Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Tax question

Posts

Tax question

#1

Tax question

John T

>Too late for this year, I know.....

Last year, i made some small items as a donation to a fund raiser for my child's school. Pull toys, a turned platter - that sort of thing.

Not much outlay on my part for the materials, somewhat more of an investment in time to actually make the things.

I know that they "sold" in a silent auction for alot more than I thought they would.

I'm wondering if it's possible to subtract these items as a charitable donation to the school somehow. Can I deduct the cost of materials (almost nothing), or materials plus time (better), or the amount they garnered at auction??

I earn my real money doing things unrelated to woodworking, so this would be simply a charitable donation, not any kind of business deduction.

Thanks in advance for any replies.

-John-

Re: Tax question

#2

Re: Tax question

North of the Border

>" the amount they garnered at auction" - it seems the amount collected in the auction shouldn't have anything to do with your tax return, that's something for the Charity to account for.

Re: Tax question

#3

Re: Tax question

John Veerkamp,Western Mo

>John,

I donate turnings to my Grandson's private school for their yearly silent auction and bazzare. The school gives me a charitable donation receipt for the amount I say the items are worth. This amount qualifies as a tax deduction on your individual income tax return If you itemize deductions. There is a specific section for charitable deductions. There are deduction limits,m but I doubt these items will exceed those limits.

John

Re: Tax question

#4

Thanks John + Woodguy

John T

>Thanks for the responses.

I was just wondering if there was a good way to place a $ amount on the items. I don't ever sell anything I make, so I have no idea what the going price would be for my "work". I'm just knwocking out some things for the church school to sell....

Guess I'll just make up a number next year and add it to my other charitable contributions.

Thanks again.

-John-

Re: Tax question

#5

Watchit, John

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Artists are NOT allowed a deduction for the value of their donated artwork. They are allowed the price of materials used, but nothing for the time and intrinsic value of the item produced. Basic reason here is tax fraud by artists going back many years and litigation costs to the Government to overturn deductions.

"But," you say, "if Gates can donate a $Million to this charity and get a deduction for it, why can't I do the same with my "million dollar masterpiece?" Answer is Gates is giving money with an "objective" value of the full million. You, on the other hand, are making a donation with a "subjective" value which might be a $Million and might be only a "$mil" depending on whom you're talking to. "But," you say, "the charity took my piece and sold it for a million. That proves its value and my right to the deduction!" "Nope," sez The Man, "People habitually vastly overpay for stuff sold by charities in order to help the cause." ( Been to an AAW Symposium auction lately?) The measure is not what it may be worth to the charity, but rather what your gift is worth on the open market when you give it. Hence the materials cost standard. Tax man says, in reply to your heartfelt protest, "If you really want to help this charity (but also get a tax benefit), sell your piece for the $$$million you say it's worth, and then donate the cash to the charity; easier on the charity, easier on me (the tax man)."

As a sculptor and an attorney who's looked at it from both sides, I'll opine that artists will continue . . .

To be screwed by the Tax Man.

Re: Tax question

#6

But Mark

Don Evans

>But Mark:

You've combined two separate things into one here!

Regarding tax write offs, one is an artist who has a business and is taking the charity contribution as a business write off, which you addessed correctly, material cost only.

The other thing is what he was asking about, John Q public, not in business, but an individual who is contributing something to a charity and that is different.

The logical thing for him to do is just forget it! Large charity contributions on an individual tax return is a red flag for an audit by IRS. My guess here is the amount of money isn't worth that chance. For the original poster, generally if you declare over $200.00 as charity contribution (national average) then you are raising a red flag to get audited. If you are an average working stiff like most of us on a salary then it's best to not try to get too creative. If you are in the 23 percent tax range and your piece sold for 200.00 you are only getting a deduction of $46.00 isn't worth wondering about.

I have a friend who had a very creative tax guy. Tax guy says you can deduct cleaning your uniforms cause city requires you to have them. IRS said (after this was done for 5 years) come in and talk with us.

Ended up costing interest over time, penalties, etc, very expense lesson.

Don

Re: Tax question

#7

Paradox

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Not talking about business "write-offs" but rather deductions for donations. When I was an actively practicing sculptor, I contributed time and effort to several charities including doing several commemorative pieces for their fund raising efforts. Tax Man said "Nice work. Must have taken a bunch of time, but all you get is a warm fuzzy; nothing off your taxes, Bub."

Became a lawyer. Contributed over $40,000 in services to do all the legal work to establish and run a local charity formed to build a community playground. Same deal; warm fuzzy, no break.

Under the rules (as explained to me):

1. I could have arranged for a donor to pay me to do the sculpture which he then would donate to the charity and get a charitable deduction for what he paid me. I could then donate what I was paid to the charity and get a deduction for that monetary donation. Huh? Two deductions for the same donation?

2. In the case of my legal work, I could have been paid by the playground charity and then taken the same dollars and made a tax deductible donation. Charity then comes out "even" and I get to take a chunk off my taxes.

Go Figure.

Re: Tax question

#8

You're overlooking the obvious

Curly Smith

>In your first example, you actually have one deduction for each of the two donations. You have to declare the money paid to you by the donor as income before you can claim the charitable deduction. Since you don't get a dollar reduction in your taxes for each dollar donated, the IRS actually comes out ahead in this case since the donor already paid taxes on the original income.

The same situation holds for the second example, you have to declare the amount paid to you by the charity as income and pay the applicable taxes on that income.

You should note that in both examples you actually lose money. At the end of the day you have nothing to show from the income that you declared, since you donated the full amount to charity, but you paid taxes on that income. In other words, you donated $40k of your time to the charity plus the taxes on $40k to the IRS. It's cheaper to just donate the $40k to the charity and walk away.

Re: Tax question

#9

Obvious

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Curly, my approach is from the policy view of encouraging charitable donations which is, after all, the whole point. If I give a charity $x,000 in free services, carefully logged and "auditable" at my normal charge, that they would otherwise have to pay for, I should not be treated any differently than the next guy who gives the exact same amount in cash. The benefit to the charity is exactly the same from both gifts. Yes, in each prior example I know I have to pay tax on the income I receive, but requiring me to do so is a disincentive for me to make the donation to begin with. The only thing accomplished by my hypothetical sculpture donor is a determination of what the original gift was really worth at the expense of a much more complicated process.

When so many people are struggling in a faltering economy and charities are being called upon to shoulder bigger and bigger burdens, we should be looking for ways to encourage and simplify donations.

Of course, the obvious reply is, "Are you making the gift for the benefit of the charity or for the tax deduction? If your motive is really charitable, it shouldn't matter whether you get a deduction or not, right?" My answer is, "Quite true, however it's not about the giving, but rather the lack of equality in the tax treatment that flows from the two equal gifts, whatever their form, that's wrong, in my view."

peace

Re: Tax question

#10

Re: Watchit, John

Stew Pharis

>Mark is absolutely correct. In your case, the charitable deduction would be limited to the cost of materials. It may not make sense, seem logical, or seem fair. However, that's the way it is.

Remember that if you decide to take a deduction, you need to be sure you have documentation of the cost of materials. The IRS is not going to take your word for it in the unfortunate event of an audit.

Re: Tax question

#11

Re: Obvious

Curly Smith

>I think you resolved the dilemma when you above talked about subjective and objective values.

Consider, without an invoice how do you determine the objective value of a service? Sure, you can claim that you donated $40k of professional services, and I�m in no way implying that you didn�t, but was that based on billable or actual hours? We all know that those numbers can be, and usually are, vastly different and a system that allowed you to simply deduct billable hours would be rife with fraud potential.

If we can agree that only actual hours should be used, how do we then determine the hourly rate? Most people would assume that charitable work occurs outside of normal working hours so your normal hourly rate that�s designed to cover labor, burden, overhead, facility costs, consumables and profit is likely not applicable. After all, should you �profit� from charity work? How about that health insurance� isn�t it fully covered during the normal working hours? Facility costs� yep, they�re paid for during normal working hours. What about salary� should you really be paid for the work when your �day job� already pays you? So we then need to re-evaluate the hourly rate to determine what cost components are applicable for charity work and, ultimately, you get to the point where only consumables (e.g. materials and utilities) should be deductible for work outside of normal working hours.

Costing work conducted during normal hours is equally, if not more, problematic. How do you account for the overhead portion? You can�t deduct the value of other people�s time, because that�s theirs to donate, nor can you expect them to work for free while you�re engaged in your charitable giving because that�s tantamount to slavery. Should you always charge for labor or should you only charge if you�ve turned away work (lost opportunity cost)? What about facilities? Sure, the rent and taxes need to be paid but should you only charge if the billable hours don�t meet the threshold requirement to stay in business? How do you develop a charge system that transparently excludes the potential for double-dipping and yet is maintained solely by the taxpayer claiming the charitable deduction?

To make the long story short, there�s no way, absent an invoice, to objectively determine that the value claimed as a deduction was the value that the charity received. When you�re donating your professional services it�s widely understood that you�re donating your time. Unfortunately, there isn�t any way to objectively value your time so you don�t get to deduct it.

The tax laws aren�t written to make it difficult to give to charity, they�re written to make it difficult for the scofflaws to cheat on their taxes. Nor are the laws written to make it easy for the 90% of the population who do the right things, they�re written for the 10% that are always trying to �work an angle�. Unfortunately, the Law of Unintended Consequences is constantly in play and the over-bearing burden that the 90% suffer to comply with a system designed to ferret out the cheats tends to stifle the activity. Of course, I do wonder how many of the consequences were actually unintended�

Re: Tax question

#12

Sorry I touched a nerve..

John T

>Thanks for your replies, Mark, Curly, and others.

Never thought this would spawn such a long thread.

Clearly, my case is in the negligible category, since the materials were essentially free. OK. They were free, since I stole them from a neighbors firewood pile....

So, I guess I won't be getting that major deduction next year, as I'd hoped. And I surely don't want to put up any flags for the IRS auditors....

Sorry to have stirred up the hornets nest.

Cheers.

-John-

Re: Tax question

#13

Nerve

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>No nerve John. Well maybe something of a pet peave. Just didn't want to see you (or another reader) get hammered by the bean counter police. Leave it to the Land of the Free to have more laws than most anyone and a tax code that takes an advanced degree to even attempt to understand, let alone comply with.

Re: Tax question

#14

Housing the Homeless.......

Barry Irby

>Dogs that is. As a Home Inspector, a Realtor hammered me to make a doghouse to donate to some charity that took them out and put them in place for dogs that did not have houses. (I know, I did not understand it either. Where did they find such dogs and how exactly did this work?) I did not really care. My point was to score points with a large Real Estate company and get more home inspections. So I went to Lowe's and talked to the manager. He bought into my second hand sob story and gave me the materials. Damaged and careworn stuff they would have sold at a huge discount, but he gave it to me, none the less. I built the doghouse and the do gooders came and carried it away. (Building a doghouse might be fun, delivering it to a homeless dog in a bullet riddled neighborhood, not so much.) So over a couple of years, I built about a dozen. To keep it fun, I got creative. Hyperbolic paraboloids, round ones, triangular ones, what ever struck my fancy. Why did I stop you might ask? I started to find my dog houses in the yards of the do gooders and Realtors. Never did take the tax deductions for them. They left me paper work saying I could, but it did not seem worth it.

Re: Tax question

#15

No nerve touch here!

Don Evans

>Don't appologize John!

We all learn from discussions such as this. In fact sometimes I'll make a statement just to see what the answers are that come back.

I try to never ever make a know INCORRECT statement however.

Don

Re: Tax question

#16

Agreed

Curly Smith

>The only nerve you touched with me is our Byzantine and indecipherable tax code. But, whenever you start thinking about taxes and deductions it's important to remember who you're really working for. Even if you're self-employed, you spend the first 4 months of the year working for the IRS, the next 2-3 months working for the State and Local governments, the next 2-3 months working for insurance companies, and then you can start earning money to pay your mortgage, make your car payments, save for the kid's college fund, buy groceries, save for your retirement, etc. Just a you'd resist any effort by your employer to reduce your take-home, so will the various taxing entities resist any effort by you to reduce their take-home. And, unless you're a Treasury Secretary, a minor mistake by you can be extremely costly.

Re: Tax question

#17

Better Idea

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Send those "beneficiaries" a bill for your services referencing their misappropriation of the "donated" units. Would it surprise you if some prosecutor came knocking on YOUR door because of an allegation that you bribed the agents to get their inspection business by making them free doghouses?

It would?

I can see the headline now . . . .

HOME INSPECTOR IN DOGHOUSE OVER PAY-TO-PLAY SCHEME WITH LOCAL REALTORS

Dateline Irbyville: In an unusual example of how tough the real estate business and allied services have become in this economic downturn, a local home inspector has been indicted along with employees of 4 real estate offices in connection with a scheme to get an inside track on the lucrative home inspections side of the dwindling real estate sales market. The indicted inspector is alleged to have provided unique, custom made outbuildings to the real estate people completely free of charge in exchange for preferential retention of the inspector on pre-closing deals being handled by the realtors. The scheme appears to go back over several years involving thousands of dollars in home inspections. To make matters even worse, the investigation reached into the pockets of several major building materials dealers when the inspector apparently conned sympathetic managers at the Lowe's and Home Deport stores into actually giving him free materials to make the structures. The manager of one store is quoted as saying "Geez, nice guy came in with a very convincing story about making small houses for homeless dogs because the shelters are overloaded. We always try to assist local volunteers, so I got clearance from corporate to give him whatever he needed, but to use the discount rack stuff first. Guess you can't really trust people any more, eh?" The prosecutor mentioned that the dog charity bit was pretty creative, and that the inspector had tried to sell the same story when he testified before the Grand Jury. "I didn't buy it, and neither did the Grand Jury," he said. The home inspector did not return calls made to both his home and business phones.

|;-}}}}

Barry, I get the distinct impression that you got took, 'Ol Bud.

Re: Tax question

#18

Re: Housing the Homeless.......

Fred Davis

>Barry, though you did not do it for altruistic reason , making a house for a dog is a worthwhile task.

We provide a home for up to four horses at a time that their owners either wouldn't or couldn't no longer care for and in some instances should have never had a horse to begin with .

We buried one this past Wednesday who developed Pituitary gland cancer , his bone marrow was nearly non existent and he had lost five hundred pounds in the last four months.

But his final two years on earth were much better then his first twenty .

BTW , you really need to find a different term then "do gooders" to describe people who care for animals.

FredD

Re: Tax question

#19

Geez, that's well done, Mark_______

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>

Re: Tax question

#20

Re: Stew has a point

Brian in Brighton

>Stew and Mark both make a point, your time and mine are worth nada, nothing, zilch, zero to the IRS. I had a customer stiff me on some engineering. 1 accountant and 1 tax lawyer both told me the same thing. I can deduct my actual costs as a loss, not my time. Since I was selling nothing but my time at that time I lost almost 100%. All I could do was deduct the loss as an uncollectable debt, not as much, but better than nothing.

Moral of the story, as our tax code stinks, is that you can deduct the materials and any money out of pocket, but not your time loss. I wonder if it would apply if one of your employees did the charity work? I guess you would be able to deduct their wages and materials. I would guess at that point that you could not deduct your shop rate, just cost out of pocket.

Wish they would just simplify it with a flat tax. :-(

Brian in Brighton

Re: Tax question

#21

Just Wish It Was

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Funny as well, but I've been involved in several cases where just that sort of thing happened with honest people innocently doing something to (they thought) help another human being that got twisted around, misunderstood, and ultimately perverted by others, and then had the attempt made to blame them. Turned out okay in the end, but their lives were a real sh..storm for about 6 months, and all they got from the authorities in the end was "Sorry."

m