Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Lead ban on toys *LINK*

Posts

Lead ban on toys *LINK*

#1

Lead ban on toys *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I know we've discussed this here in the past: The govt's attempt to stop toys from China with dangerous levels of lead from coming into the US caused quite a concern amongs those of us who make (to sell or giveaway) toys for children.

I'm an avid (and responsible) dirt bike rider. I say responsible here because I know we have a bad reputation of being noisy and destructive, but there are some of use who strongly believe in quiet bikes and not being seen or heard when riding in the forest... but I digress.

The legislation that affected us building toys also affected the motorcycle industry as a ban selling motorcycles to anyone under 12 was to come into effect. Frankly I'm not quite sure if/when/how any of these came into effect, just read about the going-ons concerning this.

I found this statement whihc I found interesting. Apparently this guy is completely against motorcycles, but realizes it just doesn't make sense to ban the selling of them. I'm not sure if similar exceptions have been made yet that would affect us building toys, but it looks like there might be a little common sense in all this.

Happy Woodworking!


http://www.cpsc.gov/pr/moore041609.pdf

Re: Lead ban on toys *LINK*

#2

Bad rep

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I have to admit, there are days when I really, really hate dirt bikes (and, in our climate, snowmobiles). That 2-cycle buzz appears to be capable of piercing the barrier of any normal sound-proofing measures. And it makes my rural outdoors impossible to enjoy at times. I can't really expect everyone to drop their hobby, but I would very much favor requiring extremely effective mufflers on all these machines. Guess you can call me petty Dave, I hate the smell of neighbors smoldering trash fires, too..

Re: Lead ban on toys *LINK*

#3

You cant buy a 50cc dirtbike new right now

A Wright

>I am looking for a Yamaha PW50 for my son who just turned 5, and it is true that dealers are prohibited rom selling them new. Basically, you can't buy a 50cc or 65cc motorcycle or ATV due to the limits on lead in toys for children that went into effect on Feb 10, 2009.

I have been researching this for the past few days, and there are several activities going on including various petitions, requests for exceptions, proposed ammendments to the legislation, etc. that are in process but so far nothing has been successful. The issue is that lead is used in the brake shoes, battery terminals, and various other mechanical parts which exceed the new federal limits (I doubt my son will inhale a lethal amount of dust from the brake pads, which where logic goes out the window)

The real tragedy is that this legislation is intended to improve safety, but could actually have the opposite effect. For example, you cant legally buy replacement brake pads for a 50cc minibike, so ievitably some people will let their kids ride without brakes that work properly. Also, if you go into an ATV dealer the smallest four-wheeler you can buy is 100cc. The risk associated with placing a child on an ATV that is too big for them far outweighs the risk of lead exposure from a motorcycle

Re: Lead ban on toys *LINK*

#5

Ellis Walentine

Interesting premise, Mark

Ellis Walentine

>I'm intrigued by the idea of transference, where a successful litigation in one arena might be applied in another, but I'm not hopeful that bureaucracies will ever make the leap.

Ellis

Re: Lead ban on toys *LINK*

#6

For me it's Harley's

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>We sometimes ride our bikes here. We're not in the country but in a fairly typical and somewhat upscale suburban city.

We ride a bunch of old Honda Z50's and my new Honda XR250R in the backyard. Usually not for more than 10 minutes at a time. Any longer than that and we'll head to the church's parking lot. And yes, we push them up the hill to the church to avoid riding them where we're not supposed to.

Our bikes are 4 strokes with stock exhausts and are run slowly so they are extremely quiet. What's funny is that my back neighbor's lawnmower is considerably louder than the dirt bikes. I've run my XR250R while he was mowing and couldn't hear my bike over the sound of his lawnmower. So I KNOW that our bikes are quiet enough.

However, the neighbor across the street recently bought a Harley and that thing makes NOISE!!!! Drives me crazy >:|

I know exactly what you mean about dirt bike noise. Loud bikes with open exhausts ripping around the backwoods making a horrible racket. I hate it as much as you do and sympathize with you. In fact I probably hate it more than you, because in addition to the noise, I hate the fact that bikers are giving all of us a bad rap. I ride and make an effort not to be seen or heard. Not unlike when we go camping and work hard to ensure we never leave trash anyplace, but cringe when we see the trash others leave behond.

Seems that alot of people are either stupid, ignorant, lazy or selfish, or all of the above.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Lead ban on toys *LINK*

#7

Re: For me it's Harley's

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>When we bought the house we're in, 12 years ago, there was, at the end of the court, a fellow who visited regularly until at least 11:30 pm many evenings a week. He'd ride loudly away, setting off car alarms in his wake for several blocks with the exhaust sounds and vibrations from his HD bike. That house has a new owner, for the last 7 years. We love them, because of, and in spite of, their teenagers and friends.

And there were folks across the street for a while, with lots of biker friends. Nice people, and I helped them with some woodworking projects. They were careful not to bee too loud with their machines, and to keep regular people hours.

Stock bikes are no worse than pickup trucks, in my experience. It's the woodworkers and their power sanders past 9 pm that get folks looking into the sound problems. DAMHIKT. ;-)

Re: Lead ban on toys *LINK*

#8

Re: For me it's Harley's

Alex Grigoriev

>You know, expanding foam makes wonders to silence the loud mufflers...

Re: Lead ban on toys *LINK*

#9

Expanding foam

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>You're not suggesting that one take some sort of ...Oh, you are! It really works?