Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Sound reduction in a new shop

Posts

Sound reduction in a new shop

#1

Sound reduction in a new shop

Chris Knob

>Hi friends. I'm getting a new house and a new shop. It's going to be a garage workshop. The problem is that it will share a wall with the new family room. There is a door between the two spaces. I have been doing quite a bit of reading on noise reduction on the web and I had already worked out a scheme in my head that, apparently would have done nothing to address the problem. What have my intreped WC brothers and sisters done that is proven to be effective and reasonable?

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#2

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

paul mayer

>that pretty much describes all three of my shops that I have had in the past. In one of them, I had noie problems. Cinder block walls seemed to transfer a lot of noise into the house, and not enough insulation in the garage ceiling. The worst part was that the bedrooms were directly above the garage, so with inadequate insulation, every move I made was heard in the bedrooms. That was a bummer, because I like to do my thing out there early in the morning, which was not popular with the sleepers.

The other two shops both had 6" thick walls insulated with fiberglass. No noise problems with those. The door needs to be solid, and well sealed, and then you shouldn't have any problems there either.

Make sure you get your dust collection solid as well in a connected shop.

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#3

My idea

Chris Knob

>I want to stud out the existing sheetrock wall with 2x4s, put either soundproofing insulation or egg crate foam in the space and panel over it with 1/4" pegboard. I read the best thing to do is build the second wall as an independent unit with no contact with the inside wall that would transfer vibration.

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#4

Alan Young

Just tell the family that when you are in the shop

Alan Young

>you must have total quite and they will have to play their music and watch TV some other time. Artists cannot be disturbed-period.

:^)

Congrats on the new house and shop!

Chief of noise from the basement

Alan

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#5

Sooo, Chris...

David Yoho

>I suppose taking a recipricating saw and cutting the shop away from the house and moving it several feet away is out of the question?!!!

Congrats on the new house and shop!

David

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#6

Re: My idea

Scott in Montana

>Chris,

Your idea is very close to the best that you can do in your situation. Building a 2x4 wall in front of the common wall will be very effective. Do not attach it to the existing wall; it must be spaced out by maybe a quarter inch. It should only be attached to the ceiling and the floor... and the less attachments to the ceiling, the better. The idea is to stop the transfer of vibration through to the interior wall. Acoustic insulation works better than traditional batts, but it is slightly more expensive.

Also, you will want to cover it with 5/8" sheetrock or staggered double sheets of 1/2" with silicone caulk in between. Sheetrock is very non-resonant compared to other wall covering materials.

Hope this helps,

Scott in Montana

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#7

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

Terry Quiram

>Chris

Is there anyone in your area that sprays Icynene Insulation? I remodeled my dinning room last year and used that in the walls and ceiling. I don't hear any traffic noise from the street. Plus the room is a lot warmer in the winter and cooler in the summer.

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#8

Re: My idea

mdclor

>Chris,

I agree with the independent wall if that is possible. I have also read about using pegboard over insulation. IIRC, place the rough side toward the shop. Your building inspector might not like exposed insulation however. If you have to go with dry wall, thicker is better and use z strips between it and the studs. Also seal with soundproofing caulk.

Good luck,

Merle

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#9

Re: My idea

David Hammelef

>Good thought. Are you planing on putting a second door in the wall. 2 door are better than 1.

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#10

Re: My idea

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I researched a lot when I did my basement shop. I built a staggered stud wall between my shop and the rec room in the basement. It works well. Basically the header and footer are 2x6 and the 2x4 studs are arranged such that they are on 16" centers on either side. There winds up being a stud every 8". Then insulation is woven between them. It would save a little space over building another entire wall.

Plain ole insulation is much better than egg crate foam. Drywall is much better than anything with holes in it. But, the combination of isolation and insulation will do the job. The door you have there will probably be sufficient assuming it isn't a really old house. Fire laws are such that garage doors are usually pretty reasonable. I used a solid core exterior door in the basement.

If you do remove the drywall and rebuild the wall, check what fire regs require you to put up. Around here there is a layer under the drywall requied for fire regs. Made adding wiring to my garage a pain.

Jay

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

#11

Re: Sound reduction in a new shop

Fred Davis

>Chris ,

unless you live in a backwards part of the country and some of it still is, you may save yourself a lot of grief by contacting the building dept.

Typical firewall construction requires a two hour wall minimum which translate into 5/8ths thick type X drywall , not two layers of something else.

The egress door into the living quarters part of the house has to be a two hour door also, some accept sheet metal over a solid door and most require that door to be steel with steel jambs.

In addition most Fire marshals and building departments require any hole cut though the wall for plumbing , wiring , etc to be in a steel chase.

If you are living in a area that subscribes to these rules and build a wall that does not conform , you will find out about the fine details when at some future date you sell your home and it becomes subject to a conformance inspection by guys like Barry for the buyer.

FredD