Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Excuse to Buy a New Router?

Posts

Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#1

Excuse to Buy a New Router?

Marvin Horn

>Getting ready to start replacing the laminate countertops in my kitchen. I have the normal assortment of routers already but no laminate trimmer. Is there any real advantage to a laminate trimmer over a full size router? Small kitchen and simple layout. I know I shouldn't pass up any excuse to buy a new toy but can't honestly see any advantage to the smaller trimmer other than convienence.

Would appreciate your input.

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#2

For one project, don't spend money

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Laminate trimmers, now being called "trim routers," are handy little critters, but not necessary. If you're not expecting to get into laminate in a big way, your existing routers should do the job.

You don't need much amperage - your smallest router should be fine.

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#3

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Marvin,

I have a little Harbor Freight laminate trimmer which I've used for years, and it cost me less than 20 bucks. It works fine. I use it mostly to rout out hinge mortices for cabinets. It has a clear base. It isn't a "production" machine but will do what you are talking about, plus a bit more. I can control it much better than any of my P+C machines.

George

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#4

How much are you saving?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>How much are you saving doing the job yourself (compared to hiring the job out)?

How much time/money do you risk loosing if you make a mistake and ruin part of the job/materials using the "wrong" tool?

What's the cost ratio of new tools vs materials for the project?

Are you the kind of person (of type of situtation) that will do a job yourself to save money that doesn't exist (ie. you wouldn't be able to afford the upgrade unless you did it yourself) or to save money for something else you enjoy, like a vacation, new TV, or a new tool?

While there certainly is overlap in the funtionality of many tools, never underestimate the value of a tool specially suited for a specific job.

And while a full size router can do the job of a trim-router fairly well, the nice thing about trim-routers is that they can do alot of other router-type jobs. By that I mean that a trim-router isn't just for trim. It's not a tool you'll buy for a laminate job and then will sit on a shelf forever, it's a tool that can often be used more effectively that a full size router in many situations. I seem to use my full size routers half as often now because alot of my routing needs are better handle by a smaller trim-router.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

Jesper, Denmark

>The excuse is that if you buy a nice little trim router, you will use that more than any of the other ones.

I have a PC trim router, which mostly gets used with a round-over bit for allmost any job I do.

Handy little critter.

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#6

alternative uses

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I use a small router for routing out hinge mortises and similar detailed fine work. For a counter top I would (have) reached for a medium sized router. I like the security (less tippy) of the larger base.

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#7

Ditto - don't use small router for laminate

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I have a little Bosch Colt, variable speed. Nice little router, but the last thing I'd use it for is laminate work. Like Bill said, it's just too tippy due to the small base. My laminate trimming is always done with a PC-690 in a D-handle base due to the vastly better control you have over the machine. The little Colt is primarily a roundover bit machine. And even for that, it's a bit tippy.

Good friend's son works for Bosch and they're always giving tools away to contractors and such for evaluation feedback. I got this one for free. After using it for a while, I can honestly say I would not waste my money on a laminate trimmer unless I had a specific use for it like small hinge morticing or other detail work.

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#8

Think twice. *LINK*

Bricofleur

>Marvin,

Here is my suggestion:

If you don't have two similar plunge routers with which you can use template guide bushings, I would recommand to buy that second router instead of the trim router. Any router will do what a trim router can do, but having two plunge routers with two sets of guide bushings can save a lot of fussings on particular projects. As example, when I bored the bench dog holes on my workbench I used two different router bit sizes. Since I had two plunge routers and two sets of guide bushings I was able to bore them all by just swaping routers instead of changing router bits for each hole. I was using a template jig to locate each hole. If you want to learn more about using two plunge routers with this jig, follow the link to the appropriate page of my website.

Yes, a plunge router is more expensive, but it's worthed.

If you already have those two plunge routers and two sets of guide bushings, buy the trim router because they are light and great for routing chamfers or roundovers in any plans (horizontal or vertical).

By the way, if you buy a trim router, choose on that accepts guide bushings!

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com


img

Bench Dog Holes Boring Jig

Re: Excuse to Buy a New Router?

#9

Thanks for the input

Marvin Horn

>