finish to pop curly maple
eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---
>What's the best way to get the most dramatic look for a curly maple table?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
finish to pop curly maple
eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---
>What's the best way to get the most dramatic look for a curly maple table?
My favorite
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>I like the looks of Deft Clear wood finish on curly maple. It doesn't darken teh wood, but the wood highlights really stand out. This box was finished with three coats of Deft Semi-gloss clear wood finish.
Lee
Re: My favorite
eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---
>It's certainly a beauty! What would it have looked like had you oiled it first? I love to put oil on wood -- usually Velvit oil.
Re: finish to pop curly maple
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>Rather than commit to another's opinion, why not do a test of a resin finish like lacquer versus an oil finish like BLO on a couple scraps, and decide for yourself. I happen to think that any of the oils tend to darken and muddy the figure, while lacquer, either tinted or clear, lets the wood reveal its natural beauty. But different strokes for different folks.
Clint
depends.....
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>The style of furniture will dictate some elements of the finish. While the just plain lacquer finishes shown would look appropriate on a contemporary piece of woodworking they would not at all be suitable for a reproduction piece, or an "Early American". In general the options are clear finish, oil and clear finish, dye stain w/wo oil plus shellac/lacquer of some tint or not. I suppose we might also add varnish to the list for a classic 50's yellow finish.
It won't be difficult revealing that the table is curly maple. In my opinion curly maple will make a very busy looking dining table and I would want to subdue the figure. But then it is not my favorite wood for furniture.
Re: depends.....
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>Aside from whatever, if any, effect a drying oil has on emphasizing figure, the one thing they all have in common is a "close to the wood" low reflectance finish. Trying to achieve even a soft gloss with oil is an unnecessary challenge. Plus straight drying oilsdon't offer much protection, if that's important.
On the other hand, a resin finish can be adjusted by chemistry and/or technique to return an appearance that is dead flat and "close to the wood" to a 90+ high gloss. That flexibility makes a resin finish like one or two part lacquers, alkyds, and urethanes the ideal choice for any and all types and style of furniture.
Clint
you sound skeptical..... data
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I recently had occasion to finish a mahogany Federal Period cabinet with crotch panel doors. Being a period piece I asked experts in finishing this style of furniture for finishing schedules. Invariably they involved an oiling of at least the crotch wood followed by a lacquer or shellac top coat. Being skeptical myself I did test pieces and indeed the oiled pieces had a much deeper and richer appearance. I have further tested on my walnut finishing schedule and oiling had the same benefit. I became convinced that adding an oil soak to the finishing schedule can be beneficial, at least in some cases. Hence, it makes sense to experiment with an oil step, either oil alone or an oil stain. For better or worse oil may yellow the finish and it may enhance the contrast in the figure.
As far as an oil only finish I think they are a cop out by people that haven't learned to finish with something better, except for gun stocks and canoe paddle grips.
It would have been considerably darker
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>
Re: you sound skeptical..... data
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>As I suggested, oil darkens the appearance of the wood and perhaps emphasizes the figure a bit due to differential absorption. A downside is yellowing and visual smearing of the figure in some cases.
If I want darker and/or figure enhancement, a dye stain, either before or included in the lacquer will achieve the effect with more control.
In general, the notion that oil uniquely "pops" the grain is conventional wisdom that doesn't bear out in actuality. Anything that wets the wood will do it.
Clint
Re: you sound skeptical..... data
eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---
>Thanks for all the responses. I also asked over at the Turning board. Since the advice is so varied, I think I'm going to make up, as someone suggested, a bunch of test pieces and try some of these suggestion out. Thanks again.
The science behind it all
Michael Dresdner
>Clint wrote: "In general, the notion that oil uniquely "pops" the grain is conventional wisdom that doesn't bear out in actuality. Anything that wets the wood will do it."
I suppose Clint has an objection to the word "uniquely," and that's a fair objection. It is true that anything with good wetting properties will enhance grain, but it is not true that all finishes are equal at that job.
There are two things that make linseed oil the favored son of wetting finishes. The first is that it adds color selectively to the end grain, adding color contrast to the curls and quilts.
Secondly, it wets well, which is a function of it having a low molecular weight. That means the molecules are small enough to be easily and deeply absorbed by the wood.
Most oils (soy, linseed and tung, in order of molecular weight from smallest to largest) have low enough molecular weights to do that wetting job. The easiest way to see it at a glance is to look at some typical molecular weights. Soy is the smallest at 290, with linseed a close second at 375 or so. Shellac comes in at 1000, and most nitrocellulose lacquers range from 2000 to 7000. All will wet wood nicely and add depth, to varying degrees.
In addition, there are a few crosslinking coatings whose monomers and oligamers are small enough prior to cure to wet wood thoroughly, most notably polyester. Because they wet before curing, they, too, will enhance grain, often without adding color.
Once you get into larger molecular weights, such as those in most waterbased coatings, you loose that deep absorption and attendant depth.
By the way, if you want to see a wonderful demonstration of just what oil is doing to wood, put some on a small area on a brown paper bag, then hold the paper up to a light source. You will see that as oil is absorbed it makes the paper, and wood, for that matter, more translucent, which explains the appearance of depth we see.
Re: The science behind it all
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>I defer to your superior knowledge of coatings chemistry, but question the validity of the paper bag - wood analogy. I suspect that a paper bag soaked with a thinned resin finish would also tend toward translucence.....but with less darkening and greater permanence. At any rate, a paper bag may be made of cellulose, but that's pretty far removed from a piece of maple.
I recall an article in FWW that compared the figure enhancing effect of drying oil versus film finish. If memory serves, the film finish won.
Clint
an enlightening discussion, proof in pudding
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>When I used oil on crotch mahogany the appearance was improved,consistent with what I had been told by the period furniture makers. If in doubt, try it. If you can't see a benefit for your particular finishing schedule then leave it out. It adds several days to getting a piece done (to get the oil thoroughly dry) so using it is not without "cost".
Re: The science behind it all
Rob Stokes in North Vancouver
>Actually, the film finish and the oil finish pretty much tied. Which indicated that both the absorption rate and the refractive indexes of linseed oil and a polyurethane based film finish are similar enough that the author deduced that the application of linseed oil prior to coating with polyurethane (polyester) was a step that could be eliminated.
Very informative as always...
John in NM
>Thanks for that great information Michael!
To tell the truth, I've never made a scientific study of it, but what I've found in general is in line with your science.
-Oils like tung and linseed tend to have the most effect on color and grain. Film finishes will sometimes give the same or similar results, but its going to depend a lot on the wood and the make up of the finish.
-Waterborne finishes always seem to give a much flatter look to my eye, and can be made to look like raw wood almost.
Using a Mix
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>A diluted oil (usually Waterlox + Naptha) is the base for my finishing routine on darker or stained woods like cherry and walnut. I then go to a thinned dewaxed shellac to seal (and tone if needed), and add even more depth. Lastly I topcoat with waterbornes that build fast and have (in my view) exceptional clarity in the film. The result is a finish that is both "deep" and yet "close to the wood". Can I get a similar look from just a film finish like oil poly or NC? Yes, but to get the visual depth I've got to apply so much material that it begins to look like a "plastic" coating. I remember my grandmother having her living room upholstery wrapped in clear vinyl (ich!).
Now with light woods like maple, I skip the oil and go with several applications of thinned retarded shellac which I find penetrates and pops grain figure quite well, Plus eliminates the issue of oil discoloration and aging. It also becomes easy to add definition and contrast to light figure by adding very small amounts of dye to the shellac. I can then topcoat with waterbornes which are easy to shift in tone to warm things up if needed.
Re: Using a Mix
eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---
>Would you be good enough to tell me what retarded shellac is? (By the way, did I ever tell you that my son-in-law's name is the same as yours?)
Re: The science behind it all
eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---
>So, would a soy based oil have even a greater dramatic effect on curly maple than a linseed based oil? I believe Velvit oil is a soy based oil.
Retarding Shellac
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Hi Elliot,
You can slow the evaporation of shellac by adding lacquer retarder to the mix. You can also use pure gum turpentine in small amounts. What they do is slow down the flash-off of the alcohol, and allow the shellac to penetrate and/or thin out and level better. If I'm using shellac (like SealCoat or extra pale dewaxed) to pop the grain in a piece, I don't want the alcohol to flash off leaving most of the resin on the surface of the wood. Slowing the evaporation helps. It helps, but care must be taken because vertical surfaces are much more prone to runs and sags in the film.
Hope this helps
Re: Retarding Shellac
eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---
>Very useful! I have been printing out all these responses; it's like a finishing course.
Re: Retarding Shellac
Chris Friesen
>If you're making your own shellac from flakes, you can adjust the time it takes to dry by adjusting the proportions of different alcohols. Of the common ones, methanol dries the fastest, then ethanol, then isopropanol.