Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Computer drawing program

Posts

Computer drawing program

#1

Computer drawing program

Jim Vest

>I know I should be paying attention more than I do (at least that's what my wife tells me), but I would like to purchase a simple computer program that can draw a project, create a material list, and detailed drawing of the layout or project.

I know the basics about computers, but am not savey with CAD programs. I tried Delta CAD but removed it because I could hand-draw the project faster.

I AM LISTENING NOW!

Re: Computer drawing program

#2

Re: "I could hand-draw the project faster"

Marvin Horn

>I believe this will be true initially with almost any/all CAD program(s).

Just my experience, no data....

Re: Computer drawing program

#3

Re: Computer drawing program

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I took a class on SketchUp, free from Google. Works well.

Learning to use it for me was 'fun', because certain mouse movements and gestures that I learned decades ago mean different things in SketchUp, and unlearning them came first.

Drawing something by hand is fine, if you make no changes, make no turned parts, make no multiples, make assume joinery, etc. I'm working on a library cabinet with 24 doors, glazed, and the dimensions of the face frames are still a bit iffy. So is the door joinery. Editing to change from bridal to biscuit to floating tenons, and keeping all the edit phases, works on the computer.

But I may just scratch it out, and build as it flows from the tooling. There's only one of them to build, and I'm doing it all.

Check it out. Don't run it on a weak computer, though. Plenty of memory, a good graphics card, and a fast enough processor are needed to make it work well. My laptop hates it without a separate monitor.

Re: Computer drawing program

#4

Good Sketchup Tutorials  *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

>


Sketchup Tutorials

Re: Computer drawing program

#5

Re: Good Sketchup Tutorials

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>I agree that the Sketchup is a fine program ......for those that get on to how to use it. Just seems toooo jerky for me to understand and use. I do my own pencil drawings much faster with my brain and put the ideas on paper softly and then trace over them with ink for the final designs. I'm just toooo old to use these new fangled programs.

Re: Computer drawing program

#6

Re: Computer drawing program

David Hay @ Denver

>I find SketchUp pretty easy to use. Their tutorials are pretty good to get you into the basics of using the program.

With regard to hand drawing, I tend to believe that there's a place for both. I think that doing some initial hand sketches of what you want to build is good way to design something, since you can iterate over your ideas pretty quickly. However, once your idea is beginning to solidify, something like SketchUp is good for working out the details of what joinery to use, how the pieces will relate to each other, getting a final check of the dimensions and assisting in building a materials list.

David

Re: Computer drawing program

#7

Right on

Bill Howatt

>I've been kept out of trouble several times by putting the sketch into CAD and finding issues that weren't obvious in the sketch such as too thin walls, interference and even "just doesn't look right" since my sketches are rarely to scale. Hand-drawing a sketch to scale quickly reduces the freedom of expression component.

Bill

Re: Computer drawing program

#8

Re: Computer drawing program

Jim Dillon

>Jim,

Sorry DeltaCad didn't work out for you, as I am a fan and use it quite a bit. It would surprise me if any program can draw something as fast as you can sketch something out on paper. But a sketch is all it is - an important idea/concept/design generator. I think there is a place for sketches, a place for a 2-D program like DeltaCad, and a place for a 3-D program like SketchUp. I also think that as ones woodworking experience increases, the utility of sketching ironically increases as one does not need a full-blown 2- or 3-D drawing to visualize what must be done.

Both 2-D and 3-D software programs will take time to learn. It can be frustrating at first, but with time and practice, it will get much easier. FWIW, I use DeltaCad to generate the exact dimensions and to fine-tune the design. I then reenter those dimensions in CutList Plus and generate a material list and, most important, a cutting layout for the boards I will then buy at my local hardwood supplier. I have played with SketchUp and think it could be very useful, and may be what you are looking for; I sure plan on learning it. Just some thoughts.

Jim

Re: Computer drawing program

#9

Re: Computer drawing program

Walt

>I have been using Cadkey for my design projects for years. It is a 3D wire frame program that is easy to use. I function that I find helpful is the "box move"...it will allow you to stretch or compress your design and the details will adjust to the new design. Then I use Cutlist for my materials needs.

Walt

Re: Computer drawing program

#10

I tried but...

Bricofleur

>I tried Sketchup and soon found out it's faster and easier with a pencil, a ruler and a piece of paper (and an eraser of course!). I believe those programs are great for drawing plans for others, not for the woodworker himself.

Best,

Serge

www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com

Re: Computer drawing program

#11

Re: Computer drawing program *LINK*

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>I am a big fan of eCabinet Systems cabinet design software. Some say it's not the easiest program to learn to use, but once you do learn it, it is extremely powerful. And, best of all, it's free.

I teach a class on it locally at Palomar College in San Marcos, CA; so I've got a pretty good description of what the software does in the attached link.

Joe


img

eCabinet Systems Info

Re: Computer drawing program

#12

Re: Computer drawing program

Tony - Memphis

>Hi Jim. I've been using CAD for many years. I've used the best and the worst! For most woodworking, I think 3D is really overkill and takes more time than it is worth. Sketchup is a great program and you can't beat the price. But, I think it take more time than needed to produce a drawing. I guess it really depends on what you want to do. I normally use an old version of IntelliCAD (an AutoCAD clone) that was free when it came out. It is easy to use and does just what I need (it is a 2D program - mainly). I'm not really up on the latest offerings, but start simple. TurboCAD seems to be a good package and you can get older versions cheap (try nothingbutsoftware.com). Actually, what you are asking (to get a drawing and cut list) is quite complex. There are plugins for Sketchup and lisp files for the various systems that will do that for you, but its not as easy as you might expect. I use Sketchup to do some concepts, but I rarely use it for real detailed layout. For that, I rely on my trusty old 2D application. Be patient, there will be a pretty good learning curve with any of this stuff. Takes a while to learn to "think CAD." Something else to remember is that the difference between most 2D and 3D apps is that in 2D, you draw lines, in 3D you create objects. Good luck with it. I probably use one or the other applications every day. Even if I'm just sketching something out.

Tony

Re: Computer drawing program

#13

Example...

Tony - Memphis

>This is a Sketchup model I did for a patio table with a tiled top. I did this just to get some proportions right. To get the final design though, I used Intellicad 2D. Why? It was much much easier to draw. And even easier to edit. I'll post a pic of the table progress to so you can see the final design was much different. The Sketchup model did help me work out some proportions though. I didn't add much detail to my model. Just enough to see what I needed to see.

Tony


img

Re: Computer drawing program

#14

In progress...

Tony - Memphis

>Nothing glued here, just dry assembled for test fitting... Notice though how different the final design is from the Sketchup drawing? Trying different shapes (especially curves) is much quicker in 2D (for me anyway). I notice a lot of folks feel like a pencil and paper is quicker. For me, its not. But, I've been using CAD for years and it is second nature to me. I do end up making a lot of pencil sketches/adjustments to my drawings out in the shop. Hard to think of every detail and mistake (oops!) you may encounter and have to make adjustments for. None of my CAD drawings represnt the final product by the time I'm finished.

Tony

PS - Why is the tile top not setting flush? Well, it turns out that cement board is hard to cut in a straight line, let alone two layers of it! AND, tiles aren't cut perfect either. So, I made my frame square and then "let in" the tile top using a rabbet plane.


img