Re: Obvious
Curly Smith
>I think you resolved the dilemma when you above talked about subjective and objective values.
Consider, without an invoice how do you determine the objective value of a service? Sure, you can claim that you donated $40k of professional services, and I�m in no way implying that you didn�t, but was that based on billable or actual hours? We all know that those numbers can be, and usually are, vastly different and a system that allowed you to simply deduct billable hours would be rife with fraud potential.
If we can agree that only actual hours should be used, how do we then determine the hourly rate? Most people would assume that charitable work occurs outside of normal working hours so your normal hourly rate that�s designed to cover labor, burden, overhead, facility costs, consumables and profit is likely not applicable. After all, should you �profit� from charity work? How about that health insurance� isn�t it fully covered during the normal working hours? Facility costs� yep, they�re paid for during normal working hours. What about salary� should you really be paid for the work when your �day job� already pays you? So we then need to re-evaluate the hourly rate to determine what cost components are applicable for charity work and, ultimately, you get to the point where only consumables (e.g. materials and utilities) should be deductible for work outside of normal working hours.
Costing work conducted during normal hours is equally, if not more, problematic. How do you account for the overhead portion? You can�t deduct the value of other people�s time, because that�s theirs to donate, nor can you expect them to work for free while you�re engaged in your charitable giving because that�s tantamount to slavery. Should you always charge for labor or should you only charge if you�ve turned away work (lost opportunity cost)? What about facilities? Sure, the rent and taxes need to be paid but should you only charge if the billable hours don�t meet the threshold requirement to stay in business? How do you develop a charge system that transparently excludes the potential for double-dipping and yet is maintained solely by the taxpayer claiming the charitable deduction?
To make the long story short, there�s no way, absent an invoice, to objectively determine that the value claimed as a deduction was the value that the charity received. When you�re donating your professional services it�s widely understood that you�re donating your time. Unfortunately, there isn�t any way to objectively value your time so you don�t get to deduct it.
The tax laws aren�t written to make it difficult to give to charity, they�re written to make it difficult for the scofflaws to cheat on their taxes. Nor are the laws written to make it easy for the 90% of the population who do the right things, they�re written for the 10% that are always trying to �work an angle�. Unfortunately, the Law of Unintended Consequences is constantly in play and the over-bearing burden that the 90% suffer to comply with a system designed to ferret out the cheats tends to stifle the activity. Of course, I do wonder how many of the consequences were actually unintended�