Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Red Oak bleed back problem

Posts

Red Oak bleed back problem

#1

Red Oak bleed back problem

Bernard

>On other posts I have received a lot of great advice on my current project, my first with red oak. I am going to start this week with my experiments on "firewood" with various combinations of dye, stain, etc. But I had one question. It has been recommended to apply dewaxed shellec (SealCoat) after staining and before applying the finish (toss up right now between shellac and water poly, either Varathane or General Finishes), but I was wondering if it is a good idea to apply a very dilute coat of SealCoat BEFORE the dye and/or stain, to help seal it up a little to cut down on the bleed back, or whether that makes no sense at all.

Any advice to this amateur hoping to get better is most greatly appreciated.

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

#2

Not a bad idea, but...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>...it will drastically alter the look of the stained surfaces. If you just want to keep stain and finish out of the pores, you could apply the shellac and then sand it back to raw wood, leaving the shellac just in the pores. Personally, I wouldn't bother. Sanding shellac is a gummy, thankless task.

Ellis

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

#3

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I've tried using some sealcoats beneath a stain to limit blotching on woods like poplar. However, you may need to coat more times with stain to get the absorbtion you want (sealcoat will block it). I don't know that you'd need to seal oak first as it doesn't have a blotching problem.

Sealing after the stain - well, I've had bleedback when I use wipe on poly over stain, but usually just the first coat. i.e. the wiping wrag shows some stain color lifted off. Usually only happens on the first coat, though.

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

#4

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

Howard Acheson

>You can greatly reduce the bleed back by not flooding any oil based stain onto the surface. The bleed back is only an issue with oil based stains. Put the stain in a flat, wide pan and just dip a cloth or paper shop towel into the stain. Wipe the stain on so the surface is damp, not soaked. Let it set only a couple of minutes and then wipe off the excess. This way, the oil is not forced down into the pores and bleed back should be minimal.

That said, always give oil based stain 4-5 days to fully cure before overcoating with any film finish.

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

#5

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

T Rex

>My wife is my finisher. She uses a MinWax stain, either red oak or gloden pecan. She puts it on with a blue paper towel. Then she will apply MinWax poly with a blue paper towel the next day or when she has time. I use steel wool between coats of poly. What is wrong with what we are doing? It seems so simple. We never had a stain bleeding problem.

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

#6

I agree...BTW what is your secret?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There has been excessive fretting on this project. I have never experienced "bleed back" nor ever heard of any one else worrying over it either. Our customers finished mountains of oak cabinets with oil stain and lacquer and I didn't see them doing anything special. Once an oil stain has cured it stays put in my experience, and ditto for filler. I think oak is the easiest of any wood to get to look good. For me the only necessary oak choices are stain color and do I want to fill the grain.

Now, how does one get wife to become the family finisher? I know that it was common in shops of old times for the females to do the finishing. But the techniques to develop this situation have eluded me.

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

#7

Re: Bill, you are 100% right

Bernard

>I came to the same conclusion tonight, that I have just stressed too much over the finishing of this project. I think I have allowed myself to listen to too many people forecasting doom, elucidating every possible problem that I can or will encounter when trying to stain and finish it, that it has raised my stress level and caused me to overthink, especially since I have had to squeeze in precious little time (an hour or so per day on average) because I have been (fortunately) swamped at the job I get paid for.

Well, the time for thinking is over, time to step back for a second, have a single malt and relax, and get back to work tomorrow with my experimentation with stains, and lose myself in the soothing sounds of life such as the growl of the saw, the whirr of of the drill, and the roar of the router.

Thanks.

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

#8

So, Maybe She Went To Finishing School?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Red Oak bleed back problem

#9

Re: I agree...BTW what is your secret?

T Rex

>I guess my wife is from the "old times".

The main reason she does it is because I applied the finish to the first project I made and she told me that she would do the rest of my projects.

She's a good gal.