Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

gear oil Delta planer

Posts

gear oil Delta planer

#1

gear oil Delta planer

eliot d

>I'm supposed to use SAE 85/140 non detergent gear oil in my Delta planner. I believe I've had Pennzoil 80/140 detergent in there for about a year, but I haven't used the planner much. Two questions, please: (1) Do you think I've damaged the planner with what I've used? (2) Short of ordering the Delta product and waiting and paying shipping, what would be a good 85/140 gear oil to purchase in, say, a local auto parts store? I also believe the oil should have extreme pressure rating.

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#2

Re: gear oil Delta planer

GalenV in Iowa

>The detergent gear lube will not hurt your planer. Additives are added to control sludge buildup in internal combustion engines.

The gear lube is extreme pressure type lubricant GL-5.

You should be able to find Shell Spirax 85W 140 or Champion HD All Purpose 85W 140. You probably will not find in automotive supplies but more in line with heavy duty fleet and off road heavy equipment dealers. You might ask at a truck stop service as you may find there.

Galen

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#3

Re: gear oil Delta planer

eliot d

>I really appreciate your response; and I, too, couldn't see what's the big deal about using a non-detergent oil. But here's the thing: I checked with a Pennzoil rep, a Delta rep, and a local auto mechanic; and they all explained to me that if there are any so-called yellow metals in the gear unit( which there are in the Delta planner feed-gear drive), there could be trouble with detergent oils. The yellow metals are either bronze or brass plated softer metals used for smoother and less noisy operation, and such metals can become pitted and worn by detergents. Auto stuff uses harder steel gears; so no problem with detergents. When I asked Delta about ordering their non detergent oil product, I found out that it costs over $32, with shipping, for a mere PINT -- not even a quart! So, I'm still looking for a reasonably priced 85/140 extreme pressure non detergent oil. Are any of the ones you were good enough to suggest non detergent?

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#4

Re: gear oil Delta planer

GalenV in Iowa

>I don't believe either of the gear lubs are detergent additives but are EP additives. You can probably find Quaker State as well as it is a Shell Oil Division. The detergent oil additives that they say may be harmful to bronze is a new one for me. Detergents help neutralize the acidity to combustion byproducts so must be more base. I do know they say sulphur in EP additives MIGHT promote corrosion to bronze worm gears. Never hurt bronze sycronizer gears in manual transmissions that I know of. EP used for lubes in a lot of bronze worm gear reducer boxes we used in drives and I know some had sulphur.

Often wonder if you are told things based on what they have or have not got to sell you.

You can get a hundred differnt stories on what oil to put in a motorcycle too but that is a story for another day.

Galen

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#5

Re: gear oil Delta planer------WebKitFormBoundaryy

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Thanks again. Now I'm determined to try to get to the bottom of it; i.e. just , exactly, what is detergent oil supposed to do to yellow metals? If I find out, I'll pass it on.

------WebKitFormBoundaryyRGohHF0K+1mjzoW

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#6

Re: gear oil Delta planer

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Hi Galen. Apparently you were right all along. A Delta person gave me the wrong scoop, namely that automotive gear oil contains detergents. And the automotive store people told me the same thing. It now turns out that gear oils don't have detergents; it's automotive MOTOR oils that nearly all have detergents today. So the Pennzoil SAE 80W-140 that I already have is o.k. but , again, apparently, an even better choice would be Mobil 600 XP 460. The 460 refers to an ISO rating of 460, which is equivalent to the 140 viscosity of the Pennzoil. The XP means it has some extreme pressure additives. So thanks for giving me pause so that I could look into it more. But I still haven't found out why detergents are supposed to harm softer yellow metals. I'm beginning to think that it's not detergents that would do any harm but , rather, the sulphur in the extreme pressure additives.

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#7

Re: gear oil Delta planer

GalenV in Iowa

>Eliot

There is something about Mobil 600 that is rattling my brain.

Even though it has extreme pressure additive I was thinking that it is not recommended for worm gearing. may not be a problem for you. Spur, helical or bevel I think is what it is for. Maybe it has to do with an additive that could effect bronze worm gears like used in some Winsmith and Cone-drive gear boxes. Just one of those things I cannot remember since I gave up working for a living.

As a side story I had an old Briggs power mower with a bad crank lower seal. Lost to much 30w oil so I had some 80W manual transmision oil and used it. Left the SAME heavy oil in it for about 8 years!! Ran fine! (Well broke the connecting rod in the end but does that count? :>)

Galen

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#8

Found this and may answer question

GalenV in Iowa

>Extreme Pressure (EP) oils:

These are inhibited oils with added extreme pressure additives. The EP agent is a friction modifier,

and there are two basic types of agents:

Chemically Active:

Chemically active additive sulfur phosphorous, which reacts with gear tooth surface material under

high temperature to form thin film of easily, sheared material. The second type of EP agent is solid

lubricant in suspension. The solid particles (such as graphite, molybdenum disulfide, borate, etc.)

get between tooth surfaces and prevent metal-to-metal contact. If bearings are to be lubricated

from the same system, some caution is required. Active EP agents must be noncorrosive to bronze

if any is present in the bearing. Solid lubricant additives may reduce internal clearance in low

clearance, precision bearings causing high temperature, self-loading and probable failure.

Did not copy/paste well!

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#9

Re: Found this and may answer question

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I can't thank you enough for looking into all this , but now I'm afraid that I'm more confused than ever. Bottom line for me is that I just put in Pennzoil SAE 80W / 140 and it worked fine.I did add some militec additive, which is used extensively in the military for smoother gun operation. I would even say that the feed seemed to work better than before. Still, am I damaging the gears somehow?

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#10

I think your fine with what you have done.

GalenV in Iowa

>If your spec was for 85W140 gear lube and you used 80W140 I don't think the slight differnce in viscosity will hurt. Hey it will run if it is out in the cold a little better.

The Penzoil I would imagine is their Gearplus which is about all that has that weight (maybe Long Life EW)that both meet the GL-5 API spec for extreme pressure lub.

I don't think they really call Militec an "additive" as such. I believe it is like 30W but does not alter the gear oil. It really would not do anything to alter the metal as it never probably gets hot enough. Think that is the stuff they say makes a molecular bond to metal at high temp and creates a smoother bearing surface. Not sure I would have put it in though.

Maybe if you were going to run it for production type work and long runs the 80 verses 85 would come into play.

Hey but then the machine is not mine so if it breaks down it doesn't hurt me :>)

Nice not to have to deal with gearboxes and lubs now from Peerless/Winsmith, Cone Drive, Eurodrive, Browning, Steel City and the like. Most could never keep their lubrication recomendations up to date and listed manufactures not available in regions of US.

Oh yah I don't work anymore, why worry!

Galen

Galen

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#11

Re: I think your fine with what you have done.

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I like your relaxed sense of humor. Nice to be retired. I am, too. Don't care much about anything now except family, my bull dog, and woodworking -- mostly turning. The project I am working on with the planner is to make a kind of table that attaches to a wheel chair for a lady who can hardly move a muscle. No charge to her for my time. What else do I have to do?

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#12

Re: I think your fine with what you have done.

GalenV in Iowa

>Sounds like a worth while project.

Retirement was not really planed by me but now I need to enjoy it.

Heart bypass surgery two years ago but it did not work well and one of four is still open. My ticker runs kinda poorly and in turn slows me down from what I would like to be doing.

Took up learning to turn and hard part is not being able to cut green wood on my own to turn.

Waiting on the oil to dry on a bowl I finished turning the foot this AM.

Good luck on your project and I know she will appriciate it.

Galen

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#13

Re: I think your fine with what you have done.

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I turn a lot. Have you joined any wood turning clubs? Most of them have members bringing in turning blanks -- often green-- to either give away or buy really cheaply. Usually some kind of silent auction kind of thing. So you really don't have to lug your chain saw around. The only disadvantage to it is that you can't choose the grain orientation exactly the way you want it when you buy something already cut.

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#14

Wood for turning.

GalenV in Iowa

>Eliot

I joined the Ames Woodworkers club and attend the monthly meetings if health is up to it. We meet this Sunday but so far a topic to cover has not been set! Made a Hunter clone the last meeting and used it to finish a bowl I had kinda given up on before. Honey Locust they cut down by the town home I'm in. Dried to like concrete.

I just glued up some 4/4 purchased wood to make pieces large enough to turn end grain lidded boxes.

I was given a few pieces of box elder by one of the experienced turners in the club and turned a few bowls and smaller hollow forms. The red coloration in the wood was nice to see what I could do.

Went back later and added a lid and finial of bloodwood to help set off the box elder. First time doing finials so that was an experience.

I will have to ask if anyone has "spare" wood to turn. Never sure what to offer for turning wood. Our somewhat local Woodsmith store has some pieces for turning but most are cracked and checked and in turn are just not worth buying.

Thanks for your comment.

Galen

Re: gear oil Delta planer

#15

Re: Late to this party

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>and I haven't read what others have said, so I'm really likely to step in it somehow.

Here, when people find that you're looking for wood to use, it shows up. Lots of it.

In my stash right now, there is free walnut, black acacia, ironbark euchalyptus, african mahoghany, cherry, ash, tan oak, red oak, redwood, and several other types of stuff. More than I can use, really. I pass this on to others who want to turn or work it as they need or want.

Lately, only for special projects, have I spent more than $100 on wood. Which is good, because there are always other things that need spending on.

I doubt my group is that much different than most of the others. Except we don't heat with wood much here that often.

Arborists are a great resource. Buy several of them breakfast some day.