Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

granite saw table

Posts

granite saw table

#1

granite saw table

N orm

>I have a Ridgid table saw which I like very much. Last time I went to Home Depot I looked at the new table saw and much to my surprise it has a granite table! I've never read anything about this. I can see some advantages in not rusting or warping but what about chipping and cracking? What are your thoughts on this? Norm, Camillus, NY

Re: granite saw table

#2

Re: granite saw table

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>It's great for rolling out pie dough.

Clint

Re: granite saw table

#3

and traditionally prepared fudge! YUM!

Stuart Hough

>

Re: granite saw table

#4

Re: granite saw table

Charlie Self

>I had one here for an article. Cracking is said to be no more of a problem than it is with cast iron--the table was a full 1-3/4" thick, with webbing to support it, and the thing is massive. It outweighed any other saw in its category by about 100 pounds, all of it in granite, I'd think. Chipping: what Scott Box (Steel City Toolworks) told me a year or so ago was that dings and chips are easily epoxied for a fix, should they occur, but aren't much more likely than with cast iron.

How accurate that is, and whether or not it will be a problem, is something only 10-15 years experience will tell. The Ridgid warranty may or may not be needed over the long term.

I wouldn't want to use one for an anvil, any more than I'd use a Unisaw table for an anvil, of course.

But you can leave a lightly leaking styrofoam cup of coffee there and just wipe the small mess off with a damp rag.

One thing for sure: with Ridgid's slide system, the extension wings, as heavy as they are (54-55 lbs. each), are the easiest to mount by one person that I've ever seen. I don't know if other granite top table saws use the same system, but it, or a similar one, seems likely.

Re: granite saw table

#5

miter slot

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't remember who made it but the one I looked at simply had a groove cut in the granite top for the steel miter gauge. Now it seems to me that steel rubbing on rock is going to wear something out and get sloppy. But, I have looked at some contractor grade of saws and they have sloppy miter gauges even on new cast iron tables.

I was at the IWF show about 4 years ago when DeWalt or Rigid or some such manufacturer was introducing a new line of table saws priced in the "contractor" range. I was snagged from the audience to demonstrate what a "great" saw it was. After a brief introduction to the saw I commented that the miter slot was excessively sloppy but was told that the saw was indeed very accurate. I was encouraged to see for myself. So I made two cuts, in one case inconspicuously forcing the sloppy miter to one side and the second cut to the other side. Then I put the ends together with an obvious "dog leg" at the joint. I thought it would be a nice saw on a job site but it didn't compete with more expensive saws in the cabinet shop.

Re: granite saw table

#6

Re: miter slot

Bill White

>I've used the granite surface plates in the machine shop (4" or more thick), but I think that saw tops from granite are just a nice sales tool to differentiate from the competition.

Somewhat porous too.

Bill

Re: granite saw table

#7

Re: Might not want to straighten a nail on it

Wayne

>

Re: granite saw table

#8

You know, I always hear that...

John in NM

>"Somewhat porous too."

But I've no idea where this idea comes from....

So I'll ask, "What makes you say that Bill?"

In all fairness, I'll warn you that I'm a geologist ;)

Re: granite saw table

#9

Re: You know, I always hear that...

Bill White

>John, I have sold many a ton of granite countertops, and even though tops are initially sealed, they will allow some water transfer. You'll see a damp spot on the underside.

As you well know, granite can have some "hidden" flaws. We do not guarantee granite tops after they are installed for that very reason, and our customers sign off on that disclaimer.

Rust free, stable, pretty shiney? You betcha.

Bill

Re: granite saw table

#10

Re: You know, I always hear that...

Dave Paine

>I first observed the granite top offered on a Steel City table saw. It seemed to offer the benefit of no rusting.

As I continued to use my present table saw, with cast iron top and my favourite featherboards with magnetic bases, I realised that a granite top would mean I would be unable to use such tools.

For my work, the use of magnetic featherboard/stops, etc. placed anywhere over the top is a bigger benefit than the potential for rust.

Every now and again I wipe on Boeshield, or Slippit to keep the rust at bay.

Now if I had teenagers around who would place their cool soda cans on the cast iron, this may cause the benefits to be different for granite.