We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Anyone know the sites that give you what the real deal is on a new car/pickup? My son is back from Afghanistan and needs a pickup. There are sites that tell you what the dealer pays and what they should be willing to accept. Any help would be appreciated?
>For the last couple of cars I've purchased, the "negotiation" has been done all by email. I've used carsdirect.com and other sites to get some baseline information. However, I did not use the dealer inquiry features of those sites. Instead, I identified all the dealers in a geographic area for which I would be willing to drive to pick up the vehicle. I emailed every one, specified features I wanted, and asked for a quote. I negotiated back and forth to get the best price. I saved hundreds of dollars and lots of time. I only had to go to the dealer to pick up the car and only had to be there about an hour. For me, it is the best, most pain-free way to purchase a car.
>In today's market, you shouldn't pay more that 75%-80% of sticker for an'08 model and 85% of sticker for an '09 model. That's a drive away price that includes all fees, tags, and registration except sales tax. Edmunds has all the pricing data. Find the vehicle, calculate a number, make a cash offer, and either drive it away or walk. It's a buyer's market.
>Maybe someone actually in the business will weigh in here. In the meantime, I will offer what I have found based on my own experience and on advice of a friend whose family was in the business for a good number of years.
First, determine the exact vehicle you want...the vehicle YOU want, not what the dealerships have on the lot. Then, go to the manufacturer's web page and configure that car, again with the options and packages that YOU want. The web site will give you the MSRP.
Most of the manufacturers' web sites will also tell you what incentives (rebates, financing, etc.) are available on the make/model you want. If not on the manufacturer's site, this info is available on Edmunds.com.
Now you are ready to buy. The ONLY way to price/buy a new vehicle is to ask one question of the dealership..."How much money, OVER OR UNDER DEALER INVOICE, do you have to have to sell me a _______ configured to my specifications?" I have done this with the last 4 new vehicles I have purchased...no games, no dickering, no "what kind of payment are you looking for..." The end result is that the MOST I have paid for any of these 4 vehicles is $200 UNDER dealer invoice.
I made all contacts via the internet. I had my price before I ever stepped foot on a lot, which eliminated all game playing (almost all, but I ended those games in 10 seconds by standing up and walking out...they chased me to my car, saying I had 'misunderstood').
What I did was to send an e-mail (the exact same e-mail) to a number of dealers, attn. general manager/fleet manager. My e-mail was almost word for word this...
"I will be ordering a 2009 Cheverolet Impala LS within the next 4 weeks. I am inviting your bid on this purchase. What I need to know is this...How much over or under dealer invoice must you have to sell me a 2009 Chevrolet Impala LS configured to my specifications?
Please base your quote on vehicle and destination charges only - I will not pay advertising costs, paperwork origination charges, or any other expense of operation. I will, however, pay legally mandated sales taxes state/local sales/registration fees, etc.
Please do not include manufacturer's rebates or other manufacturer's incentives in your quote.
I know you are busy, and so am I. I do not have time to visit each area dealership. This e-mail will be my only contact until I have chosen the dealer with whom I will place my order. All the dealers I am contacting have a reputation for excellent customer service after the sale. If they did not, I would not be contacting them. I will be ordering my new Impala from the dealer that offers me the best price.
Thank you for reading my e-mail. I am looking forward to doing business with you.
Best wishes,"
I sent this e-mail to 6-8 dealers (depending on the year) within 35 miles of me. I got responses from all but one each time. Some invited me to come in and talk. I responded "no thanks, my e-mail was clear." Each of those then sent me a price.
I chose the best price and contacted the person who e-mailed me to arrange a visit. I walked in with a list of exactly what I wanted along with the quote. One dealer tried to play games by playing 'dumb' on invoice price...he tried to include an advertising charge that was on the paperwork he said was his invoice. I didn't even respond...just got up and told my wife we were leaving, walked OUT the front door and let the sales guy catch up. He tried to tell me "that is part of the invoice...we are required to charge it." I kept walking, not saying a word. When I opened my car door, he said they could waive the charge. I said, "thanks. If you even hint at some other con game, I will never be back" and walked back in. End of games.
Not every dealer will give you a below invoice price, but ONE will. When I bought my 2006 Impala, I received bids from $500 over invoice to $400 under invoice. You have to know that invoice price is NOT what the dealer pays for the car! Dealers have a number of incentives from the factory, some varying from time to time. One that does not vary is called 'dealer holdback.' Holdback is a % of the vehicle price, typically 2.5 - 3.5%. This is the amount of money the manufacturer will send to the dealer AFTER the sale...essentially a rebate to the dealer on the invoice price. So, if a truck invoices for $10,000, the dealer will receive $300 or so back from the manufacturer. A $20,000 invoice truck will return $600 or so. So a dealer selling a truck at invoice, their theoretical cost, will make $600 or so just from the holdback. Plus, they will receive other dealer only incentives.
Now, before I get flamed here about the dealer having to make money to stay in business, I KNOW THAT! I don't expect any dealer to lose money. I just don't expect them to make a year's salary on one sale to me! At any point, the buyer and the seller can shake hands and walk away without being enemies. The fact that I have had several dealerships bidding for my business under my terms, not theirs, tells me two things...one, that my method works; two, they must be making money or they would not offer to sell me a vehicle at several hundred dollars under 'invoice.'
The simple fact is that the dealership plays this game every day. They know all the psychological tricks and are very good at using them. Examples..."someone else looked at this truck this morning, so don't take too long to think about it; how much monthly payment were you thinking about; what would I have to do right now to let you drive away in this car today; let me talk to the manager - I'll try to convince him, but...; of course, we have to add in the paperwork fee...but the state limits us to $250, which doesn't even cover our cost; we can get that truck for you from another dealer, but we'll have to add a small fee to cover our cost of going after it..." These are all games that you have to deal with if you are a 'walk-in' customer. And if you play the game, you will LOSE almost every time. Every single one of these games is eliminated by asking for bids on YOUR terms by e-mail. Do not use the dealer web site forms...use YOUR form. And keep printed copies of all communications.
Remember, make it clear that the quoted price is NOT to include mfg. incentives. Those belong to YOU, not the dealer. Get an 'over/under invoice' price, then subtract the incentives. Don't let them snowball you with supposed savings that actually include money that is yours.
Enough. You get the idea. Believe me, this method DOES work. It has worked 4 times for me, and has worked several more times for friends I have badgered into using it. It costs nothing to send out e-mails asking for bids. With the e-mail bid request system, you have everything to gain, nothing to lose. If it doesn't work, you can always go in and play their games.
>In re-reading my post, it may seem that I was paying at most $200 under invoice. This was before adding in all rebates, etc. With rebates, GM credit card earnings, etc., my actual price was far less...$3800 or so less. Some dealers will include the rebates in their advertised price, making it seem like you are getting a steal, when they are actually selling their car at hundreds or even a couple of thousand over invoice. Believe it or not, some buyers don't realize that!
>IIRC They have a service that will tell you exactly what any dealer pays for any car.
But why a new car. I can afford to buy just about any car made, but won't buy new because there are so many real nice used cars around and the discount from new is very attractive investment wise. And any new car becomes a used car the minute you sign the paperwork and that is almost an instant loss of somewhere in the range of $3,000 on an average new car(ouch).
>I would add that you should ask to see the signed sales contract early in the game. You don't know what the price will be till its signed and before it is signed provides lots of opportunity for mischief by a disreputable dealer. I have taken a hike every time a dealer has added curiously named fees to the contract "required" by this or that "regulation". I have done a lot of hiking.
I am curious why you don't just ask for a quote including rebates etc. instead of your strategy of asking for a +/- invoice price?
I know what you mean about that sort of gender bias stuff going on. My next door neighbor went to trade her 6 year old Dodge van and wanted to test drive a new smaller car. This is about 6 weeks ago. She is 35, smart and by no means a "ditzy blonde" or whatever stereotype works. I could not believe that in 2009 a male salesman at the new car lot actually told her that he would not let her test drive a car, but that she should come back with her husband and those two (the husband and salesman) could work out the deal. Unbelievable. The next day she bought what she wanted at a dealer across town, not even the same brand of car.
I told her she should drive her new one back to the first dealer and let him know that his bad attitude cost them a potential sale, but she said it wouldn't really register in his head anyway. Sadly, I had to agree with her.
>We go to an auto buying service owned and operated by a gentleman in our church. They primarily make fleet purchases and have huge amount of buying clout. We configure the vehicle exactly as desired and the buying service searches for the dealer who offers the best deal. For the best deal, the car has to be ordered from the factory which takes a few months, so it's not good for someone in a big hurry. Once a local dealer offered the best deal and another time we drove to Atlanta to pick up the car.
The times we did this the deals were astounding and all the fees were negotiated away. It is so nice to simply walk into a dealer and hand a check and drive away rather than play the negotiation game. I will not longer buy a new vehicle any other way.
The reason I don't ask for a specific price is that the equipment on a specific model varies. If I ask for a specific price this interjects the possibility of having to compare apples to oranges. Dealers want to sell the cars sitting on their lot instead of finding one in a dealer trade or ordering one. They are paying interest on the cars on their lot, and have a very good incentive to move them. The car on their lot may, or may not, be just what I want. Because they want to move their stock first, different dealers may be quoting on different specific cars. Dealer A may have one with a Bose sound system, while dealer B may have a standard system. When they quote on a specific car, I then have to do the extra work of figuring out what is included in what car and explaining why/what I want. This means being led into playing by their rules, i.e., 'dealing' on various cars. If I do that, I probably will not 'lose,' but I have to expend the energy and stress in doing so.
When I specify "...how much over or under invoice to sell me a car 'configured to my specifications' ", I can compare exactly how much money each dealer is expecting to make on the deal. I don't have to know the exact price or the exact equipment on the car being quoted. At this point, I don't even care about the configuration, just the difference in price over/under invoice between the various dealers. In short, I have found the "best' price without ever knowing the "exact" price.
Once I have picked my dealer, I can then configure my exact car. I can pick the stereo, wheels, trim, etc. and calculate the exact invoice price (easy to find now that we have the internet!). I then give my dealer the specs for the exact car I want. This is where the point about wanting to sell from THEIR lot comes in.
When I bought my TrailBlazer, they had an "almost" sitting on their lot, but it had custom wheels. I was told that it was "only" another $800, wouldn't I like to just take that one? After all, I could have it that day! (Did I mention games?) I refused and nicely said, "I'm in no hurry. I can wait for you to order one from the factory." That afternoon the sales guy called and said they had found one in Flint, MI just like I asked for...except for the Bose sound system, which would only be an extra $600. No, thank you. I don't need and won't pay for a Bose system. Of course, if you want to toss it in for the same price as a standard system... No? No problem, I'll wait for one to be built for me.
Next day I get a call...would I be willing to split the cost of the custom wheels and take the one on the lot? No, thank you, I will wait for one to be built. Then, would I go an extra $200 for the custom wheeled one on the lot? Yes, if you will add pin striping and the custom-fit wheel well mud guards (which would have cost me about $200, and that I was planning to add aftermarket anyhow). Deal done, but only because my original negotiations were not based on a specific vehicle, but my willingness and apparent insistence that I would only accept EXACTLY what I wanted, not what they had on lot (and were paying interest on).
Anyhow, a fairly long answer to a short question. Negotiating a price over/under invoice on a theoretical "built to order" car instead of a quote on a specific car allows you to compare apples to apples, and leaves open the possibility of getting an even better deal on a vehicle the dealer wants to move instead of paying interest on.
My dad always told me, "Never bet on the other man's trick." I have found this can apply to buying cars, too. :-))
>I have heard some good comments about this kind of service, John, but never used it or knew anyone who did. How did your final price (car, buying service fees, etc.) compare to the MSRP or the invoice price of the car?
>I can't disagree, Victor. Until 2000, I have always bought 2-3 year old cars with 20,000 - 50,000 miles, then drove them until they fell apart. The 'new car premium' was far to much money for me. I only changed my buying habits when manufacturers started offering tremendous rebates or extremely low (1%) interest rates, and then only after I was offered a GM credit card that would allow me to accumulate money toward the purchase of a GM vehicle.
I pay almost everything with a credit card, but pay off the bill in full at the end of the month. GM was offering a 5% credit (with no cap at the time; they have a cap now), but was charging 18% interest. The idea was to give you 5%, but charge you 18% on the balance...a gain of 13% for GM. By paying off the bill in full every month, we got the 5% credit for zero cost to us. Combine a $2000 rebate with $3000 in credit and the cost of the new car was only a tad more than for a 2 year old car, plus the new car had a full warranty.
It will likely be some time before we need another car. When we do, I will go back and do the 'used versus new' comparison again. If I decide on new, out go my e-mails again! :-)
>When I run across that sort of thing, I write a polite letter to the highest up person I can find in the business.
I cite chapter and verse and inform them I will tell any and all who will listen of the their business tactics in this supposedly enlightened age. Then I point out that the cost of attracting customers is an escalating expense to any business and express wonderment at how they then feel they can dismiss a little over half of their potential customer base.
And since their customer service is so lacking, they logically could not be expected to be in business should I need service from them in the future.
Well, you get the idea. You ought to read the letters I get back in return! One sent flowers, chocolates and an embossed letter of apology. I enjoyed the flowers and candy, and sent a note of thanks, but did not tell them they still missed the point!
>A woman I knew in grad school was getting a divorce and having car problems at the same time. She told her lawyer, who just sat and listened to her tell her tale of woe about how she would bring the car in one week and the next week something else would go wrong. This went on for more than a month and was costing her a bunch of money. Turns out, her lawyer was also lawyer for that car dealership. He told her to bring her car back to the place. She did. The car got fixed, nothing ever went wrong again and all her money was refunded.
Bruce in MN, where spring may have arrived. Just glad I don't live in Fargo.
>Don't remember the details, but the final price of the last car I bought was thousands of dollars below what I could get one similar for anywhere else, this at a time when dealers were not much inclined to discount anything. My wife bought one more recently and I don't know the details, but she was pleased with the price. She did have to wait 4 or 5 months for her car to be built and delivered from overseas.
I've always considered myself adept at squeezing the last dollar from the dealer (I have a few proven tricks of my own), but I hate every minute of it. The auto buying service method eliminates the stress and improves the quality of life!
>I never budge even a lug not. They either have exactly what I want, can find it at another dealer or make it at factory. I ask to see the manufacturer's specification book on the vehicle and I sit down and spec out exactly what I want. Numerous times I have been told this or that vehicle doesn't come with a manual transmission only to find it can be ordered with one.
On the signed contract insistence issue I ordered an Explorer with my peculiar specifications. Some time later I noticed the contract lacked the dealer signature. After two rounds of effort to get it signed the new signed version now included a $200 fee with some strange name, required by the city of Lexington KY I was solemnly told, (which sounded like horse pasture odor to me). They never go my signature on this contract and I hope they had fun selling a 2WD manual trans. Explorer to someone else (mine, fetched from Atlanta by a more honest dealer, gets routinely 25 mpg. so much for gas guzzling SUV's).
On rebates, according to daughter who woks in industry, some rebates are split rebates with part to customer and part to dealer. Some dealers will give all rebate to customer. Get this issue clear when negotiating on invoice price. It saved me $500 on one purchase.
>Not only is Invoice price different at different dealers. The same car at the same dealer can have different invoice prices depending on when the dealer bought the car. Manufactures change invoice prices about 4 - 6 times a year.
>I know of a person that walked into a dealership and told the salesperson he wanted that car, pointing to a vehicle. He then let him know that he would be paying cash for the car. Upon pulling out a large roll of cash, the salesperson started drooling. The customer then informed the dealer of the catch. He said "I know how much I am willing to pay for that car. I am going to start laying cash down on the table. I will stop when I have laid down all I will pay. If I get this far you can accept my offer or I will walk out." The salesperson was obviously overwhelmed by the sight of the cash. If I remember correctly, he paid a little over $17,000 for a $27,000 vehicle. Cash obviously speaks volumes.
Then, there is the person I work with who takes his four kids car shopping with him. They are all boys, and they are somewhat mischievous. He says the deal gets closed really quick when they start running around the show room playing. It's always been in his favor also.
>and...yes, two dealers buying the same car on the same day will pay have the same invoice price except for destination charges, which will vary according to distance shipped.
Another post here says the invoice prices may change over a period of time. I have no direct knowledge of this, so I have no reason to doubt it...it sounds reasonable since mfgs can raise prices whenever they want. What I do know is that my dealers' invoices showed the same prices I found researching on the internet.