Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

Posts

Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#1

Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

Steve in East Tennessee

>Minwax Polyshades.

I made a utility shelf for my son using milled dimensional lumber (i.e. softwoods) from a Woodsmitn plan. The shelves turned out so nice, I decided instead of just sealing the wood with clear lacquer, I would "spruce it up" (no pun intended) with some Minwax Bombay Mahogany Polyshade. According to the marketing, it combines the stain and finish coat into one step. Perfect time-savings for a project such as this.

Since this was a softwood project, before I broke out the stain, I started with a washcoat of 1# shellac to seal the wood.

I brushed it on. Streaks and runs. I scraped it off.

I wiped it on. Blotchy and rough. Scraped it off again.

I sprayed it on. Fairly smooth and consistent on the flat surfaces, but blotchy and uneven on the corners and ends. Now I am selectively scraping and hand-brushing out the bad sections. It comes off in sheets with a scraper, and can't be sanded because it loads up the paper even after curing for a couple of weeks. It absolutely cannot be touched-up. And it is a very fragile finish. Scratches very easily.

If I would have just used a dye and sprayed it with lacquer, I would have been done with it in a couple of days. Now I'm into this to the tune of several weeks, and it still looks like a 3-year old painted it with cheap, watered-down latex paint.

Is this problem a result of technique (I tried three separate methods), or is this stuff as bad as I think it is. I'm not a Minwax naysayer, but I think they may have whiffed on this one.

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#2

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

Alexander Grigoriev

>You just used wrong finish for your lumber.

By the way, you won't see the right result after a first coat of polyshades. It's very nice product, but not for all cases. Yyou can also use it as toner.

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#3

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

Craig in Silverdale

>I've always said it was the finish that non-woodworkers used. I did some work on a very expensive home a few years back and the owners wife liked a shade of Poly shades. Terrible stuff to use, though I must admit that after about a thousand linear feet of it, I got pretty good at applying it. It does need more than one coat, and I used cheese cloth to apply it. Never again.

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#4

Wrong Application

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Stuff was "designed" based on contractor/builders making their own quickie "1-step" finish for woodwork and trim out of varnish and stain. Actually does quite well on stuff that's under 4" wide. Beyond that the lap marks will kill you.

End grain must be really sealed.

As the can say "Lather, rinse, repeat" 'cause like shampoo, once (for some strange reason) is not enough. Keep that in mind when picking a color.

PS: It's not the worst product in the world. The water stuff, Poly-crylic, is worse. DAMHIKT

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#5

the moral of this story.........

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The project to be finished is not the place to evaluate a new or untried finishing schedule. One can screw up a project for unexpected reasons even with a classic finish. After a few of these myself I now evaluate any finish I intend to use by applying it exactly how I intend to use it on a piece of the wood identical to what is used in the project.

For example, I recently needed to finish some mahogany crotch. When I laid up the veneer on the doors I simultaneously laid up some veneer trimmings on scrap pieces. After I got all the steps perfected on the scrap I felt more confident all would be well on the actual doors.

But even something that seems to be ok can become a problem. Some time ago I sprayed butyrate lacquer on an oil stained piece. The lacquer failed to adhere properly and I had to strip it. After that experience I make no assumptions that any change in a finishing schedule will be ok until I test it.

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#6

Agreed...

John in NM

>It is tricky stuff, but once you're on top of the learning curve it works well and is a fast finish. Foam brushes are a must to avoid streaks.

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#7

Re: Wrong Application

Yonak

>I appreciate Minwax Polyshades as a valuable solution in a manufacturing operation where speed and mass application is important. I have found that spraying several coats gives an adequate finish for production items.

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#8

Re: the moral of this story.........

jerry mayfield

>The former moderator on the finishing forum at Wood Mag. used to say that stuff was the worst thing that ever happened to the can. I agree totally, it is a better idea to color and top coat in steps.

Jerry

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#9

I agree with Bill.....

Barry Irby

>Just because the ads say it is easy, fast, cheap, or whatever does not make it so. I seem to keep learning that lesson. I must be a slow learner. Most recent example is 1-800-Pet-Meds. Buy that flea and tick stuff and save over your local vet. Not so in my case. Local vet is a Heck Of a Guy and sells the stuff cheaper.

Whatever your project is is no place to practice with a new anything. Don't assemble the drawers with a new glue, until you test first. Don't count on new runners until you try one first. Don't introduce a new step in the finish until you practice and see how it works. And don't assume that just because it worked when it was 85 degrees and 20% RH you can use it outdoors in a snowstorm.

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#10

Which Decade?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#11

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

Mike in NC

>My experience with this product was just as dramatic as Steve's. My wife acquired a kitchen table from a coworker that needed refinishing. The only color that she would have on it was in a Polyshade. After finishing the fourth sprayed on coat - this is what it took to get the color dark enough - I stepped outside my shop to clean my gun. Upon returning, I found a kamikaze moth "swimming" in the middle of the table. Due to the inability to touch up this product, it had to be stripped a second time and re-refinished. And yes, I did use it the second time around, only because I knew it would produce the color I was looking for. I now try to stay as far away from this finish as possible to save myself the headache. Oh, and I also now have this crazy fear of moths!

Re: Nomination for Worst Product of the Decade

#12

I've also been burned by Bombay Mahogany

GolfSteve in Calgary

>That stuff looks so good in the can but turns out so awful unless you really know what you're doing.

My cousin bought an unfinished dining room set and finished it with Bombay Mahogany. It looks OK so long as the lights are turned off.