Chair thoughts - LONG *LINK*
Paul Cates - Henderson, KY
>Hi Jason,
Many days, I sit in a chair for much more than 8 hours, so my requirements for comfort and support are beyond the usual. Also, I'm nearly 6' tall and ~143 lbs., so I don't have much "padding" either. :) Discomfort was distracting for me too, and led to me not wanting to �go to work.�
My first chair was the Aeron. I liked the numerous adjustments: forward and rear tilt with a tilt tension adjustment, the way the seat moved when reclining, and the padding on the armrests. I did not like the fact that the arms move merely up/down, and the lumbar adjustment was up/down with only two settings fore and aft. The mesh seat/back allowed air to circulate, but caused numbness on my backside. I sold the chair to my uncle and he says the same thing. The way the Aeron's seat is shaped did not offer enough thigh support, and I always felt like the chair was made for a much larger person since I inevitably ended up slumping to one side or another. I think, as it seems you do, that a chair shaped more like a bucket seat, would be more comfortable and supportive. I decided that I wanted a headrest when reclining, so that led me to...
The Humanscale Freedom chair. I read some glowing reviews on the 'net but only sat in one a few minutes before buying it. Pluses: seat has enough padding (maybe not for a heavier person though), arms are padded and can be lowered below thigh level. Seat adjusts fore/aft in relation to the back. Headrest is good when sitting upright. Minuses: no fore/aft lumbar adjustment (except via moving the entire back up/down), which led me to feel that my belly was always sticking out. Arms only move a bit side-to-side, and the seat is low in the middle (no pommel hump) which causes one�s thighs to rotate toward the center - not good according to a Phys. Therapist friend. When reclining, the seat does not tilt at all, which caused my pelvis to move forward and thus I ended up with no lumbar support. Also when reclining, the headrest pushes your head forward to keep your eye gaze level, but that's a neck killer.
I got to the point where I was in so much pain (not due solely to the chair, but also due to the way I was reaching for the mouse), I threatened to build a desk and chair together as one unit and have it pivot 90 degrees so I could lie back like an astronaut. After an internet search, I found the desk ($$$$) in the link below. Finding that desk led me to asking about tilting desk ideas here on WC a few weeks ago. After showing the pic to several chiropractors, they agreed that a reclining position is good, provided that I don�t have to reach for the keyboard or mouse, and that the monitors are at a good height.
So�my requirements for chair three and hopefully last: headrest with a fore/aft adjustment, bucket-seat-like feeling, considerable tilt, and many adjustments � especially for the arms. I narrowed a short list to three chairs, the Ergohuman, Verte, and Bodybilt, and made a trip to St. Louis to sit in a Verte and Bodybilt. I came home with a Bodybilt because it felt the most comfortable and because that brand has many, many options, including seat shapes, three different tilting mechanisms, and probably ten different types of arms. I�m in the process of making the desk, so I�ll reserve my judgment on the Bodybilt until I�ve used it in a reclining position for a while, but so far, I�m quite happy and optimistic that this chair will be my last.
If anyone has any questions, please ask.
PC
Tilting desk