Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

Posts

Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#1

Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

George Van Beynen

>I have a chance to purchase a Shopsmith Mark V with many extras for $650. Five tools in one: Table saw, horizontal drill, vertical drill press, lathe, disc sander.It is hardly used and appears to be new.I would be buying it for my son-in-law who does not have any stationary power tools. He is starting to be interested in woodturning and occasional woodworking repairs. Is this tool a value at this price? I have the individual stationary tools in my workshop but I thought this might give him a good start and may be much better than nothing or cheap tools in his small shop area.

Any information from those experienced with this tool would be appreciated, George

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#2

from my limited use of my dad's

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>it's a lousy table saw (table too small; you need a teenager for an outfeed table - THAT use was not limited, except by my growing up).

I'm told it's a marginal lathe, because the bearings allow too much vibration. No direct experience there.

Great drill press, horizontal drill, and disc sander. In fact, I have an older shopsmith that I bought, but have yet to clean up, primarily because I'd found the horizontal boring feature on my father's Shopsmith helpful.

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#3

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I started out with one. I bought it used. Its greatest asset is probably as a space saver. However, as my skills improved I came to realize the Shopsmith was somewhat limited...especially as a saw. The add on tools are expensive and most do not work quite as well as stand-alone tools. It is not a bad machine but it was hard for me to re-sell. Just 2 cents

Tom

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#4

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Goood Morning George,

My college room mate has one, purchased new a couple years ago. We did a couple lathe projects on it. I used the table saw feature, and didn't like it at all. All this in comparison to my own single purpose stationary tools. If you were to put money out for a new drill press and sanding center, you could eat up a substantial portion of the $650 you mentioned as a price. The lathe does work, perhaps not so well as my Jet 1236--and that isn't perfect either. The table saw can be used for basic work. So, from the standpoint of capability and utility I think a beginner would be satisfied. If space is an issue, then Shop Smith could be the answer to a prayer. With care and planning, the Shop Smith can do marvelous things-more of a testamony to the operator than the equipment.

George

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#5

Louie Lovas

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

Louie Lovas

>I have a shop full of stationary machinery (actually most of it's on mobile bases) - including a Shopsmith which I bought used with a number of accessories/attachments. As a few people have mentioned the table saw is not all that great. I use it for the jointer, lathe and belt sander (and occasional horizontal drilling). For my purposes it was a great investment, I paid $1500 (about 12 years ago). I've since sold the bandsaw and a bunch of the other smaller components on ebay (re-couped about $500 of that initial investment). You can check it out at my website http://www.flinthillfurniture.com Just click on "The Shop" button. You'll see the ShopSmith in a few of the pics.

For that $650 price, if you get at least 2 attachments like a belt sander, jointer or the bandsaw then it's a steal. If there are no attachments, then not sure I would bother.

If you do a "ShopSmith" search of eBay you'll see the used parts market is huge.

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#6

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

A Wright

>one note is that the table saw arbor is not standard siz, so buying blades can be a pain. If it doesn't include a good set of carbide blades factor that cost into the purchase, because you wont be able to give him some of your extra blades and probably won't be able to find a basic $25 blade at HD or Lowes.

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#7

Master of none

Ellis Walentine, Host

>When I was doing research for an article I wrote in 1992, in American Woodworker about combination machines, I was amazed to find that more than 424,000 Shopsmiths had been sold since the first model was introduced in 1947. Presumably, there are over half a million by now. Of all the machines I looked at, the Shopsmith was the only lathe-based one; all the rest were European tablesaw-based machines, heavier duty and much more expensive (think Felder and Robland).

At the time, I interviewed owners of all the machines we tested and learned what they liked most and least about their machines. Most had purchased their combination machines for the same reasons you are contemplating: They're economical, portable and versatile, and they get you up and running in a hurry. The main drawbacks they cited were that only one person can work on the machine at a time, changing functions is tedious, and you need to organize your work differently to avoid having to change so often from one function or attachment to another. And, in the case of the Shopsmith, the capabilities of the various attachments are generally lighter-duty than dedicated machines.

If space is a concern and the scale of your projects is likely to be small, this shop-in-a-box is one way of getting up and running quickly, and the deal you found seems like a good one. If it were me, buying for someone interested primarily in turning, I'd find a small dedicated lathe in the Jet 1236 class and maybe a bandsaw. The Shopsmith lathe function has a lot of accessories, nowadays, including special-purpose centers and chucks, but they are all proprietary, with the set-screw mounting system.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#8

Re: Not according to the guys I know

Brian in Brighton

>I know about a dozen guys who have had own, or still have it. I have yet to find one who liked it for much. They cite the same reasons as above.

I would buy some smaller, used, bench top tools. They are about as powerful and you can get a more useful group of tools.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#9

Re: Shopsmith Mark V

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My father-in-law has one sitting in the back of his garage.

His comment: "It does 6 things; only one of them well."

I asked he which one it did well. He replied "With the addition of a piece of 3/4 ply, it makes a real sturdy shelf."

m

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#10

Re: Shopsmith Mark V

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>I have one, bought new in 1978, also have bandsaw, lathe duplicator, and a few other accessories. In my opinion it does what it is advertised to do...give one the use of five tools in one in a small space. What the operator/woodworker needs to do is to have himself organized in his work and setup the machine to do various workings

such a dovetailings, sawing, sanding, drillings, etc all at one time during the project underway. I have made several pieces of furniture using it and it does still meet my needs very well.

Would I buy another....maybe, if I had the projects to do that required more opportunities to use the various setups without too much changings.

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#11

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

George Van Beynen

>Thank you very much for taking the time to respond. My son in law will take these responses to help with the decision. It may well be worthwhile to look at individual tools as they become available.

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#12

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>You can purchase, from ShopSmith, an arbor which allows the safe use of 5/8", rather than 1", center hole saw blades. I did. You'll want another one for the dado head cutters, too.

My system, bought new 7 years ago, gets used as a disk sander. And I use the dust collector with my thickness planer, because it moves to the driveway easily. It fills up pretty quickly, but half as fast as the drop can on the big system. Harder to dump though, but not too bad.

The saw works, but only sort of. A cross cut sled is a major help, but that's true on the Unisaw, too.

The lathe is really sad.

All of the other functions are now filled by dedicated purpose tools.

For me, about a $2k life lesson. My son wants it, and gets it when he gets a garage...

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#13

Best deal I ever made......

Barry Irby

>I was looking for some turning blocks for my son. Guy had a Shopsmith that had been sitting around for 20 years abandoned. Sold it to me for twenty bucks. Insisted I take it. Had a band saw and a jointer with it. I cleaned it up, painted the painted parts. Listed it in the paper and "sold" it for about a truck load of turning blocks, an air compressor, a bunch of clamps, more sand paper than you could carry and $400 in cash. I loved that Shopsmith for the week I owned it and think of it fondly when I plane something in the planer I bought with the $400.

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#14

Dale Lenz

Re: Best use for them, Barry! Good Job!

Dale Lenz

>

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#15

We should put Barry in charge of

Dan Mitchell

>liquidating all those "toxic assets"!

Though I suspect they may require a bit more than a fresh coat of paint ;-/

WAY TO GO!!!

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#16

Re: Best deal I ever made......

George Van Beynen

>Barry, I have a rusty 500 gallon tank on the back forty. A fresh paint job and maybe.........?

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#17

Re: Shopsmith Mark V - Owned two

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>Hello George,

First one was inherited from my grandfather. It served it's purpose for basic woodworking as a young teenager. Mom sold it after I moved out and got married. I missed it because I nothing and was a new home owner shortly after. I managed okay though with hand tools and friends contracters saw, etc.

Second one was purchased by my brother with a jointer and bandsaw attachment. He also purchased a seperate Shop Smith dust collector. It had all the fixins', lathe equipment, extra blades, disc sanding attachment, everything Shop Smith made basically. He couldn't make the payments any longer so I took over that burden and used this machine for a number of years. I quickly got aggravated with the process of converting the machine for different tasks, and trying to plan 10 steps ahead as the others have posted here.

I found as my skills got better, I yearned for better equipment. I finally listed the second Shopsmith on eBay or Craigslist and sold it to a Naval guy down in North Carolina. It took a long time to sell though. We split the rental truck fees and I loaded it up and met him at the Crackel Barrel in Frederickburg, VA. Sold the second one and all it's goodies for $1,200. The Naval guy was thrilled to say the least. The money was used to purchase my current equipment.

I agree that if a Shopsmith works for you, then buy it. Shop around though. You'd be surprised what you can find used or in NEW bench top type equipment. About a year and a half ago I found a JET (JJ-6CS?) jointer from a guy who "wanted to start woodworking" and decided he didn't have the patients for it. He sold me an almost brand new jointer for $200.00. It sold at WoodWorkers Wharehouse for around $599. Price tag was still on it. Not a bad purchase I thought.

My 2 cents worth,

Ray

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#18

Re: Shopsmith Mark V as a shelf - LOL

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

#19

Re: Shopsmith Mark V Worthwhile?

George Van Beynen

>Thanks again everyone. We decided to not buy the Shopsmith. We will look for used equipment. I told him to keep his eye off my Oneway and PM66 while I am still alive ;-)).