Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

Posts

OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#1

OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

Steve Silca

>This is a multi-pronged inquiry - I would just like to hear yor preferences and recommendations. I have done a fair amount of tile work and always worked with 1/2" cement board, taped the seams, used screws to attach it. I have several more tile projects coming up and wanted to consider alternatives.

1. If you were doing a tile surround for a tub/shower, would you use cement board or hardiboard? If you use hardiboard, how do you tape the seams?

2. If you were doing a floor, would you use hardiboard or cement board? What thickness

3. I am going to wrap my exterior wooden steps with tile. So, I will be applying tile to the front of the treads, the top of the treads, and the risers. Right now they are sturdy wooden steps. I am thinking of applying the 1/4" hardiboard as a substrate. What do you think?

4. When can you use 1/4" or 3/8" cement board?

5. Finally, I have always used mortar and screws to attach backer board, but have seen videos of people doing it with a roofing nailer. Does a roofing nailer (1 1/4" nails) and mortrar suffice for backer board installation?

Thanks for any input you can offer!

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#2

interior floor

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The manufacturer of the floor tile we used specified sanded 1/2 plywood for the under layment, screwed every 4?? inches (I don't remember). It makes sense to me as plywood is going to be stiffer and fewer seams. No failures after 14 years.

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#3

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Floors I use 3/4 ply, glued and screwed + Ditra. For a shower I used 1/2" Hardi (mud-slab floor) rather than Durock with mesh/mud joints, also screwed (no nails).

If you want 1st class advice and deetailed how-to from pros on all of this, take your question to the John Bridge tile/stone forum at the link.


Tile Forum

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#4

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I've used both. Hardiboard is a little easier to get a nice straight cut/break on. I used cement board for my shower and taped it with fiberglass since I was building the floorpan out of fiberglass over cement board. After 2 years of use there is no evidence of water issues under the shower.

I used 1/4" cement board over plywood for the bathroom floor, primarily because we incorporated the heating mats in a couple of places and I didn't want to put them directly on the plywood.

I've never tiled exterior steps, but I imagine either product would work well.

I've always used screws to put down the boards. My gut doesn't feel comfortable with the idea of nailing it down.

Gary

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#5

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

Ronald from NW Ohio------WebKitFormBoundaryAAddAAU

>I used 1 1/4" staples on 1/4" plywood put one in about every 6". Still there and no problems that i know of. That is on kitchen floor. I would go with cement board in bathroom. Just because it is a bathroom.

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#6

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

steve mackay

>Doesn't Mike Holmes prefer the hardiboard ? Thats good enough for me.

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#7

Hardiboard, with some reservations....

John in NM

>I like Hardiboard better because I find it easier to cut and work with, and less prone to cracking if mis-handled. But those are fairly minor points on the whole. We did a lot of slate and ceramic tile floors in our house a couple years ago - mortar bed, hardiboard screwed down, seams taped with fiber and mortar, then lay tile. This is over a 2x10 joist floor with 3/4" plywood subfloor. Seems to work fine for me, though extra reinforcement around large live loads like the tub are critical.

As for shower walls, I won't use backer board - it doesn't breathe, and the one I've ever ripped apart had extensive dry rot of the studs. That was probably more the tile installations fault than the backer board, but the weaker link allowed the second weakest link to also become a problem. On the other hand I took apart a 60 year old plaster wall around a tub once, and there was absolutely no water damage after all those years and at least two tile jobs. The reason is that a plaster wall lets the moisture escape (moisture that gets in around cracks in the tile/grout/backer/tub joint, etc).

I don't have a sure solution for a shower wall - I'd either do plaster with tile over it or OSB/tar paper/sheetrock or backer/tile, but I won't claim that either will definitely be trouble free - every method has its drawbacks, and showers are one of the hardest places to avoid trouble later.

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#8

Re: Waterproof Shower and Tub Walls

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Next time consider the Kerdi waterproof membrane, made by Schluter, for your walls.

mm

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#9

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardboard

Barry Irby

>I don't have much of an opinion on Hardy VS cement board. Just did two jobs with them, one of each. 1/2" on the floor. I screwed the board to the floor with a LOT of screws, but did not bead it in thinset, out of ignorance. Neither job has been down long enough to make any comment. Cut both with a scoring tool. Not enough difference to matter, but the Hardy is easier. I did the framing in one job, so the shower is 3' 1" by 5' 1". Ran the boards vertical in the ends and horizontal on the longer walls, Nice size and it minimized cutting.

I would say definitely screws. DEFINATELY. Roofing nails are smooth shank and a serious invitation to nail pops, especially if you drive them into the joists. (As a Home Inspector, I know a thing or two about nail pops.)

My opinion is that the putting tile on exterior steps will accelerate the rotting. Water will find its way through to the wood and hold it there and it will rot. Even treated wood rots after a long enough.

I have slate in my house that has been in place for thirty years. Two layers of 5/8" plywood, glued and screwed. The slate is glued with PL 400 construction adhesive. Butt cut joints, no grout.

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#10

well...

John in NM

>You're talking to the guy who stuccoed a house with lime plaster rather than portland cement stucco - not real big on innovation, but thanks for the idea, I'll look it up when (if) we ever build a guest house.

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#11

Re: well...goto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>the link I posted above. You use acomputer and the Internet to communicate with others around the world. No reason your construction m&m's should be stuck in the 19th Century |;-}}

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#12

Sure there is...

John in NM

>"No reason your construction m&m's should be stuck in the 19th Century |;-}}"

Sometimes the innovations are of interest only to professional builders who are trying to minimize time spent and employee skills/salary and thus maximize profits. The plaster is a perfect example - far superior results (for my application), but the learning curve is steep.

I will certainly have a look at the shower membrane though, I don't think my wife will let me plaster all the walls - sheetrock is cheaper, easier, and way faster - a good example of the flip side: modern M&M better than the old ;)

Re: OT - Cement Board vs. Hardiboard

#13

Re: Plaster

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Is an art form nearly lost. I've watched some of these old guys do a lathe and plaster wall, and it was truly amazing to see them produce a dead flat and straight wall surface. We've become so used to the sheetrock "undulating wall" effect that few people know or notice the difference.