portion of an antique piano lid that was damaged by water. The original shellac in the damaged area had completely flaked off, so I was to stain and refinish the damaged area. The remainder of the lid was also crazed, as old shellac finishes are prone to do. I told my client that I would polish the non-water damaged areas to fill in the crazing.

The bulk of the thickness of shellac was built up by spraying blond shellac; some coats were straight shellac, and some were toned with aniline dyes.

My problems arose last week when we had an unusual hot spell. The temperature rose to over 100 degrees in my shop, and the shellac bubbled in spots. The bubbles were pin-hole sized, but there was no getting around them, so I sanded the top flat using 600 grit paper.

I had already started polishing the surface, and had had good luck filling in the crazing just by French polishing, so I figured that these pin-holes would fill in. No such luck. They're just not filling in.

With several hundred small holes to fill, I can't see using a tiny brush to fill each hole with multiple layers of shellac. Likewise, I don't think that brushing on (or spraying) multiple layers will do much good, either.

What can I do? Will standard wood putty fillers work? Do I have to sand the finish all the way through the bubbles?

On the upshot, I seriously underbid this job in the first place, so any other work I do will only lower my hourly rate slightly below the $2/hour I'm already making on this repair.

-Jeff-

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

#2

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

Chrispy

>Jeff, I hate to be a pessimist but you have taken on the most difficult finishing problem that there is, there is no better finish, hence the term 'piano finish'!!. My nephew has inhereited my Father's 30's Bechstein piano and has had it refinished (wealthy) for the minute sum of only 10,000 pounds (some $15000). Good luck!

Chris

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

#3

Ellis Walentine

Whew.

Ellis Walentine

>I wouldn't want to speculate on this one. I'm a bit leery of your original comment that the piano was finished with shellac to begin with. I suspect it may have been a somewhat more esoteric spirit varnish. But my knowledge of these things is less than adequate to tell you why this bubbling/cratering is occurring or what to do about it. I think we need the likes of a Dresdner or a Jewitt or a Kevin Hancock to light the way for you. I'll see if I can drum up any interest among the finishing mavens.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

#4

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't see why the shellac would not redissolve and eliminate the bubbles if a slow evaporating solvent was sprayed on the surface. I would try ethanol, but if that did not work I would try isopropanol (100% not rubbing alcohol).

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

#5

I'll try to help

Michael Dresdner

>I'll be happy to help you, but there is too much information missing, beginning with the age and make of the piano, and whether French polish means shellac, modified shellac or padding lacquer.

I suspect, as does Ellis, that you are not dealing with a straight up shellac finish, since several things you said don't quite fit the pattern of old shellac.

Please feel free to email me directly at janeandmichael@msn.com and we can take it from there. If you need to speak with me, set up a time by email and we can talk by phone, if you prefer.

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

#6

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I think the bubbles are caused by trapped solvent evaporation from the underlying layer(0) from the high ambient temperature. I've had the same thing happen using solvent lacquer when I tried to speed up the cure by putting the work in the hot sun. The more layers of finish, the more prone to bubbling, even after months. The only cure I found was to strip and refinish.

Clint

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

#7

Re: French polishing/shellac bubble problem

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I had a bubble problem one time. I had a freshly polished walnut chest in the sun on a very hot day. Apparently there was still some alcohol in the shellac, but the outer layer was skinned over and wouldn't let the gas escape. I definitely think the heat was the problem. I did a light abrasion of the surface, then French polish. I don't remember how much work it was, but the chest is a sample that I cart around and subsequent exposure to the sun gave no problems. The chest looks good today.