Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT: Electrical question

Posts

OT: Electrical question

#1

OT: Electrical question

Dan Mitchell

>Yesterday, I had the cover off the main service panel in the 1970's vintage house we bought 2 years ago, and noticed that about 2" of insulation was melted/charred on a 14ga neutral wire just next to where the wire enters the neutral bus on a 15 amp circuit. The circuit in question is for a bathroom we don't use much, so while I replaced a section of the wire inside the panel (using a ~14" length of 14ga wire & an appropriate wire nut) as well as the breaker on that circuit, for the time being, I have the circuit turned off. I'm wondering what could have caused this, other than a faulty breaker. One would assume that if an overload had existed on the circuit great enough to have charred the insulation, it should have tripped the breaker. The only other possibility that occurs to me is that the connection at the neutral buss was loose or otherwise poor, so that some resistance existed at the spot where the wire entered the bus, causing it to heat up. The wire at that point had blackened & oxidized green a bit, but of course I don't know is this was the case before the charring occurred. When I re-connected the wire, I used a different hole in the bus, to avoid the heated area where the wire was originally connected. Any insights appreciated.

TIA

Dan

Re: OT: Electrical question

#2

Re: OT: Electrical question

Ronald from NW Ohio------WebKitFormBoundaryAAddAAU

>To being with 14 gauage wire is,to me, not big enough to carry all that a bathroom has to put out. Hair dryers, curling irons pull a lot of amps. I would say over time that heat just kept heating up more and more and finally started melting the insulation. I would say to replace the wire all the way and use 12 gauge. But then to i am not a quailfied electrician. But that is what i would do. Good Luck!!!

Re: OT: Electrical question

#3

Re: OT: Electrical question

Howard Norman

>I would guess that you had a bad connection that overheated and melted the insulation.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#4

Re: OT: Electrical question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Either or both these things could be true:

1. Faulty breaker that isn't tripping at 15 amps - in which case, you're overloading the circuit and creating a hazard.

2. Bad connection at the neutral bus, causing localized heating.

The trouble with finding a problem like that in a visible place is wondering what's going on in the less visible locations. Was there any length of the wire in the panel on which the insulation was OK?

If the panel uses affordable breakers, you might consider replacing it as a safety move - if it trips under the load you normally put on it, then you've discovered a deeper problem, and you should be glad to discover it that way.

I agree that 15 amps is a little small for a bathroom - but if you find the new breaker's not tripping, then it is adequate.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#5

Re: OT: Electrical question

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> I agree that 15 amps is a little small for a bathroom…

In fact, it doesn't meet modern code. NEC currently specifies 20A for bathrooms and GFCI to boot. 15A is okay for bathroom lighting, however.

Rod
Addy Protocol: Experienced amateur electrician

Re: OT: Electrical question

#6

Re: OT: Electrical question

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. To clarify, the 15 amp circuit serves only the lights & fan in the bathroom & one outlet in an adjoining bedroom, the outlets in the bathroom near the sink (as well as outlets in another 1.5 baths & 1 near the utility sink in the laundry room) are all served by a separate 20 amp circuit. There is a GFI on the outlet in the utility room.

I did replace the breaker on the 15 amp line. I do think the trouble was likely a result of a loose connection where the neutral for the 15 amp circuit connected at the panel.

Dan

Re: OT: Electrical question

#7

Electrical trivia

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>Over a period of time terminal screws will get a little loose regardless of how much they were originally tightend.

Anytime I am working in a panel I will check all the screws, both on the breakers and the neutral bar. If nothing has been done in the panel for several years it's usually possible to get a least a quarter turn and sometimes a lot more than that.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#8

Re: Electrical trivia

David G. Sparks

>An experienced electrician told me when wiring a breaker it's a good idea to tighten the screw holding the wire then loosen the screw and tighten it again really well. He said this helps keep the screw from loosening over time. I do think your idea of checking the connections is a good one also.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#9

Re: OT: Electrical question

Jay Lombardo

>All of the possible causes mentioned already could be true, especially the loose wire at the neutral buss. If the terminal was not loose when you took it off there is a more common problem. When homes are wired the electrician runs networks, which is a circuit from A phase, a circuit from B phase and a common neutral. If for any reason somebody swaps the wires in the panel or grabs any old neutral when they are working on the system and you end up with 2 circuits from the same phase sharing the same neutral you WILL overload the neutral and cause the situation you described. Just something else to check because if that was the case it will do it again. And as a practical matter even though code says now that you need a 20A circuit a 15A will blow the breaker if it is overloaded not melt the wire. If you do have an overloaded neutral it won't blow the breaker because it is not an overload.

Good Luck,

Jay

(Electrician 40 yrs)

Re: OT: Electrical question

#10

but don't overtighten

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I've seen wires cut through by people who overtighten the screws. The causes a hot spot but does not always result in a broken circuit. I've seen a 3 hp motor running with one wire complete cut through by an overtightened breaker terminal.

There are torque specs available for breaker terminals.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#11

Re: OT: Electrical question

Alexander Grigoriev

>14 AWG copper is normal for a 15 A circuit.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#12

Re: OT: Electrical question

Dan Mitchell

>Jay - Thanks for the reply. I'm having a hard time visualizing the shared neutral scenario. The panel has 2 hots & 1 neutral coming in, which I thought was the usual setup. Given that there is only 1 neutral line entering the building, aren't they all the same? Can you clarify this?

I do have a pdf of the 2008 National Electrical Code, NFPA 70. Is what you're referring to described in there some place, or do you know of a wiring diagram online that may make this a little easier to visualize?

Thanks,

Dan

Re: OT: Electrical question

#13

Re: OT: Electrical question

Dan Mitchell

>After reading this again, I gather you mean a situation where you have for example 2 15 Amp hots, each from a separate breaker, sharing a single neutral wire, so that each hot could be carrying 10 amps & not trip the breaker, while the neutral would be carrying 20 amps. As far as I can tell, the circuit in question is as it was installed; doesn't look like anyone has modified it or added anything. If this is what you mean, how would I determine if a neutral is being shared, short of physically tracing out/checking the entire path?

Thanks again

Dan

Re: OT: Electrical question

#14

Re: OT: Electrical question

Ronald from NW Ohio------WebKitFormBoundaryAAddAAU

>Yes that's true,but 15amp breakers are usually not used for bathroom outlets and neither is 14 gauge wire. I do believe that is code at least in Ohio.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#15

Re: OT: Electrical question

Dan Mitchell

>The outlets in the bathrooms are on a separate 20A/12G circuit.

Dan

Re: OT: Electrical question

#16

Me too

Bill Howatt

>That's what he means, 2 circuits on the same "phase" putting the return current on the same neutral. Note that if the 2 circuits are on different "phases" then the currents actually subtract. I would say that a properly bonded #14 wire would carry well over 15A without serious overheating (It could get warm, though.) so I don't really think this is the root cause of the problem.

Years ago, I had the same problem with a burned neutral wire and the reason was insufficiently tightened screw bonding it to the neutral buss. I always check the screws whenever I'm in the panel but I find that after you do a re-tightening sometime after the installation that pretty well takes care of it.

Once the wire starts to get a bit hot because of higher than normal resistance in the joint for whatever reason, the heat causes oxidation which usually means more resistance and even more heating thus creating a vicious circle. Ultimately, the wire can burn off.

Bill

Re: OT: Electrical question

#17

Re: OT: Electrical question

Barry Irby

>My understanding of this is ancient and somewhat vague, so take it with a grain of salt.

The two incoming leads (legs) into your panel each bring in a 120 volts and can be pictured as a sine wave. The two waves are exactly out of sync with each other and if you draw current from each of them, you get 240 volts. (plus or minus about 5%) A good layout in a panel suggests that you should pull nearly equal amounts of 120 volt power from each leg. My understanding is, that if you draw identical amounts form each leg, there is no current flow in the neutral. If there is an imbalance, say you draw thirty amps for one side and forty from the other, there would be a ten amp flow in the neutral, (the Imbalance.) This is why you can connect a 240 volt device without a neutral. Just two hots and a ground. Since the load is balanced, there is no return flow for the neutral.

I suspect your neutral was loose and that is why it got hot.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#18

Re: OT: Electrical question

Fred Davis

>I think based on seeing this very thing more then a couple of times, that Bill and Barry probably are right in thinking loose neutral buss bar screws.

Once a screw becomes slightly less tight then it should be, it permits constant expansion and contraction which under severe conditions will eventually cause arcing.

This is the main reason Aluminum wire was phased out in California except for the Utility company who can run Aluminum to your service panel and are a law unto themselves.

As for balancing the load phase wise , this is routinely done by a Electrician, not necessarily so with a homeowner or helpful neighbor.

For myself I believe it is peachy dandy to have a Electrician with forty years experience on this site, if you see some bad advice being handed out Jay , jump right in , your most welcome.

FredD

Re: OT: Electrical question

#19

Aluminum

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I was told, back when I was an electrician's grunt, that aluminum creeps more than copper, thus getting thinner under the screw, thus loosening the screw and causing the problems that got it banned. I don't know if this understanding is/was correct, since the electrician I worked with had some difficulty explaining three phase to me.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#20

Here's an interesting twist

Dan Mitchell

>I just measured some currents in the panel with my clamp on amp meter. The current on one side of the line entering the box is ~5.4 amps. The current on the other side of the line entering the box is ~5.8 amps, and the current on the neutral entering the box is ~2.7amps. Now the interesting part: the current on the neutral wire that had been burned & which I just replaced is a little over 1 amp, WITH THE BREAKER FOR THAT CIRCUIT OFF. As one would expect, the current on the hot coming out of that breaker is 0.

So, while the 14 ga wire is of course easily able to carry 1 amp, it would seem there is something else going on.

Thanks all for the input & if anyone has any other thoughts, I'd like to hear them.

Dan

Re: OT: Electrical question

#21

Re: Here's an interesting twist

Ed Wozniak, Buffalo, NY

>Dan,

Does your meter indicate any current flowing when it is not clamped around any wire? That is does it accurately report 0 Amps when you are certain that the current is 0 Amps?

Re: OT: Electrical question

#22

Re: Aluminum

Fred Davis

>In a matter of speaking that is what happens.

FredD

Re: OT: Electrical question

#23

Re: Here's an interesting twist

Dan Mitchell

>It's not a meter error, it does read 0 absent any conducting wire.

I'm going to try shutting off surrounding circuits one by one to see if the current stops.

Re: OT: Electrical question

#24

Re: OT: Electrical question

Jay Lombardo

>Dan, is this conduit, or romex? If it is conduit you will have 2 colors and a white for each network (shared) and 1 white for each color on separate neutrals. If it is romex you will have just a black and white for separate and a black, red, and white for shared (don't include any greens or bare conductors). Make sure if they are shared that one circuit goes to A and 1 goes to B phase. In your post you asked if each circuit carried 10 amps then the neutral would carry 20 amps back, no. If each circuit had a 10 amp load the neutral would bring back 0. It only returns the unbalanced portion. If one circuit had a 10 amp load and one had a 15 amp load it would return 5 amps.

Jay