Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Posts

Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#1

Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Terry Alexander

>Still in the construction phase of building my new house.

Had a buddy help me install 15 interior doors last weekend.

We have a LOT of holes that the 2" nailer left in the trim.

We tried DAP to fill the holes, but it dried and shrank so much you couldn't tell we had put any in at all.

Then we tried latex caulk. Had the same results as with DAP.

It "appears" our only option is to buy a tub of wood filler and fill in the holes. BUT, this leads to sanding all the places you put the filler.

Having said/typed all of that, do any of you have an easy "quick" way to fill the nail holes and possibly not have to sand every spot?

FWI...the trim is just lumber yard yellow pine that comes already attached to one side of the door.

As always....TIA for your valued advice.

Terry Alexander in West Texas.

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#2

Re: Filling nail holes - Paint or Stain??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>What's going to be your final finish on the wood?

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#3

One idea... *LINK*

David Yoho

>The first thing that comes to mind would be Timbermate Filler. I think it would solve your sanding problem as well as fill all those holes without shrinking, cracking, or falling out. The best part is it's water-based. I can fill holes quickly either using a putty knife or tip of my index finger. Since it's water-based, you should be able to wipe away anything on the surface with a damp cloth.

I've switched from Famowood, which I used for many years, to the Timbermate and think it's the best thing since sliced bread!

There's more info on the manufacturer's Website below.

David


Timbermate Wood Filler

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#4

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Yonak

>Terry, I filled all the nail holes in all the trim in my house with wood putty and, while it was rather mind-numbing and took a day, it went faster than I thought. It's a matter of mind over tedium, developing a system, and listening to music. I would not use a filler that doesn't dry if it were me.

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#5

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Mark Nowicki

>Are you painting or staining?

On paint grade trim fastened with 16ga nails I use acrylic painters caulk. I use a coarse, damp ( warm water) sponge to remove the excess, rinsing often.

Mark

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#6

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I use wood filler by DAP tinted tot he final color the wood will be. Use a putty knife and press it into the hole. A quick pass with sandpaper after it dries will smooth it out. Quality work needs attention to details.

Lee

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#7

Paint is the final finish

Terry Alexander

>

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Jesper, Denmark

>Prime it first, then fill with spackle.

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#9

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

steve mackay

>Just me but I quite trying with filler. Put up my molding with as few finnishing nails as possible, set them, and leave it be. I've always made a way worse mess and more work with any filler I've tried than just useing less nails. I've even trashed a piece of molding once I've found I've used an excess of nails rather than filling eight or ten holes. If I've used more than one nail in three or four feet its too many.

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#10

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Bob Lemon, Sacramento CA

>Terry, I find the neatest way to put in the filler is to use a syringe. Put the syringe in the hole and start pumping. Leave a little bump on the outside of the hole to sand off. This prevents grain filling around the hole and cuts down on labor.

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#11

Re: Paint is the final finish

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Then I use a bit of hard-set plaster (right, like from Paris). Sets without shrink, sands off smooth and level when dry (day or 2). 2 coats of any paint an it's invisible.

mm

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#12

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Barry Irby

>Trimmed out a house a year ago and a bathroom in the last few days. Painted pine trim nailed with a finishing nailer. Got "Painters" Nail Hole Filler/ Spackling at Lowe's. Comes in a soft plastic tube like toothpaste with a sponge applicator on the end. The stuff inside the tube seems to be somewhere between sheetrock compound and plaster. You just squirt a little out and wipe it over the holes. Takes about four or five holes to get the knack. Almost no sanding or clean up. The most amazing part was that the same tube did both jobs, over a year apart. The goop had separated, but shaking it and kneading the tube reconditioned it and it was fine. Drys in about 30 minutes. The tube was about $4. I have to say I was a skeptic. Never really thought it would work. Much better than I expected. Saw several similar products at Home Depot and Lowe's, but I know this one worked. Painting section.

I used (Years ago I was builder and we did our own painting. Painted hundreds of houses.) to do them with Dap Glazer's Putty. Oil based. If you use oil based putty, you should prime first and then paint with oil based paint to seal in the putty. If you apply flat latex directly over the putty, it will soak through and it looks like a wet spot at each dab of Dap. Almost like somebody spit on each nail.

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#13

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

Fred Davis

>A couple of tested ways to do this and as you do it you will become faster at it.

Many professional painters I have had over the years use or used (haven't seen one lately) Linseed oil Putty rolled into a ball about the size of a golf ball and they press it into the nail hole and run a putty knife under it ,all in one motion. Very hard to detect and once it is painted impossible.

I personally since Red Devil developed light weight Spackle which dries as fast as the water in it evaporates, use it for all paint grade nail hole filling .

After you get a feel for it , sanding is nearly done away with and if it is needed , a swipe will cut the Spackle flush.

This applies only to the light weight formulas, the old ones take more work.

FredD

Re: Filling nail holes - any easy way?

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

What's your goal?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Is your goal only speed, when you say, 'easy'?

If so, Fred probably has it with the "painter's putty"--it's basically the same thing as DAP 33 window glazing, they're both a clay/linseed oil mixture of some sort. However, I hate the stuff, because I find it's difficult to get a perfectly flush fill AND smooth. I can get flush with the knife trick Fred mention, but it leaves texture, or I can get smooth by rubbing it in with my finger. Neither is acceptable to me (or my customers) in anything but rental property.

If you want a virtually perfect, flush fill, you have to sand. There is no way around that. What material you use and how much you apply determines how much you have to sand. Most of the time, I use a no-shrink, lightweight spackle, pack it in the hole with my finger, then wipe a VERY THIN film over the now-filled hole so that there is A LITTLE excess to sand off later (not much later, though, it's easier to sand if it's less than a day old). You can sand it after less than an hour. Most primed trim I've seen needs to be sanded anyway before painting, and I definitely like to sand it before I caulk it.

My favorite nail-hole filler, though, is Crawford's Spackle. This is not to be confused with Crawford's Putty (one of those clay/oil mixtures). The spackle comes in a bright green quart can, and is roughly the consistency of a thick drywall joint compound, but with a better cohesiveness. It's also not lightweight, but still sands very well. I apply it the same way as the lightweight spackle above, but it does dry more quickly, so your fingers will get crusty.

Jason