Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade
Steve in East Tennessee
>Minwax Polyshades.
I made a utility shelf for my son using milled dimensional lumber (i.e. softwoods) from a Woodsmitn plan. The shelves turned out so nice, I decided instead of just sealing the wood with clear lacquer, I would "spruce it up" (no pun intended) with some Minwax Bombay Mahogany Polyshade. According to the marketing, it combines the stain and finish coat into one step. Perfect time-savings for a project such as this.
Since this was a softwood project, before I broke out the stain, I started with a washcoat of 1# shellac to seal the wood.
I brushed it on. Streaks and runs. I scraped it off.
I wiped it on. Blotchy and rough. Scraped it off again.
I sprayed it on. Fairly smooth and consistent on the flat surfaces, but blotchy and uneven on the corners and ends. Now I am selectively scraping and hand-brushing out the bad sections. It comes off in sheets with a scraper, and can't be sanded because it loads up the paper even after curing for a couple of weeks. It absolutely cannot be touched-up. And it is a very fragile finish. Scratches very easily.
If I would have just used a dye and sprayed it with lacquer, I would have been done with it in a couple of days. Now I'm into this to the tune of several weeks, and it still looks like a 3-year old painted it with cheap, watered-down latex paint.
Is this problem a result of technique (I tried three separate methods), or is this stuff as bad as I think it is. I'm not a Minwax naysayer, but I think they may have whiffed on this one.



