Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

Posts

OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

#1

OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

Doug Ring

>In the past, I have used cement leveling compound to even out sections of concrete flooring before installing hardwood. I'm now into the second floor, and the upper story flooring in my house is even worse than the poured slab surfaces. Is there an equivalent to the concrete compound, except something that I can nail through?

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

#2

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

Fred Davis

>Doug ,

I don't know what part of the country you reside in , but on the West coast ,a product called "FixAll" is far and away the choice for what your looking for.

Looks and acts like Plaster of Paris , but is much harder , sets fast, and if the substrate is firm , does not crack.

Comes in five and ten pound boxes and up to fifty pound sacks.

And you can sand it.

FredD

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

#3

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

Doug Ring

>Ah, yes, that could be a good candidate for my job. I will pick some up and try it in the next bedroom.

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

#4

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I will echo Fred. You don't have to be a contractor to love this stuff.

My dad used to say that you couldn't do anything without Fixall and duct tape!

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

#5

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

Mark Salomon

>Fixall (or Fix-it-All) is great for patching but won't work well on a large scale underlayment and can't be nailed through after it dries. I've also found that when used in fairly small amounts to patch under a floor it invariably breaks down over time from the slight movement/vibration of walking on it. I used cement self leveling underlayment to go on top of an upstairs plywood subfloor that really had problems where I ended up floating an engineered hardwood floor. I'm not sure why you need to nail through the underlayment but if you have significant amounts of leveling then I think that you're pretty much stuck with something that is self leveling and that will be cement-based. If you're putting another layer of plywood on top of the underlayment I think that you can screw through it ok (you always want to use screws rather than nails anyway).

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

#6

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Doug,

As mentioned, a gypsum or cementacious filler will break down and "powder" in a flexing situation like your second floor. Nailing through it will only hasten that process, and you're likely to have a great Japanese burglar alarm for all your efforts. You should therefore consider a resinous filler like Bondo or even a selective application of a membrane like Schluter's Ditra (made for decoupling tile floors). If you mix additional filler or chopped fiber into the raw Bondo before the hardener, you'll be able to thin out its density a bit making it easier to nail through up to say 1/4", and even if it cracks, it'll stay in place without degrading. More than that and you should consider applying a layer of 1/4" material and "sandwiching" the filler.

There is also the "nuke" option to cut and remove the old sub out to the base plates and start from the joists with a new sub properly glued and screwed. I've done that, it saved a whole lot of time, and the difference in the floor under both wood and tile was more than worth it.

YMMV

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

#7

Re: OT - "Leveling Compound" for Ply Underlay

Fred Davis

>Doug ,

It's hard to tell how much you need to float the floor to level , but here is exactly what Professionals sheet goods installers use for linoleum , vinyl tile and like that.

They fill the joint spaces with Fixall , float the dips even and BOND the finish floor with adhesive.

Drawing from that you would not want to nail in the areas you float with Fixall or any other material, because of the fracturing the nails could cause.

You would want to bond the underlayment in those areas with a construction adhesive like PL 500, this eliminates any possibility of movement of the underlayment , cracking of the filler and Fixall will not degrade into a powder .

It is the least expensive , most used by far by Pros's and easy to use for someone not familiar with it.

Bondo has it's place , but is overkill money-wise and difficult to sand down because of it's hardness compared to Fixall.

Sometimes for floors unevenness, something as simple as a piece of 15 LB. felt will build it up to even.

Hope this helps , feel free to email me .

FredD