Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT: Drywall primer

Posts

OT: Drywall primer

#1

OT: Drywall primer

Ben Ragusa, S Jersey

>Sorry to go off topic, but I know there are some expert painters here and I would like their advice. I need to prime a fair amount of drywall this weekend, about 6 rooms. Questions: Should I buy cheap primer at the box store, or get more expensive stuff? Is there a significant diffference? I expect the drywall to drink up paint, so can I stretch the primer by adding in leftover flat wall paint? Or not a good idea?

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#2

Don't go "cheap" ! . . .

steve mackay

>Been there done that ! Spend the money the FIRST TIME. I know it hurts but its wprth it. Two coats of "KILZ" and you'll LOVE the results. Honest !

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#3

Re: OT: Drywall primer

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach, FL

>I'll leave the answer to the question you asked to Jason or another pro. However, with that much to prime/paint, and with fresh drywall, assuming you have bare rooms to deal with, I highly recommend renting a sprayer. Six years ago it cost me about $60 for the day when I needed to paint the ceilings in my new old house and it's the best money I ever spent.

Do not fall for one of the Wagner buzz boxes. I'm talking about a real sprayer like they hang five gallon buckets from (you don't need five gallons to use it, though).

If you have carpets and/or furniture to deal with, that may be another story, but if you can spray, you can turn an all day job into a one or two hour job.

Rod

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#4

Re: OT: Drywall primer

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Amen to the sprayer! I was converted by the Binks, years ago, doing many houses (for an amateur).

As to product, primer is cheaper than wall paint, and you're going to need two coats of good wall paint. With everything else you've done, don't wimp out now. Zinsser or Kilz are worth the price. In 5 gal buckets, you typically save about 20%.

Go to a pro paint store, and talk with the people that can help. At the BORG, it's hit and miss, and they have little flexibility for projects like yours...

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#5

Or, if a sprayer's not workable

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>definitely get an extension pole for your roller.

That sounds dumb - of course you have one - but it was years before I realized how much efficiency they add. About a 150% improvement in speed or more, after cutting in the edges. It's also easier on your back because you can paint the low parts of the walls while standing.

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#6

Spend the extra money

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Good primer will seal up the drywall faster and provide a superior base for your finish coats, thus speeding up finish coat application and improving the quality.

My experience is limited, but the drywall-specific primers do seem to be better for drywall than generic primer.

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#7

Ventilate

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>especially if you choose the alcohol-based KILZ. I did some apartment painting back when I was young and broke, and realized one day when doing a bathroom (standard practice then to use oil paint in wet environments - latex was not the high quality stuff it is now) that I was stoned on the fumes, because I hadn't opened the windows. Oil-paint stoned is not a pleasant experience, and the headaches are awful; wood-alcohol stoned is similar.

It was on that same apartment that I got a call from my sweet wife, telling me we were pregnant - so the job carries both negative and VERY positive memories.

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#8

Re: OT: Drywall primer

Ben Ragusa, S Jersey

>Thanks for the advice so far. I have never used spray equipment (other than the Wagner thing I bought years ago, used once and garage sold to the next dreamer), so I think I'm going to roll it all. And I agree that a good extension pole makes a big difference. I used a cheap, skinny one a few times, it tires the hands. Now I use a fatter one with a padded grip. Much better.

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#9

forget the primer, time more valuable than paint

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>My time is vastly more valuable than paint. I "prime" with whatever I intend for a top coat. This application plus one additional coating is guaranteed to cover with no risk of needing a 3rd coat.

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#10

Re: forget the primer, time more valuable than pai

Barry Irby

>I agree with Bill. As a builder I (and my men) used to paint most of the houses I built. We always removed the door hinges, etc. and painted everything with the wall paint we were using and then went back and painted the trim with semigloss. With very little cutting in to do it was amazing how fast you could paint a house.

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Not a great approach.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>You can probably get away with that method if your topcoats are a cheap, flat paint, but you would likely run into problems with shinier finishes.

Not to mention, with a good primer underneath, topcoating goes much, much more quickly, no matter the paint, and you'll use less of it, allowing you to budget for a better topcoat.

As to what primer to use, I'm not a fan of the BORG-ish primers (Kilz, BIN, etc.). They have their place, and that is usually stain-killing/sealing. When I'm priming bare drywall, I want it to dry to a flat, sandable finish. This also rules out most PVA primers as well, which tend to dry to a bit of a sheen. My favorite is Sherwin-Williams' Prep-Rite 200, though I only use it because of the ridiculously low price we get on it. I wouldn't pay shelf price for it. If nothing else, use a cheap, flat paint for a primer, though it won't seal as well, and will absorb more of the first topcoat.

Oh, and like Rod said, an airless, (piston pump) sprayer is well worth a day's rental.

Jason

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#12

Re: OT: Drywall primer

Jim Dillon

>Ben,

Sure sounds like you got your answer. Another advantage of a good primer is that it minimizes the differences in your final top coat sheen between where you have drywall compound and plain drywall. Well worth the extra effort IMHO. Plus, I would imagine, the primer provides a better bond for the top coat. I've used Kilz, but for no other reason than it is readily available at the local Borg. Will take Jason's recommendation into consideration next time though. I've always just rolled the primer on and brushed the corners, but I've never had to do a lot at one time where a rented sprayer might be very useful. And I've generally used two coats of primer but, like I said, I've never done a large area. And one more thing, I let the primer dry overnight even though the can says much less time. But again, I am just a plodding DIYer with lots of time to kill ;-).

Jim

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT: Drywall primer

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I try to let the primer dry overnight also. And that's mainly so that it can set up enough to be lightly pole-sanded the next day. I've discovered a round-headed pole sander that doesn't ever roll over and gouge the wall, plus it covers more area (9-10" diam, off-hand).

Jason

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#14

Re: Not a great approach.

Fred Davis

>Jason is right about the primer, though I never heard that one about PVA having a sheen that would shine though a flat wall paint.

PVA (polyvinyl acetate) primer/sealer has been the choice for drywall prep for many years and also the least expensive.

Kilz is fine for sealing but it is overkill and more expensive for new drywall , since it was originally intended to block out bleed though from stains, dirt, and the extractives you will get out of Redwood and Cedar that will bleed though a finish coat of water based paint, unless it is blocked by a product like Kilz.

The reason that using the same paint for a sealer , that you will use for the finish or topcoat is a bad idea is that primers/sealers have more binders then finish paint does and the finish paint has more Opaqueness and color then the sealer does.

So you will not get the binding advantage of a primer by using the finish coat for the primer and like Jason points out, you will get a uneven seal and it cost's more to get less, doing it that way.

On the other hand a painter like Jason knows that painters mix their "scrap paint " all of it being different shades of White and spray that for a primer. ;-))

FredD

FredD

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#15

Re: Thanks for advice

Ben Ragusa, S Jersey

>Just a quick thanks to all who offered their advice. Picking up some Benj.Moore this afternoon. Planning to paint (prime and topcoat) through the weekend.

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#16

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Why I don't like PVA

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>It's not so much that it shines through a flat paint, it's that as one rolls on (or sprays and back-rolls) a topcoat, the topcoat is more likely to smear, affecting the stipple quality, and lowering the coverage of the topcoat. With a primer that dries flat, the topcoat "grabs" a little better when rolling, so the coverage is better and the stipple less pronounced.

BTW, I don't use scrap paint for primer...I'm just not into cutting corners like that.

One more thing--tinted primers are your friend. 50% of the color of the topcoat is the general rule of thumb, unless you're doing bright or deep colors, then an appropriate shade of gray is the ticket--the paint store can help you in that department. Bright reds are probably the worst by far. Without the right primer, you could put 6 coats on and still not have it be 100% covered.

Jason

Re: OT: Drywall primer

#17

Re: Why I don't like PVA

Fred Davis

>Jason , I did not say YOU used scrap paint , I said because your a painter , you would know that, very few outside of the paint industry do.

As for cutting corners , the practice of mixing water into water based paints is a very real, shady method of cost cutting and done all of the time.

I have walked down the hallways of new homes , not yet sold , run the flat of my hand over the wall surface , and sure enough , sometimes it came away , covered with white powder.

This was caused by thinning five gallons of paint with as much as five gallons of water, I caught a painter doing just that, it cost him his really good connection with that developer.

One more thing about PVA , though primer/sealer now comes in many colors and names, if you look closely on some of the cans, you may find that PVA is a major ingredient, regardless of what they are calling it at the moment.

And lastly Jason, I think your a responsible painter who takes the time to help out on this forum and I also know for a fact ,from a consumers and contractors point of view, that your industry really needs to clean up some of it's practice's.

FredD