Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Two questions about Oak plywood

Posts

Two questions about Oak plywood

#1

Two questions about Oak plywood

Bernard

>Sorry for the long post, but I need help.

I am in the process (1/4 done)of building a big bookshelf unit for my daughter's house (total width about 11 ft, staggered height up to about 10 ft). It is being done completely with oak boards (for the face frames, etc.) and 3/4" oak veneered plywood.

I have to say up front that I am an AMATEUR carpenter, even though I love doing it in my spare time, and have done some pretty good work in the past.

I am in Florida, and unfortunately, within my vicinity, the only oak plywood I could get was at Lowe's/ Home Depot. Frankly, it is junk compared to the much better product I used 13 years ago in another project. Looks okay when done but obviously, with the humidity kicking up here, and the thinner veneers in this plywood, I am having trouble with them bowing once I rip them.

Anyway, when I was building the main base cabinet, the plywood had started to bow on me, and I had a heck of a time trying to straighten it out, and I was not 100% successful, as the back is not totally straight, and one end will be almost 1/8" from the wall. It will not show, but here is the question #1: I am concerned about the plywood shelves after I cut them. I obviously do not want them to bow after they have been cut and put up (I am drilling holes and they will sit on shelf pins). Would you say that once they are finished, they should not bow any more? I guess I was planning on applying the finish on even the cut ends to try to hold out moisture. I originally was going to use Deft Brushing Lacquer, although being concerned with dust in my environment, I have been encouraged to use the boiled linseed oil-turpentine-varnish rubbing combination, which I have been told works very well with red oak.

My second question refers to the top of the cabinet bases. I originally was going to use a single sheet of cut oak plywood with moldings, of course. Although now I am wondering if I am asking for trouble doing so: with these thin veneers, and the cabinet tops probably getting the most use with stuff like flower vases, picture frames, are they guaranteed to get damaged very easily, or am I overly worrying about nothing, and once it is finished, it will hold up fine (it is not a kitchen cabinet after all?). My only alternative would be to join two oak boards together for the top, although I do not have a biscuit joiner, I would probably have to do so by clamping, glue and pocket screws underneath. I have used pocket screws to construct the face frame, and it worked great.

Any and all advise is GREATLY appreciated and I thank you in advance. Thanks!

Bernard

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#2

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Depending on the length of the shelves and the weight they will see you may want to attach ribs to the bottom side of the shelves to stiffen them. These ribs may only be an inch tall, but will dramatically stiffen the shelf.

One advantage of a loose shelf is that if it bows, you can flip it over and put the bow up.

Lee

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#3

Re: If you want a solid top...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>You can do that, without biscuits. Long grain glue joints are stronger than the wood they join, in almost every case. And the top would be sturdier than the veneer would give you, too.

I've never been to Florida, but there are woodworkers there who buy from people besides Lowes and Home Depot. You may have to drive an hour or two, but good cabinet grade oak veneer ply is available. Call a cabinet shop and ask them where they buy theirs, and if they have any suggestions for buying three or four sheets.

The other suggestion about support ribs is spot on, as well. Particularly if the shelves are more than 30" in length.

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#4

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

Bill Earl

>As Lee says, you can easily stiffen the shelves. But I'd be wary of using the stuff for the top. The veneers they use are paper thin, and the inner plys have a lot of voids.

I was spraying some birch ply with shellac last week and the face veneer started to pucker in lines at right angles to the grain. I poked one of the wrinkled spots with a pencil and it easily went through the face veneer.

I saw similar problems when I tried to use it as a substrate for veneer. Coming out of the veneer press, I could see grooves where all the internal voids were.

I ended up scrapping a lot of crappy plywood and some very nice veneer. Good ply is expensive these days, but the cheap stuff will cost you more in the long run.

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#5

not your only choice for plywood

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Find a local cabinet shop and see where they get their plywood from.

Book shelves will get abrasion wear. I would consider a harder finish than what you are contemplating.

I see no problem with a plywood top.

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#6

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

Ray Binnicker

>My 2 cent response is about getting your plywood from Lowes/Home Depot. The last time I checked both of their so called "cabinet plywoods (birch and Oak) were both being made in China. Lord only knows what they use to put that stuff together with; I know I will not use it even for basic shop projects. I just drove 2 hours to get 3 sheets of maple ply. I don't mind a bit doing it either.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#7

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

Bernard

>I guess the feeling is unanimous that I need to return the crap I have (hopefully they will not give me any trouble about that)and find some other, better, plywood. I was afraid of that, but deep down I know that is what I have to do.

My to-do list tomorrow will be to make calls to cabinet makers and hope that they can tell me where to get this from.

By the way, the width of the shelves will be 22" in most sections with a depth of 15", with a couple at 29" with a depth of 12".

I will post again with a followup question after obtaining (hopefully) replacement plywood.

Any opinion of rubbing varnish diluted with the BLO and turp instead of lacquer or poly, since I am working out of an attached garage with the heat and humidity rolling in for the next 7 months?

Thanks again to all those who gave me their opinion, it is greatly appreciated.

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#8

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood *LINK*

Fred Davis

>Bernard,

since your dealing with a dead load that ranks high weight wise per running foot of shelf , you may want to consider that Plywood without a lot of help will sag , immediately.

The good news is you can purchase Oak lumber from a hardwood lumber dealer cheaper then a good grade and brand of plywood , like Apple for instance.

This is far stronger , permits slim appearing shelving, looks the same top and bottom.

These book cases I made for our Library some years ago use this approach and the shelves do not sag in a 36 " span and if they every do I would simpley flip the shelf.

The finish is Lacquer, much better in my opinion then home made concoctions , dubious at best for a long wearing finish.

Hope this helps.

FredD


http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/wawg2Q8hwD7Vq7rxm3io-Q?authkey=Gv1sRgCLyvxdiyq5nzxwE&feat=directlink

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#9

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

Dennis Yoder

>Where are you in Florida? There are many many better places to buy plywood than the big boxes. Dennis Y

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#10

Re: Found Some Plywood, hopefully

Bernard

>Well, spurred by all of you, I started to make a lot more phone calls- many places went out of business, but from a chain of recommendations, I finally found a place that sells A-1 Oak plywood for $70 a sheet. That will boost my cost for the project, but I want this to last and my work is my signature, so I will go by the place tomorrow afternoon to look at it to make sure what they told me is true. The kicker is that I never even heard of this place, and yet it is only about 2 miles from where I work!

Thanks again for everybody taking the time to tell me straight as to what to do. If it looks good, then my big job will be to have Lowe's take back 6 or 7 sheets and give me my money back. I hope they don't give me too much trouble.

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#11

Re: Found Some Plywood, hopefully

Barry Irby

>I find Lowes to be very good about returns. So good in fact that I marvel at them. I used to keep my left overs just in case. Now, I store them at Lowes. The down side to their generous return policy is that you really have to check what you buy. I nearly bought a half used tube of caulk. Actually bought some pluming fittings that had the purple cleaner already on them. Take your receipt and they will return your money "in kind". Put the cash back on your credit card or hand you cash. OTOH, if you don't have the receipt they will ask for your drivers license and give you a store gift card.

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

#12

Re: Two questions about Oak plywood

Pete in Holland, MI

>Not sure about any kind of oil finish on a book case. If the oil is not 100% cured, at any point of it's life, it may start to wick into any books that sit in one spot for years on end. Think you need to stick with something that seals & cures.