Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Carving tool sharpening info needed

Posts

Carving tool sharpening info needed

#1

Carving tool sharpening info needed

Joe Pack

>I am an absolutely new carver. I have a set of carving tools (Swiss Made Rockler Anniversary Set) plus 4 other (Ashley Isles) that need sharpening. These are new, so the factory bevel is still on them for guidance. What I don't know is how to sharpen them properly.

I went with a friend to a carving studio one night and saw that they had a couple of wheels mounted on a motor/arbor setup. One wheel looked to be linen, the other leather. I assume both had some sort of compound on them, as it took just a touch to bring a sharp edge back to the tool.

I have a 6" grinder I am not using. Would it be appropriate to set this up with 2 wheels dedicated to sharpening carving tools? If so, what wheels/compounds, etc. do I need? Am I even on the right track here?

Any and all advice would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#2

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

Dan Donaldson

>I would guess that the wheels that you saw were for a fast method of honing the tools. I would say that this is great for a professional carving shop to get the speed up, but is probably overkill for someone that doesn't do carving all of the time, and you can burn the tool if not careful. I just use a piece of leather charged with "green stuff" for honing. I have a flat piece that I use for the outside bevel (I roll the tool as it is dragged down the leather strip) and one that is folded over to get the inside.

One other thing. It is usual to sharpen gouges with a small bevel on the inside and not "flat" like a turning gouge or a chisel. The reason for this is to allow you to "climb" out of a cut while carving. A "flat" edge will tend to dive into the work and is more difficult to control. There has been discussion in the past on this topic.

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

Jesper, Denmark

>You are on the right track, and no doubt others will add some details.

My suggestion is to turn the grinder around, so that you hone the tools with the felt and flap wheels moving in the opposite direction to that of a normal grinder.

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#4

What I've used

Chris Knob

>To true and polish the inside of curved tools, I wrap sandpaper in asending grits up to 2000 around wooden dowels of matching diameters to the gouges. For the bevel honing, there is nothing better than a narrow stationary belt sander. Grizzly sells one of these very cheaply and they have belt grits up to 320. The fexible belt more easily conforms to the outside diameter if the gouge curve for better freehand sharpening. For the final honing, I use a high grit wetstone.

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#5

JL

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

JL

>I'm not really a carver. I have a small set of tools that I use to add gutters and volutes to furniture. As I don't do much carving, I didn't really see the need to invest in separate machinery to sharpen the tools. I have a small ceramic slip stone to touch up the insides. I also have a couple of waterstone "plates" with grooves. For honing, I generally use the leather add-on to my Tormek.

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#6

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>The Pfeil / Swiss made chisels are good tools. Problem is they have been buffed and dubbed over so you have to hold them at a high angle relative to the work surface to get them cutting. High angle = less control. You can see this dubbed edge if you wiggle the tool and look at light reflecting off the bevel.

To get the edge prepared well, remove the dubbed-over part, regrind and hone. I use a belt sander in a shop-made fixture for heavy metal removal. I never grind all the way to the edge. The last bit of metal is honed off on oil stones, then stropped on mdf or leather charged with green compound.

Sharpening these gouges is challenging! Keep at it and it will come. I highly recommend Chris Pye's books on the subject.

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#7

Here's some info from a master *LINK*

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Ian Agrell is a British classical carver who lives in California. He was my guest in the Chat Room on one occasion. I visited his shop in Sausalito years ago, where they were carving stuff like a half-million dollar Chippendale mirror, and korbels for the Utah State House, and saw how he and his employees sharpened their tools. The thing that struck me was that all their tools were super sharp and polished, and that they didn't use hand-held stones. The objective was to sharpen quickly as needed and get back to work. They were using a John Burke sharpening system for most if not all their honing needs. (I guess there are tools that it won't work for, like veiners, but I'm not sure. Here's a link to the Burke Page:http://216.106.57.180/~burkes/product1.html, and here's a pretty lame YouTube video of it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbMZiCFCSV0.

For quick-and-dirty edge touch-up, they went straight to the leather strop, which was charged with a very fine-grit polishing paste that came in a tube. I think it was British.

Anyhow, read what Ian says about sharpening in the link below.

Ellis


Ian Agrell Carving Tool Sharpening Article

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#8

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

Tony - Memphis

>I may the minority here and I certainly don't conisder myself a carver, but I don't think you need much more than a few oil stones, strops, etc. Don't make it more expensive or more complicated than it needs to be! At some point, you may need to re-grind a tool, but usually, you only need to hone. Oils stones seem more popular for carving tools than water stones because they don't wear as fast. When sharpening carving tools, your contact point is just that - a point (sort of). So you would be grooving up your water stones rather quickly. I use the green stuff or the yellow stuff on mdf for stropping and I also made a couple of shaped leather covered strops (leather scraps from the fabric store). I have a few slips that I use too. Phil Lowe gives a good demonstration of his technique in his Ball & Claw carving video. Anything by Mr. Pye is great (he has a book and a DVD out on sparpening). Generally though, I really don't see that anything motorized is required. I took a class with Mack Headley once and his sharpening stones looked like rocks he had gathered from a creek! He said most all of his were second, third, fourth hand and many of them were small pieces. Also, if you do go motorized, take note of the speed of the sharpening systems out there - most are pretty slow. You might check the library for some of the DVD's. I bought Mr. Pye's and it has been a big help. His web site has some good info as well. There is really no secret to it, but it does take practice. Good luck with it!

Tony

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#9

Lee Grindinger

Excellant article!

Lee Grindinger

>Ian accomplished the article I always intended to write.

The importance of the secondary bevels cannot be stressed enough. While the 10 degrees is not all that critical it's vital that there be a fulcrum whether it's rounded as Ian advocates or left alone after honing.

Lee

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#10

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

John McGaw

>John Hartvigson, a friend from Alaska, is an expert carver. He had rigged a low speed spindle mounted with MDF disks into which were cut profiles of his various gouges and such. He then sharpened using compound applied to the wheel as needed. I can vouch for the efficacy of the process -- I never found one of his tools that was less than razor sharp.

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#11

And here's some info from another... *LINK*

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>Chris Pye. It's important to know why to sharpen a certain way, and Chris explains all. After viewing, you may wish to change some of the parameters of the Swiss Made carving chisels.

Best, Ted


Chris Pye's Sharpening Video

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#12

Danger, Will Robinson....overload eminent

Joe Pack

>Lots to digest! As with sharpening my lathe tools, it is evident there will be a learning curve here. At least I have some good background advice to get me started. Thanks. Your tips are much appreciated.

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed

#13

Re: Carving tool sharpening info needed *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Joe,

If your experience parallels mine, you won't have any money left to buy fancy sharpening stuff after you've purchased your quality carving tools ;-).

Anyway, I had to learn a little bit about carving last summer to complete a project. You've gotten great advice. I found several resources helpful: Chris Pye's "Woodcarving - Tools, Materials & Equipment", Volume 1 (New Edition), and "Relief Carving in Wood - A Practical Approach". The second book focuses on learning technique, while the first is more comprehensive with more on sharpening than the second book.

Rob Cosman has a set of DVDs on carving with Chris Pye. The first in the series covers sharpening using, naturally, Pye's approach. I found the DVD to be excellent and up to the high standard that Cosman's other DVDs have set. Cosman asked Pye to teach him carving and the DVD reflects almost a real-time description of what to do from both a sharpening and technique standpoint. And many of Cosman's questions to Pye reflect his flat-wood background and make the DVD more interesting IMHO. Cosman's website also carries Pye's sharpening oil stones etc. (as does Tools for Working Wood).

I went with a couple of inexpensive water slip stones, some green honing copmpound from Lee Valley, and a leather wheel mounted to my slow speed grinder, but a piece of sturdy leather would also work. I wish Pyes's stones came in a water version as they are nicely designed.

I also practice quite a bit on scrap mahogany, which is a nice wood to practice on. That really helped. Have fun!!!

Jim


Rob Cosman (with Chris Pye) Carving DVD