We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Taking the advice I have received on this board so far, I have decided to finish my bookcase project (red oak boards and oak plywood) with dye, followed by stain, a coat of dewaxed shellac, and then finish with either shellac or Varathane Diamond. I will try all these combinations on both the boards and plywood, and then proceed accordingly.
I have assembled all my "firewood" as Ellis calls it, to get ready for the experimentation. I have two different tints of brown dye (I will try each alone, and perhaps variations in combo), and then will followup with one of 2 stains, etc. Long process, but after all the work going into the project, I want to make sure the finish is good.
Due to all the permutations possible, I would like to restrict myself to having to buy too many stains that will remain unused. I really want to use something available locally, so that I can get something quickly if I need it. I was going to use the Sherwin Williams stains, although Varathane stains and Minwax (and even Cabot) are available as well. In all reality, is any one brand much better or worse in terms of quality that the others?
I have to say that the help I have received so far on this site has proved invaluable in terms of confidence going forward, and was getting good information for a better project.
>Try just plain oil based stain first and see if that will suffice. Minwax has some nice oak shades. Sand to 180 grit. Put the stain on with a "rubber", similar to what is used to apply shellac. Make a ball of something absorbent (wool or cotton) and wrap it with a layer of something like worn blue jeans. Dip rubber in stain and apply with rubbing strokes. This technique will control take of stain on the wood. Wipe any excess off with another rag, but there should be little to no excess if applied optimally.
People have gotten into a heap of trouble with dye stains. It is not trivial to learn to get them on uniform. Personally I don't find them necessary to get oak the color I want. Now, if you ridiculously over sand oak so it won't take stain then a dye may be necessary.
The oak in PIC was stained with a Minwax oak of medium shade. I have done white oak darker. In any case the non porous parts are stained dark enough to suite me, without resorting to the perils of dye stain.
People can discuss relative differences/variations in "quality" between various stains forever and ever. I do agree with Bill about the oil based stains from minwax: they do a very nice job and are predictable. I generally seal the stained surface with shellac before applying my final top coat finishes. If you do what it talls you to do on the lable of the stain can, you will get acceptable results without too much wheel spinning.
>Almost all oil based pigment stains are made the same way in general. Pigment is a coloring that is not dissolved. Rather it's suspended in the liquid. Once the thinner evaporates, the residue (pigment) is left sitting on the surface of the wood. At this point, the pigment would be easily wiped right off. Therefore, manufacturers put a little bit of resin (varnish)in the mixture so it hardens and attaches the pigment to the surface of the wood.
The other common stain is a dye stain. Dyes are much, much smaller particles of color and actually dissolve into the water or oil medium. Because dyes are dissolved in their medium, dyes are absorbed into the wood rather than sitting on the surface.
So pigment stains and dye stains are quite different in how they react to or in the wood. Each will produce differing color effects. Pigments tend to partially obscure the grain of the wood while dyes are more transparent and do not obscure the grain. Different woods react differently to pigments and dyes.
My point is that "quality" is not really definable or relevant when referring to stains. Each stain has different characteristics but that is not an indication of quality.
Minwax Wood Finish oil based stains are somewhat unique in that Minwax mixes both pigments and dyes into their stain in varying proportions. Some of their colors are pure dye, some are pure pigment. When you open the can, the watery stuff on top is the oil, resin and solvent and the dye. The thick glop on the bottom of the can that you must stir in is the pigment component. When both dye and pigment is used to produce a color, you are ending up with a combination of colors. I find that Minwax Wood Finish is problematic on woods that tend to color unevenly.
So, when playing with stains you need to know what you want to accomplish. Sometimes, dye is the answer, sometimes pigment is the answer and sometimes dye followed by pigment is the way to go.
An example of the issues based on the species of wood is with red oak. Red oak has deep pores. Waterbased stains have the water characteristic of surface tension. This means that water based stain will not flow into the bottom of the pores. Instead a sort of bridge is formed part way down the pore. Once the water evaporates, you tend to be left with pores that are not colored. To overcome this, generally an oil based pigment stain is used or, after the waterbase stain has dried, an oil based stain or an oil based gel stain is applied. Red oak is also quite variable in color. Solid wood stains differently than the veneer of plywood so adjustments need to be made to get an even, overall color.
You are doing the right thing by testing. Use accurate measurement and keep accurate records of each step so you can recreate your work.
>I would consider testing and using a gel stain. Easier to control, and more consistent. The ones I've used were Olympic brands, although I can't say they are current. Those cans came from the sales rep a year ago or more, but they worked well last month...
The oil leak back issues with red oak make me really hesitant to recommend that you use the Minwax products. I gave all mine away years ago. But that just may be me, old crank that I can be.
I agree with you because I had an issue with Minwax golden oak stain 3 years ago on red oak. I think the oak is just too porous and the stain runs back out of the pores if they are oriented downward. This after I wiped it down for an hour after the initial application. Fortunately, I was able to lightly sand the area to blend it in with the rest of the project.
>As always, Howard's explanation of dye versus pigmented stain was spot on. I think he summed it up correctly when he said, and Ellis eluded to this also in his reply in the other thread, So, when playing with stains you need to know what you want to accomplish. Sometimes, dye is the answer, sometimes pigment is the answer and sometimes dye followed by pigment is the way to go.
I used Minwax stain on red oak for a long time and had the bleed back problems mentioned. Now that I've discovered and used Lockwood dyes, they're the only way to color red oak and woods with grain like it for me. However, I've also had occasions to use both NGR dye and oil-based stain to achieve the look I wanted on wood like poplar.
>In my time as a woodworker, I have utilized the full spectrum of methods to impart color to wood. It is a process that is ongoing, not toward an ideal, but as a process. There have been times when I was devoted to dyes, times when I advocated off the shelf commercial stains, times when I mixed my own stocks and custom colors, times when I'd stain and spray on layers of colors for effect etc.... I have never stuck with one scenario. My advice would be try, try, and try and never become restricted by a single process. Enjoy.
>.... of ways to stain or control the stain. What is successful for one is generally the result of becoming familiar with a process and sticking with it. Jumping all over with new, un-practiced processes will only lead to inconsistent results.
Unlike the processing of wood, finishing is a learned skill. Practice and experience is the only way to become a proficient finisher. It is almost always true that when first using a new product or process, the results will not be top notch. That's the reason most good finisher always test out their planned finishing schedule on scrap before committing to the actual project.
As I have said to finishing students, the finish is what gets the "oohs" and "ahhs", not the joinery. Learn to be a good finisher if you want to really showcase your work.
>>> The oil leak back issues with red oak make me really hesitant to recommend that you use the Minwax products
Not necessarily to defend Minwax stains but the bleed-back issue is a function of the oil in the stain, not the stain itself. For example, Watco Danish Oil will bleed-back on red oak as will Minwax Tung Oil Finish. Any in-the-wood oil finish will bleed-back. The oil generates heat as it cures (polymerizes)which causes the still liquid oil to expand and be forced up and out of the pores.
>and that's one major reason I'm doing this current project in tanoak, and doing a dye/varnish finish. Looks like oak, comes very close to the variety of oak furniture and trim already in the building, but finishes more easily...
>Thanks to everybody for the input. A lot of great advice from everyone (as usual). Howard, a lot of great info, but your second post especially resonated with me: "What is successful for one is generally the result of becoming familiar with a process and sticking with it"...that makes so much common sense that we forget that. Frankly, although I am forcing myself to include dyes in my testing (later this week), I am most comfortable with wiping stains, except mostly with other woods such as maple, never red oak. I have read about using ClearCoat on the wood AFTER applying the stain and before applying the finish, although I am wondering about applying some BEFORE the dye and/or stain in some of my testing, and whether that will help with color uniformity (and the bleed back problem that many have had) or be a disaster. I guess testing will tell.
Thanks again to everybody for taking the time to post your thoughts: I just wanted you all to know that it is not time wasted, because they are all greatly appreciated and help amateurs like me hone our skills.