Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Blade Sharpening by Forrest

Posts

Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#1

Blade Sharpening by Forrest

Mike Caldwell

>I've used Forrest blades for years, but this was the first time I sent them a Woodworker II to sharpen. I've never been particularly impressed with the sharpening jobs I've gotten locally, so I thought I'd give Forrest a try. Their blades are so ggod, I guess I expected their sharpening to be of equal quality. Boy, was I wrong. They ground the thing down to where I can't use it with some of my jigs. Oh well, at least I got a thin kerf blade out of the deal.

Has anyone else experienced this with Forrest? Any other thoughts?

Thanks,

Mike Caldwell

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#2

be more specific

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have some knowledge of how blades are sharpened in a sophisticated shop and it is highly unlikely that something was done that didn't need to be. Your blade was essentially ground by a robot and robots grind things repeatably to specification.

You were not clear as to what detail you were unsatisfied with. Typically teeth get ground smaller (height) and thinner (carbide thickness), and the width stays about the same. That is to say that the top of the tooth and the face of the tooth get ground. It is unclear how this material removal would affect your jigs or how one would sharpen otherwise.

If the blade had been sharpened by others it may be that the angles were altered and Forest restored them to specification.

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#3

I spoke with Forrest

Ellis Walentine, Host

>They assured me that they don't grind the width of the tooth unless it is strictly necessary, and even then, the amount of material removed shouldn't be more than about .005" total across the width.

I expect that Forrest will be contacting you soon. I would hope they post a reply here as well. We'll see.

Ellis

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#4

Thank you very much

Mike Caldwell

>Douglas from Forrest just called me to talk about my complaint. I told him that 4 surfaces had been ground: face, top, both sides. That was easy to see because the grinder bit into the circular part of the blade itself. I didn't measure the new width of the carbide tips, but it's obviously thinner. I will measure the tips with a caliper, and report back to Forrest and all.

Thanks to all for your assistance,

Mike Caldwell

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#5

Re: be more specific

Mike Caldwell

>Bill, thank you for your interest. Please see my response below. By the way, I've never taken a Forrest blade to be sharpened. I wouldn't trust anyone but Forrest with it. That's why I was so surprised.

Thank you,

Mike

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#6

Dang!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>there is almost no side clearance on the blade to begin with (my major complaint with this blade). If the sides were significantly ground I can see why you have a problem.

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#7

*** I APOLOGIZE ***

MIchael Caldwell

>Boy, did I blow this one. I got home this evening and looked at the blade again. It did'nt look too bad. Then I pulled out the caliper and measured the width of the teeth. The tooth that was replaced was just a little under 1/8". All the rest of the teeth were 1/8". I swear, last night when I took the blade out of the box, it didn't look right.

So, Forrest did a good job, and I am boxing up another blade to send off to them. To Forrest Mfg and to you, my fellow woodworking, I give you my deepest apology for miss speaking the services of Forrest. I spoke out of turn, and with out checking the facts. I can assure you, I will be much more careful in the future.

Additionally, I will repeat this in a week, in case someone read my earlier post, but isn't reading this.

Humbly,

Mike Caldwell

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#8

That's okay, Mike.

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Speaking for myself, we all jump to conclusions. Glad, it worked out.

Ellis

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#9

Re: Thanks Mike

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Glad the blade is Ok.

Re: Blade Sharpening by Forrest

#10

Re: *** I APOLOGIZE ***

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I glad to hear that there's no problem after all. My experience with Forrest sharpening has been that they do a perfect job every time.