Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

Posts

Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

#1

Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

howard

>I prefer sharpening by hand but time is the culprit. I know the Tormek has gotten good reviews but I am looking for something in the $150 t0 $300 range. Any suggestions on what might be reliable? Thanks for the help.

Re: Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

#2

Recent threads give an answer

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>In the last day or two, or at least within the last week (because I can't remember anything farther back than that) there was a thread about grinder/sharpeners. Look back for that.

I recall AJ remarking that the Grizzley tool was made for them by some (German?) outfit that I was not familiar with - but that it seemed to be a quality tool much cheaper than the Tormek. The accessories were not as good as the Tormek's, but the Tormek accessories fit the Grizzley.

Look back at recent threads

Henry

Re: Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

#3

Re: Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Howard,

There are a couple Tormek kniockoffs around. I believe one is from Harbor Freight, and one from Grizzly. I use an alternative--a wet wheel grinder from Grizzly. Wit a AccuSharp jigs for long and short chisels, I have no trouble with keen edges. A diamond honing by hand and polishing on my buffing wheel result it razor sharp edgesand shaved arm hairs. All tiold, I doubt if I have more than $200 invested in all hardware. A used washing machine motor powers the buffing head.

George

Re: Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

#4

The lowest.............

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Yes, a conventional bench grinder and a properly selected crowned wheel.

One of the incorrect assumptions some make on grinding is that the whole edge must be ground at once by pushing the tool into or across a flat wheel. I don't know if this approach works with a very slow water cooled wheel but it certainly does not with a bench grinder. Instead, the proper technique is to use a crowned wheel and move the tool back and forth across the wheel with a very light touch. Only a few thousandths of an inch of metal is removed at each pass and one examines the edge after every few passes to see what has been removed and what still needs to be. The crown enables one to grind at any portion of the edge with each pass. It is common to overgrind the edges so I start grinding at the center and move out to the edges with subsequent passes. In short order I can grind right to the edge of any chisel or plane iron with a 3600 rpm wheel.

The result is a hollow grind that one can refine with a few swipes on a stone or other fixed abrasive ( I use diamond stones).

Re: Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

#5

JET

Don Orr

>I have the JET 10" slow speed wet grinder that is similar to the Tormek and works very well for quite a bit less money I got it at Holiday time and got 3 accessories free, free shipping, $75 total rebate an one of the resin cast mini tools.

Easy setup, easy to use and get good results. Not as cheap as Grizzly, but I had tried a Grizz and did not like it at all. Very cheap way to try is the HF version.

Re: Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

#7

Re: Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

john lucas

>I bought the Sheppac which is made in Germany. The only complaint I heard about it was that it was easy to stall. I put a spring on the motor to pull the drive wheel into the main wheel and it's powerful enough to do anything I want. I picked it up for $100. I think you can buy them off of Amazon for just a little more.

I'm pretty sure it's not a Tormek and it didn't come with any good accessories but the Jet and Grizzly accesories fit. It's done what I want to do for now which was speed up reconditioning tools. It works great for that. I can take an old plane iron and in minutes have it cutting really well. Possibly not as good as the scary sharp system but good enough for many purposes.

What It won't do very well, and I don't know if the tormek has this problem, is put a really fine edge on a carving tool. I rough the tool, then grade the stone and grind a finer edge and then go to the leather strop. It has a polished edge and seems to cut pretty well but if you look at it under magnification there are ridges in the bevel. It's like there needs to be a stone in between the fine and the strop to clean up these ridges. When I do the next one I'm going to try and use a diamond hone by hand to finish the bevel before going to the strop. I think you need a really superior edge on a hand carving tool. At least as good as the scary sharp system I was using before.

Re: Lower Cost Slow Speed Sharpening

#8

Thanks All...................

howard

>I'm looking seriously at the work sharp unit, the one that uses sandpaper attached to a glass plate. Should do what I need for handcarving tools. Thanks again