Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

Posts

Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#1

Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>So the batteries in my DeWalt 14.5v 1/2" chuck cordless drill are due for replacement. Primecell wants $56 each to rebuild + upgrade them to NiMH to about twice the power as the old ones when new. Net $135 with shipping.

But

I can get a new 18v Hitachi 1/2" Lithium drill from Amazon (and give WC a little commission) for about $240.

The Dewalt's a perfectly good drill.

I have an 18v Hitachi impact drive that's absa-loootly amazin'.

What to do.

What to do.

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#2

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

John K Jordan

>Curious why they are "due for replacement". Won't hold a charge?

A friend brought three "worthless" Dewalt batteries over last week and we zapped them with my welding machine. (Applying a strong current pulse can vaporize conductive whiskers which sometimes grow and short batteries with nickle chemistry)

He said the first one he tried works now.

JKJ

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#3

battery replacements

Philip Duffy

>Mark, Look to see if you have a Batteries Plus store in your vicinity. I took my cordless in, got new battery in 2 days and it still running full power after 3 years. Cost was half of what you have been quoted. Phil

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#4

Re: battery replacements

del schisler

>i have a dewalt 12volt battery wouldn't hold a charge I used my battery charger and zap it a few time's and it went on charge and would work fine I would like to had 24volt to zap but didn't want to do a serries of 12volt battery's To much trouble 12volt worked ok Try it Be sure and get the + and - right the plus is faceing to the biggest part of the battery neg is on the back side or smallest part of battery If you have a volt meter you can check also good luck

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#5

Yeah, But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That 1/2 cost appears to be for 1.2mAH cells. Went by their place in Union, NJ. I think they wanted $60+ for XRP NiCads. Even Amazon beats their price for new packs by quite a bit.

The price I got from Primecell is to rebuild my packs to 3.3mAH with NiMh cells that still charge in my old charger. I can get "XRP" NiCad cell rebuilds for $38 each.

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#6

No Guts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>They run out of gas very quickly.

They're 5 years old and have been "zapped" twice already.

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#7

This is what I'm hearig

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>A guy that is really trying to rationalize a NEW DRILL. I say go for the new drill! I had to have a ladder go out from under me and the drill land on the concrete floor to get a new drill. Lisa wanted the 18v Makita with Impact driver combo, I was only going to get a 14.4v DeWalt but whats a guy to do.

glc

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#8

It's a lie, lie, lie.......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I mean "Li"..... as in "Li-thium" :)

Hey, I've got a half dozen DeWalt 12V batteries, plus a few Panasonic (and other) 12V batteries, oh, and several of the drills that they USED to power..... all sitting in a box in the corner of the workshop. They've been replaced with a combo set of Milwuakee drill/impact drivers powered by their (tiny) 12V Li-ion batteries.

Now I don't use them 8 hours a day, nor can I compare them to the 18V versions, but these 12V pack alot of power in a small package.

No, more old batteries for me.... I've switched to Li-Ion baby!

;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Decisions, Decisions. . . . .

#9

Actually . . .Not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I originally got the 14v drill to get a bit more beef but still control the tool weight. Now that LiIon has reduced the weights so much, an increase in voltage is tempting.

However, just got e-mailed by the rebuilder that NiMH cells are not available for my pack, so at $86 for high capacity NiCads, the economics have been pushed to redoing the batteries rather than spending the $$$ for a new drill that I don't use that often anyway. Most of what I do, I can do with the lighter 12v drill or the 18v impact driver.

mm