Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

Posts

Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#1

Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I'm finishing my PA Spice box cabinet which is made from walnut. My plan is to use only shellac (gonna try mixing my own for this one). I sanded the whole project up to 220. As I did, I noticed that the wood seemed to lighten and look a little muddy. Is this something common with walnut or is my sanding not up to par. I'm being patient on this project and I'll try a few things on scraps before doing the final finish.

For the shellac, I would like to try using super blond, blond and amber just to see how each turns out. I've read that using an oil on walnut can be a bit touchy (could get blotchy) but that shellac produces a very good finish. I've read that amber gives a nice warmth to the wood and brings out the character.

I'll follow up the shellac with a good coat or two of paste wax.

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#2

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems mudd

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Walnut isn't any different to sand than any thing else, and easier than maple for example.

I start at 100 or 120 and most of the time should be spent with the first grit. It needs to remove all glaze from machining and torn grain as well as level the surface. At 120 grit you should not see any trapped sawdust, ie. no dull areas. Trapped dust (dullness) indicates torn grain that will trap stain later down the road and make dark places.

It would be helpful to know what was done leading up to 220 grit. At 220 the surface should look fairly bright. I never sand beyond this grit.

A properly prepared surface will never be blotchy. Stain and/or oil will bring out the figure, which some inexperienced finishers could label blotchy. But if such people wanted the wood to look like it was painted then they should learn to spray NRG stain and all will be nice and uniform like a factory finish from China.

A classic reproduction finish for walnut would be flood with oil, wipe and let thoroughly dry (at least three days if warm and longer if cold). Then coat with one of the darker shellacs.

Personally I always oil stain walnut so that it stays walnut color and doesn't bleach out.

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#3

Lee Grindinger

Muddy? Is it steamed walnut?

Lee Grindinger

>Steamed walnut can have an appearance you might call muddy. In the long run it doesn't matter whether it's steamed or not but for a couple of years it can be noticed by trained eyes.

Was the walnut steamed?

Lee

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#4

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems mudd

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Sounds like you're not vacuuming or otherwise cleaning the surface each time you change grits. As an open-pore wood, walnut will get "filled" with dust and sanding grit along with uncomplete cut fibers if you push the paper too far. I'd suggest you vacuum your surfaces very well, then moisten the surface with a damp rag to get a grain raise. Follow with resanding with fresh sharp paper. Vacuum again. Raise the grain again, but this time lightly spray with fresh 3/4lb cut dewaxed shellac which works like hair spray and will keep the fibers up so they can be cut by fresh abrasives. Then a final vacuuming.

[psssst - Not to confuse you, but walnut also responds beautifully to a freshly sharpened (and burred) cabinet scraper.]

I think you'll see a big difference over what you have now.

On your finishing proposal: If you want to go the shellac route, I strongly recommend you move to the darker tones like dark garnet.

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#5

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems mudd

Kelly Anderson

>I am not sure about your sanding problem but my favorite finish so far for walnut is blo followed by regular old Zinssers' amber shellac. It has looked great on everything that I have used it on.

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#6

A picture is worth a thousand words

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>So I'll add a picture of what I'm seeing, as I think I may be making a big deal out of nothing. This picture is the side and the feet sanded to 220 grit (yeah I know, got a few scratches - the box was traveling a bit). As I sanded, I noticed that the grain just didn't look as pronounced.

So, I took some scrap, sanded from 120-150-220 (I'm out of 180!) and it looked about the same. Then I tried wiping on just a touch of mineral spirits and it looked great - all the figure came right back out and it didn't look dull or muddy at all.

So, the picture is here anyway.

One other question - after a wipe with mineral spirits do I do anything other than let it dry?

Thanks!


img

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#7

Sample before mineral spirits

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Just for yucks, I'll add the before/after shots of the sample. Pretty easy to see where I sanded to. Looks pretty dull all around.


img

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#8

Sample after

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Wow, definite difference. Bit of curl in there too!


img

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#9

Bull's Eye Problems

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"Regular Old Zinsser's" is actually waxy orange shellac. Three issues that I have seen/had:

1. Waxy (not dewaxed) shellac is a softer finish that is much more susceptible to water damage. Waxy shellacs are, however, actually preferred by instrument makers because the finish is softer and may (I'm told) enhance the sound.

2. Waxy shellac ages (esterifies) more quickly in the can, and may sit on shelves too long to use as a finish.

3. Waxy shellac will not work as a sealer or base coat for waterborne finishes because the wax content creates adhesion and cold checking problems. If you try to top coat with a waterborne later, you'll have to either remove all of the old finish (alcohol bath) or reseal the shellac under a compatible coating. Simply top sealing with dewaxed shellac may or may not work because the reamalgamation effect of the new application may bring wax to the surface.

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#10

Re: Bull's Eye Problems

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I'm going to try making up my own shellac this time around. I have de-waxed flakes.

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#11

Re: Sample after

Chuck Bender

>Steve,

Are you hand sanding or using a random orbit? Sanding walnut always fills the pores up with dust making it look cloudy in the raw. As you see when you apply a thinner, it clear right up. cleaning the surface really well prior to applying color and/or finish will help greatly. Take your time and get the finish right. You did a great job on your spice box so you want get it right...the first time. If you need help, you know how to reach me.

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#12

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems mudd

Jim Dillon

>Stephen,

In my very limited experience with sanding and finishing walnut, I've been happy with sanding to 220, then applying a coat of orange dewaxed shellac (Homestead Finishing) 1# cut, followed by several coats of an oil/varnish blend (Tried and True), then followed by a coat of wax. As others have mentioned, I also clean the wood between grits. I think I got the suggestion to use orange shellac from an article by Jeff Jewitt in FWW.

Jim

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#13

Re: Sample after

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Thanks. I'll look you up if I face any problems. Among the other firsts for me on this project (like the whole half blind dovetail thing) this is my first main use of walnut, so the way the pores filled kinda surprised me. Now that I see it, I know how to deal with it. I'm looking forward to mixing up a few batches of shellac to see how it finishes up. And yes, I'm going with making my own shellac - I'm tired of getting a can, using a few ounces, then throwing it away a year later. I figure I stepped up my game on other places in this project, why not push my finishing skills a bit too.

Oh, and yes, I'm wondering about the finishing class now :-)

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems muddy

#14

Re: Question finishing walnut - sanding seems mudd

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I think I saw that same article. I figure I'll sand a bunch of a board, tape off a few sections and try multiple finishes to see what I like for the project. This is some nice expirementation for me. I'll try to get some good pics and post them, maybe it'll be useful to others.