Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

hand scrapers

Posts

hand scrapers

#1

hand scrapers

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I like to think that I can sharpen these. But the truth is that, despite my best efforts to do it right, they never seem to work very well. I mean I get by, but it's not really satisfying the way I believe it should be. I start out with filing flat , then smoothing with a stone, then burnishing with a special hard steel designed for the job. Still, only fair. What am I not doing right?

Re: hand scrapers

#2

JL

Re: hand scrapers

JL

>How are you doing the burnishing? Are you doing repeated strokes at a particular angle followed by repeated strokes at a slightly increased angle? My initial problem with sharpening scrapers was going straight for the hook rather than "sneaking" up on the hook.

Re: hand scrapers

#3

Re: hand scrapers

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>First ant most importantly, don't obsess over the act. You don't need anything but a fine tooth flat file and a hard drift pin. Flatten both sides with the file without rolling the edge. Clamp the scraper in the vise and file the edge flat and square by eye. File any fringe off the sides with a couple light swipes, then burnish the edge four or five times, successively increasing the angle from zero to about 30 degrees. Works for me.

I also keep a couple chisels with rolled edges that are great for detail scraping. I do use an oil stone to flatten and sharpen them before burnishing.

Clint

Re: hand scrapers

#4

Re: hand scrapers

Michael Bush

>I third the suggestion that the problem is probably in the burnishing. The hardest thing get under your hands is slightly increasing the angle of the burnisher with each stroke.

Re: hand scrapers

#5

Re: hand scrapers------WebKitFormBoundaryoAUhnckyz

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Thanks for the responses. I just remembered, also, that I have not been "tick-it-ing" --that step where you put the scraper down on a flat surface and rub the burnisher back and forth along the edge so it makes a repeated "ticking ' sound as it falls off the scraper and hits the table. What about that , as well?

------WebKitFormBoundaryoAUhnckyzX+RImRa

Re: hand scrapers

#6

Possible issue

roninkokomo

>Many people use WAAAAAY too much pressure when they burnish the edge after honing. This crumples the edge and makes the tool almost useless

I learned from Brian Boggs to give just a swipe or two across the burnisher with very little real pressure. About as much pressure as when you are swiping your credit card through the reader at the checkout counter.

Try this. I bet it will help.

Re: hand scrapers

#7

What's not right?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>You say your results are only fair. Can you be more specific? Does the edge not last long? How long does it last? What kind of woods are you scraping? Are the shavings more dust-like instead of more shavings-like? Is the scraped surface not satisfactory? What don't you like about it? How often are you sharpening?

The ticketing step you mention removes the old hook. It's important IMO.

My results improved dramatically when I began fixturing the scraper so the edge and sides are at right angles. For example, the filing step: a lot of people do this free-hand. I use a jig to make sure the cut is at right angles to the sides. Same with the stoning step: I jig it to make the three surfaces square. Also, I use a dab of mineral oil on the scraper for ticketing and burnishing.

Re: hand scrapers

#8

Re: hand scrapers *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Eliot,

Sounds like you understand the basic procedure just fine. The scraper is really a very valuable hand tool that I became acquainted with (by necessity) when working with the intertwined grain of hickory during building my kitchen.

I found that the biggest problem was being too aggressive when turning the burr in the final step. Use light pressure (like "... spreading butter on bread... " to quote Graham Blackburn, woodworking author), then test the burr with your finger/nail. You should be able to feel quite a sharp edge burr/hook when done right. If you use too much of an angle or pressure, then the burr will break off or won't be sharp. I suggest turning the burr in several light strokes, at least at first, testing with your finger after each stroke. Later, when you get a "feel" for the sharpness of the burr, you can try using just one stroke.

There are loads of gizmos on the market for preparing scrapers, and I have too many of them ;-). As others have suggested, keep it simple. Having said that, here is a link to a little gizmo that I got six years ago that has worked very well for me. At the time, it shipped with a nice pamplet on preparing the scraper.

Loads of info out there as well. Chris Schwartz authored a nice overview in the February 2007 issue of Popular Woodworking. Hope this helps.

Jim


Scraper Burnisher

Re: hand scrapers

#9

Re: hand scrapers

Fred Davis

>Eliot ,

if you add using several light strokes when rolling the edge to what your already doing , then all you need is a little more practice.

One thing about card scrapers, they are not created equal.

They vary in thickness and hardness of steel , the harder steels hold a burr longer , but are more difficult for a person new to the technique to get the hang of .

So , practice and don't give up and when the scraper is giving you consist shavings , then you got it.

Bill and I both subscribe to not making it any harder then it is , a few light strokes with a small flat bastard file is all it takes and if your reasonably coordinated , don't worry about maintaining a exact ninety degree angle to the flat side , a degree one way or the other is not detectable in the result.

I use a good flat oil stone to remove the burr , it takes only seconds do remove it.

When you finally get it going the way you expected in the first place , try keeping some scrapers with different angles on the burr , analogous to rough and fine cutting.

Happy scraping and don't burn your fingers ;-))

FredD

Re: hand scrapers

#10

Consistency

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Fred, I agree that perfect 90 degree angles aren't necessary. I suggested filing and stoning in a jig because it gives consistent results. A consistent angle on the scraper allows a consistent angle on the burnisher and improves the possibility that the burr will be useful. Think of it as training wheels on your first bike. Sure, the older kids know how to keep their balance just as the more experienced scraper users know how to freehand a good hook. But for a beginner, a little assistance is good.

Re: hand scrapers

#11

Stop the madness!

B.K. Moring

>Any newbies reading this thread would probably do what I did 19 years ago and throw my scraper in a drawer and let it rust, what with all the burr turning, honing, and burnishing. That is until I read the article in FWW #91, pg 66, "Sharpening a Scraper, A flat file and a few seconds is all it takes."

The author clamps a metalworking bastard file to the bench, angles the scraper at approx. 20 degrees, and with 4 or 5 strokes on the file, it's ready to go and can produce a pile of thin shavings, even on hard, figured wood. The clear advantage is resharpening in ten seconds and getting back to work. No muss, no fuss. I highly recommend it.

Re: hand scrapers

#12

Re: Stop the madness!

Fred Davis

>I believe that is what I said , more or less ;-))

FredD

Re: hand scrapers

#13

Re: Stop the madness!

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>That method (file at an angle) is exactly how I file my handled paint scrapers for house painting preparation. As you say, it is quick to do and easy to learn. The extra stoning and burnishing steps give a more refined edge for smoother cuts.

Re: hand scrapers

#14

Re: Stop the madness!

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Please wait a minute. When you say hold the file down and hold the scraper at a 20 degree angle, do you mean 20 degrees to the direction of travel, or do you mean to actually slant the scraper in such a way that the bevel will be 20 degrees instead of 90 degrees. I think you must mean the former. And what you're saying, too, is to skip the honing step AND the burnishing step, yes? This is quite different from what all the others are suggesting. I'll try two things, based on what I've learned here: (1) Do it the usual way, but burnish much more gently;(2) Try just filing, once I get what you mean by the 20 degree thing.

Re: hand scrapers

#15

Re: Stop the madness!

B.K.Moring

>Eliot

Sorry for the slow response. Slant the scraper to change the bevel. I've found that by using less slant, more like ten degrees, both edges will produce shavings. You have to tilt the scraper considerably more forward on the "weak" edge but it works. Try different tilt angles (and skew angles) when scraping to find the optimum.

It's also important to attach a 1/8" to 3/16" thick strip of wood to one side of the tool to protect your thumbs from overheating during a vigorous scraping session. I attach it with apiece of duct tape that is 1/2" wider and longer than the wood.