Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Posts

OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#1

Jesper, Denmark

OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Jesper, Denmark

>I am winding down to retired, sorta, in about a year, so will buy a new PC as a machine to hopefully last a long time - whatever that means. My current HP Compaq dc5700 with Vista and 32 bit OS is working fine. The replacement is likely to be HP Compaq dc 5800, but the question is whether to get 32 bit system, which is limited to a lttel less than 4 mB Ram or to get the 64 bit system and max out to 6 or 8 mB Ram.

I do not understand the full cosequences of the choice other than the RAM limitation of the 32 bit system.

Your collective wisdom is welcome.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#2

JL

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

JL

>I believe you meant 4 gB and 8 gB. I am not Mark Goodall - he does computers for a living - but I'll give you my opinion.

The more memory the better. Many of today's applications are getting more memory intensive. As such, they are consuming more of your available memory resources. Vista and other operating systems have a lot going on in the background. Check the processes list on Windows Task Manager. Add in the obligatory anti-virus and anti-spyware software and you have a lot of stuff going on in the background. Therefore IMO, more memory would really be nice.

Supposedly you can do more and larger processes with a 64 bit machine. Video editing, gaming, CAD and other things are supposed to run better on a 64 bit machine.

The main drawback is that you would be obligated to use Windows Vista (if you go for Windows as an OS).

My $0.02.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#3

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Tom

>It sort of depends on what you're going to use it for. The 64-bit, I believe, isn't maxed out at 8gb. I think it can see a ridiculous amount of memory. The average person wouldn't notice the difference. If you're working with large files, and video-editing and other taxing software, you may want to go with a 64-bit os. I'd hold off for 7 though (January, if not maybe earlier), and skip Vista.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Jesper, Denmark

>JL is right, of couse the RAM is 4 or 8 Gigabit

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#5

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Dan Donaldson

>Linux runs 64 bit also. No Vista ;-) (or Windows for that matter ) ;-))

Ducking and running.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#6

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>We bought a computer that the store swore would be adequate for the programs we planned to run. And it was, for about three years.

Always get more.

One of the issues we weren't aware of is how many little programs wind up showing up to assist in running this and that. They all eat RAM.

By the time the hard drive crashed and we had to buy a new one, we could sometimes run just one program at a time - and not always then.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#7

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Bill Howatt

>One of the issues with the 64-bit Windows has been driver unavailability for some devices. If you are buying a complete new system it won't be an issue except perhaps for a scanner or some other device you plan to use with the new system.

Also, some application programs may not be certified for running on the 64 bit OS. I have a friend who can't run one of her apps but she often is running apps that were originally created for Windows 95.

The recommendation to have 2GB or more to run Vista these days is not too far off the maximum useable RAM address space of about 3GB of the 32-bit system. The other reality is that more and more machines are being shipped with it showing where things are heading. I'd give the 64-bit version very serious consideration. Memory is extremely cheap these days and so is disk storage so you are not likely to see any effort made in being frugal with them in the future.

billh

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#8

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Curly Smith

>If your current system is operating satisfactorily then why do you need to upgrade? What performance issue are you trying to address?

The biggest questions you need to resolve about making the move to a 64-bit system are:

a) Is the software that you routinely run available in a 64-bit version?

b) Will you upgrade your existing software to the 64-bit versions?

If the answer to either is no then it�s rather pointless to move to a 64-bit system. You�d be spending a bunch of money to buy 64-bit hardware to run your 32-bit software that runs quite nicely on a 32-bit system. You may be different, but it�d cost me far more to upgrade my software, assuming 64-bit versions even exist for all of the software that I use daily, than it would to buy the hardware.

IMO, the biggest performance gains for the cost come from:

- Adding system memory --> IF you�re having system memory limitations. For many people it�s debatable whether they�ll see any benefit from increasing system memory past 2.5 GB

- Adding a better video card. If you have a large monitor (>17�) and you�re running in higher resolutions then you need more video RAM since you have more pixels to drive.

- Adding a second monitor. Every version of Windows since Win98/NT has had dual monitor support. You can buy video cards that drive two monitors or just install another video card. Both monitors are driven independently and you can have different resolutions on the two.

- Adding a faster hard drive. If you already have a fast drive then you�ll see some benefit from formatting it into smaller logical drives and by using a drive optimizer to put frequently used programs at the start of the drive.

- Removing the processes that you don�t use in Vista. While this is free, I put it last because you�ll only get trivial benefits unless you�re running up against a memory limitation.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#9

Let me add to Curly & Bill's responce...

Howard Acheson

>... regarding 32 bit verses 64 bit. Compatibility with your existing peripherals and any 32 bit programs you plan to run has been a significant issue with Vista. I don't know it it's been fixed yet.

Look carefully at that issue. I am going through a thought process before upgrading my laptop and am wrestling with the issue.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#10

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Chris Friesen

>Actually, most userspace apps shouldn't care whether the underlying OS is 64-bit or 32-bit. The exceptions to this are things which hook deeply into the system, like antivirus programs. 64-bit Vista also will not run 16-bit software (really old stuff that some people still use).

On the other hand, hardware drivers must be 64-bit aware. If you have old peripherals there may not be 64-bit drivers available. It might be worth checking first.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#11

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Alex Grigoriev

>I think 64 bit Vista is standard on modern major brand PCs.

The only drawback is that it won't run old MS-DOS programs and Windows 3.1 16-bit programs, which should not concern you at all.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#12

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Brian

>I recently had the same issue that I needed to upgrade my desktop computer. Most of the computers available were 64-bit systems but I still had some software that used 32-bit. Since most of my work is done on a desktop (I do a lot of graphics) I decided to get the 64-bit system for that and then opted to get a laptop to run a 32-bit system. That way I had access to both worlds while still being able to have my more powerful system where I needed it most.

Like I said, most computers are now being offered in 64-bit. However, the remaining 32-bit systems are being offered at lower cost.

Just another option to look into.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#13

Have to say it...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think Porter-Cable routers will take at LEAST 64 bits.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#14

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Alex Grigoriev

>x64 Windows OS will run 32-bit software without problems. It won't run MS-DOS or Windows 3.1 (16-bit) very old applications.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#15

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

Alex Grigoriev

>All currently shipping PCs are 64-bit capable. All current Intel and AMD processors can run x64 OS. If you simply buy any new computer, you can run x64 OS on it, you don't get anything only capable of 32 bit.

Re: OT: New PC choice, 32 or 64 bit???

#16

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Have to say it...

Jesper, Denmark

>I knew you had to pipe in with your two bits.