Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Almost totally OT *LINK*

Posts

Almost totally OT *LINK*

#1

Almost totally OT *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>Not sure if you have ever seen this site, but it has talks on many different things from which you can learn a lot and just enjoy. A caution is that it can be a huge time sink ;-) This link is to a talk about how we sit, but there are talks on almost anything that you can imagine if you look around. Hopefully someone will get something out of it.

(High speed connection required.)


Ted

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#2

Re: Almost totally OT

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Thanks Dan. That reminded me of the first time I designed a chair. To this day it's still one of the more challenging things I have ever had to design. The Freedom Chair looks great. But at this moment I am typing from the comfort of an Aeron Chair. To this day the best desk chair I have ever had.

Tom

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#3

Re: Almost totally OT

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>Great site Dan, but I vote thumbs down on the Freedom chair. Mine will be on eBay soon.

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#4

Re: Almost totally OT

Dan Donaldson

>Actually, the chair was really just something to use to put up the link. The site, to me is very interesting and has some really interesting talks. I used to have the Aeron chair at work and it is my preference if I were to buy an expensive chair.

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#5

Re: Almost totally OT

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>Hi Dan,

Sorry if I came across the wrong way. I agree about the site, and since you mentioned the chair, I just had to put in my 2 cents since I finally realized that many of my recent aches and pains were due to that particular chair. I mostly agree about the comfort of the Aeron, though I traded it for the Freedom since I wanted to recline a bit with a headrest. One more thing, I always read your OT posts since you find some really good stuff. Please continue.

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#6

Re: Almost totally OT

Dan Donaldson

>No problem. You didn't come across wrong. I just used the chair as an excuse to post the site. I am not sure that I would like that chair either. I mainly thought that the design methodology he used was kind of interesting, and I have spent quite a bit of time at that site listening to talks on lots of stuff. As I mentioned, the aeron that I had at work was the best chair I remember having. Glad you enjoy some of the oddball stuff I find here and there. I know that there are many people here with myriad interests, and when I run into something that tickles my fancy, I post it in case anyone else is as nuts as I am ;-)

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#7

Re: Almost totally OT

Howard Norman

>Dan, I too enjoy your OT posts. I don't always check them out but at least I enjoy your posts even if I don't pursue the links. Keep it up!

h

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Almost totally OT

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Okay, I'm gonna bite. I'm not an office guy, so I don't need/want an expensive office chair, nor can I afford one just for grins. But you've piqued my curiosity. Would you care to elaborate on the pros and cons of the Freedom and the Aeron chairs?

I do know this about my $100 Staples special in which I now sit--the padding in the bottom was shot in pretty short order (and I don't have much of that naturally), the armrests are too low for me, and it doesn't tilt back enough (I'd say 'recline', but the relationship between the back and seat doesn't change, so I said 'tilt').

About the only thing I can sit comfortably in for long periods of time are van, minivan and full-size truck seats, provided they're far enough off the floor or have enough adjustments. In our minivan, I've found that on long trips, if I tilt the seat back and move it forward, interstate travel is much less tiring. It seems counterintuitive, but I've found that discomfort is far more fatiguing and distracting. When I'm comfortable, I can expend more energy on paying attention to my driving situation, even though it would seem logical that comfort would lull one to sleep.

Sorry for the semi-hijack...

Jason

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: What I want to know...

Dale Lenz

>how many of the viewers in the privacy of their home put their hand under their butt to feel for their tail bone, : ' >. I did, made me think. Thanks Dan.

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#10

Chair thoughts - LONG *LINK*

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>Hi Jason,

Many days, I sit in a chair for much more than 8 hours, so my requirements for comfort and support are beyond the usual. Also, I'm nearly 6' tall and ~143 lbs., so I don't have much "padding" either. :) Discomfort was distracting for me too, and led to me not wanting to �go to work.�

My first chair was the Aeron. I liked the numerous adjustments: forward and rear tilt with a tilt tension adjustment, the way the seat moved when reclining, and the padding on the armrests. I did not like the fact that the arms move merely up/down, and the lumbar adjustment was up/down with only two settings fore and aft. The mesh seat/back allowed air to circulate, but caused numbness on my backside. I sold the chair to my uncle and he says the same thing. The way the Aeron's seat is shaped did not offer enough thigh support, and I always felt like the chair was made for a much larger person since I inevitably ended up slumping to one side or another. I think, as it seems you do, that a chair shaped more like a bucket seat, would be more comfortable and supportive. I decided that I wanted a headrest when reclining, so that led me to...

The Humanscale Freedom chair. I read some glowing reviews on the 'net but only sat in one a few minutes before buying it. Pluses: seat has enough padding (maybe not for a heavier person though), arms are padded and can be lowered below thigh level. Seat adjusts fore/aft in relation to the back. Headrest is good when sitting upright. Minuses: no fore/aft lumbar adjustment (except via moving the entire back up/down), which led me to feel that my belly was always sticking out. Arms only move a bit side-to-side, and the seat is low in the middle (no pommel hump) which causes one�s thighs to rotate toward the center - not good according to a Phys. Therapist friend. When reclining, the seat does not tilt at all, which caused my pelvis to move forward and thus I ended up with no lumbar support. Also when reclining, the headrest pushes your head forward to keep your eye gaze level, but that's a neck killer.

I got to the point where I was in so much pain (not due solely to the chair, but also due to the way I was reaching for the mouse), I threatened to build a desk and chair together as one unit and have it pivot 90 degrees so I could lie back like an astronaut. After an internet search, I found the desk ($$$$) in the link below. Finding that desk led me to asking about tilting desk ideas here on WC a few weeks ago. After showing the pic to several chiropractors, they agreed that a reclining position is good, provided that I don�t have to reach for the keyboard or mouse, and that the monitors are at a good height.

So�my requirements for chair three and hopefully last: headrest with a fore/aft adjustment, bucket-seat-like feeling, considerable tilt, and many adjustments � especially for the arms. I narrowed a short list to three chairs, the Ergohuman, Verte, and Bodybilt, and made a trip to St. Louis to sit in a Verte and Bodybilt. I came home with a Bodybilt because it felt the most comfortable and because that brand has many, many options, including seat shapes, three different tilting mechanisms, and probably ten different types of arms. I�m in the process of making the desk, so I�ll reserve my judgment on the Bodybilt until I�ve used it in a reclining position for a while, but so far, I�m quite happy and optimistic that this chair will be my last.

If anyone has any questions, please ask.

PC


Tilting desk

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#11

Re: Chair thoughts - LONG

Dan Donaldson

>I know that chairs can be very personal. Glad you found a good one for you. The Aeron worked well for me. Also, you mentioned that it seemed to be made for a different size than you. I believe that the aeron chairs come in at least three sizes for differing people. From some of the other things you mentioned, this would probably not have made it fit you, but that option is available FWIW ;-) For me, I later moved to a different area of the company and had to give up the aeron. I don't know the brand, but the chairs there were some of those that adjust every way and have very high tech looks. Unfortunately, it only took about 45 minutes of sitting in it to give me a backache no matter how I adjusted it. I finally took it into one of the conference rooms and traded it for one of the generic chairs from there. It wasn't fancy, but at least I could sit in it without pain.

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#12

Re: Chair thoughts - LONG

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'm 6', and much more than 165 lbs, and LOVE my Freedom chair. It's been the desk chair for the last 6 years, and NOBODY better come and get it.

My daughter-in-law saw one advertised online somewhere, and saw why I guard it so closely... It's worth the money, though.

A good chair took me longer to find than a good wife!

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#13

Re: Chair thoughts - LONG

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>I'm glad you like it. I like the looks of my Freedom chair, and will be sorry to see it go because of it.

Re: Almost totally OT *LINK*

#14

Re: Chair thoughts - LONG

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>Dan,

You're correct about the three different sizes, and I should have mentioned that as a plus. I had the C which is or was the largest, but the smaller B felt too small. I'm glad that there are many different chairs to choose from. :)