Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Question about finishing Oak

Posts

Question about finishing Oak

#1

Question about finishing Oak

Bernard

>I am looking for feedback/opinions/advice on a project I am working on in the evenings. It is a large bookcase unit with cabinets (total of almost 13' wide and 10' high at the peak. If anybody wishes, I can post a pic of the rough sketch.

Anyway, this is all being done with oak plywood and oak boards (my daughter's choice- it is going in her house) with a medium brown Sherwin Williams stain (forgot the name, and I am at work). The big question is the finish.

The criteria are the following:

a) I am not a professional, even though I try to pour my heart and soul in my work, so I am looking at something relatively easy to apply, even though I will be meticulous and patient in whatever I decide to do.

b) I do not have a sprayer, and therefore would prefer to brush or rub a finish rather that experiment with spraying.

c) I am working in an attached garage, in which I am both building the cases and will finish (therefore I will try to finish all the sanding and then vacuum everything up and then let it all settle before finishing to minimize dust.

d) The bookshelf unit will occupy a wall facing south in a Florida house with plenty of windows, so it will be getting a decent amount of sunshine (although muted in the summertime when the sun it hottest but more directly overhead).

e) All the wood will be oak boards or oak face plywood.

f) Water spillage will not be concern, unless the dogs and cat decide to use my work as a litter box.

I originally had somebody put a bug in my ear about mixing BLO with turp and varnish and rubbing it in, that it provided few problems with oak, but I realize that the finish will not be very tough.

Somebody else encouraged me to use a brushing lacquer such as Deft, but I am concerned with fumes, and that a brushing lacquer will not dry as fast as a spraying one, therefore negating the advantage of fast drying to avoid dust nibs.

Right now, I am leaning towards using a good varnish (any recommendations on brands???), thinning the first coat for better absorption, and then applying two more coats on top of that.

Any thoughts about this, or any advice about anything I should absolutely do? I am still weeks away before finishing, but I have gone dizzy over trying to choose a finish, and frankly I love the construction part, but the finishing part freaks me out a bit.

Any and all comments are appreciated. Thanks!!!!

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#2

Re: Question about finishing Oak *LINK*

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>General Finishes Wipe on finish Arm R Seal is easy to use and I think gives a decent finish. Here is a link:


Arm R Seal

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#3

Re: Question about finishing Oak

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>The toughest easiest finish I know is Varathane Diamond Floor finish. It is a water based polyurethane that does little to swell the wood. It imparts almost no color toteh finish and stays that way for years. It is only sold by teh gallon, but a large project will use quite a bit. It is brusable and dries quickly without fumes.

Deft, by the way dries in 30 minutes or less in warm weather. It does take a couple of weeks to cure completely to be order free. Best part is it can be refinished even years later with no issues if you want to add another coat. It can also be applied in very cold temps and still dry, it just takes longer.

With brush on finishes apply them only to horizontal surfaces to avoid runs.

Lee

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#4

Re: Question about finishing Oak

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Two thoughts, based on my California experience:

1) Waterlox series of products. The original sealer/finish, and then the more traditional varnish. I like the gloss, and rub to dull the bright shine.

2) McCloskey's Spar Varnish, cut 30% with VMP Naptha, and wiped on. Also gloss, and rubbed.

I've done both. The Tanoak library cabinets I'm building now are getting the McCloskey's over a light cherry toned dye. It dries to recoat in about 4 hours in this coolish, dampish weather. Takes about 3 coats, maybe 4. I use a t-shirt-like cotton material to apply it, and dispose of the wipe after each session.

The Waterlox would get more use if I didn't have to drive 45 miles round trip to resupply. Spar varnish comes from the local guy four blocks away.

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#5

Re: Question about finishing Oak

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Stay away from BLO in any form; it adds nothing. An easy, quick, and durable brush-on finish is a clear waterborne poly floor finish, like Benjamin Moore or Varathane. If you can walk on it, you can rest a book on it. Good luck and post pics when you're done.

Clint

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#6

Verathane . . hands down.

steve mackay

>

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#7

Re: Question about finishing Oak

Fred Davis

>Bernard ,

given all of the restrictions your putting in place for a finish, think about Shellac, a age old tried and true finish that will enhance Oak with a stain or not.

It also is probably the easiest of finishes to repair if damaged, like Lacquer it burns into the preceding coat,

Unlike Deft Brushing Lacquer which I like , but have a way of venting the noxious fumes from it , you won't run into the same problem with Shellac, it has a rather pleasant odor to me and because it is cut with Alcohol,it is a very fast drier.

There are fans of Varathanes and I won't go into that subject , except to say , they are difficult to repair.

Any hoo , be glad you can build it , take the same careful approach to the finish and you will be good to go.

FredD

On the varnish side , if you use a true Varnish, depending on your house keeping , you will get anything from nibs to fur until it dries slowly....

Also a relatively long time between coats and a lot longer time before it is cured enough for rub out.

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#8

Couple things...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I'm betting that the Sherwin Williams stain you are using is an oil-based pigment stain. I don't know if you have prepared test samples of it yet, but I suggest doing that right away. You may find that the pigment stain adds too much visual emphasis to the earlywood grain pattern, which can end up being rather chaotic and/or disjointed looking with this much red oak. That's my main objection to red oak as a cabinet material: most people don't pay close enough attention to grain matching and composition, so their finished products end up looking rather jarring.

Usually when I made furniture or built-ins with red oak, I stained with dye stain or NGR stain first, then followed up with pigment stain. This assures that the summerwood gets evenly colored as well as the earlywood. I'd suggest making a sample of this approach. I think you will find it adds richness and depth to the color that you get with neither a dye or a pigment by itself.

As far as finishes are concerned, I never recommend a hand-applied finish for an architectural piece of this scale unless you have time on your hands. We always used lacquer of one flavor or another, sprayed with a regular spray gun. It is the easiest and most cost effective way to do it, it dries right before your eyes, and it stands up well to dirt, dust and abrasion. A lot of custom shops spray even more sophisticated conversion varnishes and cabacrylics for the sake of additional wear resistance and film properties, but I wouldn't try these unless you're willing to set up a decent spray booth, invest in the right equipment and materials and do a lot of experimentation.

If you really don't want to get into spraying, I like the waterborne polyurethane suggestions that some others have made. It dries a lot faster than oil-based poly. Regardless of what you use for a finish, make sure your dye/pigment/stain combo is DRY first. I've actually ruined a couple pieces because I was in too much of a hurry to finish over stain, and the finish wouldn't dry. That's a heartbreak you don't need.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#9

Re: Couple things...

Bernard

>Thank you for the staining tip. You actually mentioned one thing I was going to post a question about...drying time for the stain before finishing. I am assuming a week or so should be enough, depending on humidity and temperature? I think Flexner's book has a test for checking that, and I will have to find that.

Also, is there any problem using the waterborne Varathane over an oil-based stain? And would the water-based product raise the grain a lot?

I guess I had not given too much consideration (until now) to the water-based Varathane only because I had read that the water-based polys did not give much UV protection, and it will be getting a decent amount of direct and indirect sunlight.

I will DEFINITELY look into your suggestion about using a dye first. It is that kind of info that I was hoping to get- thanks! I suppose I will have to go to a more specialty shop that Sherwin-Williams, though to find it. Any suggestions on brands, etc.?

Thanks again for the input.

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#10

Re: Follow up question on dyes

Bernard

>I had kind of originally dismissed using dye because of comments in Bob Flexner's book, when he says that "if you are staining wood that will be placed in direct sunlight, even inside a building...you should try to avoid using dyes altogether".

This project will be on a wall exposed to a decent amount of sunlight, so I am concerned about fading. If, however, I followup the dye with a pigment stain, will that help protect the dye, or will it fade anyway, causing a waste of time applying it in the first place? Or is there anything else I can do to help prevent that?

I guess the problem in my mind is compounded by the fact that I have read that one problem with polyurethane is that they do not give much UV protection, and being that many people are suggesting the Varathane Diamond to me, does anybody know if they have added enough UV protection for it to be appropriate in this application?

So many questions...sorry.

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#11

Re: Couple things...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Drying time shouldn't be more than a couple days at most. A week is overkill for any stains I know of. Regarding compatibility and grain raising, the mantra is "finish firewood first," in other words, make up those samples I spoke about and see for yourself, with the exact combination of products you plan to use, what results you can expect. My hunch is that the pigment stain will seal the fibers enough that grain raising will not be an issue. Adhesion should be okay, but it's worth confirming with a sample. There are standard, simple tests for adhesion that you can do with a razor blade and a piece of tape, if you want to run a couple experiments with your finish versus some other.

As far as UV protection, your concern is with the stain bleaching out, but I wouldn't worry too much about that. If you use a water based dye or trans-tint type stain, it will be fairly colorfast to begin with, and pigment stains offer even better protection from bleaching or lightening. I wouldn't worry about the UV barrier. All it does is slow down the effect anyhow.

Ellis

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#12

Re: Follow up

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>As Ellis mentioned, UV "protection" in finishes only delays the process. You might also consider a UV screen for the windows admitting the light in question. Some of the E-film products are very effective UV blockers.

I have used a TransTint alcohol NGR dye + oil pigment stain combination with waterborne topcoats on ash where the items get direct summer sun here in NJ. The fabric cushions faded, but the wood is unchanged.

Do your adhesion tests as Ellis suggested, but if you want it foolproof, apply a thinned coat of 100% dewaxed shellac on top of your stain before you apply the waterborne. If you don't wish to mix your own, get a fresh-dated can of Zinsser's SealCoat, thin it 1 part alcohol to 1 part shellac (for a "1 pound cut") and wipe it on with a lint-free cloth.

Side Note: I've used Varithane Diamond but prefer General Finish's Enduro Clear Poly for furniture. Do not, however, hand-apply waterborne finishes with a foam brush, they entrap too much air in the finish. Far better is a high quality Taklon nylon brush.

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#13

Re: Sherwin Williams might be OK...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>They can have decent products and people. Some of them are quite good. Not all, however.

BTW, I second Fred's shellac suggestion, if you are against spraying. Or even if you are not, shellac sprays well. It wipes pretty well, too.

Re: Question about finishing Oak

#14

Re: Dye/Stain question

Bernard

>I am most definitely going to try the dye/pigment stain combo.

One question, though, when try to achieve a certain balance of tone. Will the two have a cumulutive effect, so that if I am looking for a certain level of darkness, that I will have to step it down a notch and use a lighter shade of either dye or stain to achieve the level of color and darkness I am looking for? I know I have to experiment, but I would like to start off buying something close to what I will eventually use so that I do not add any more cans to the collection of stains I have which are only used 5%. Not sure if I explained my question well, but basically, by using both, will I come out with a tone that is darker overall than what I would have expected using one of them alone. I assume so, but you know what they say about assuming...

Thanks in advance for the input.