Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

[AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

Posts

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#26

Re: Now that Bosch has been exposed

Dale Stansbery

>as the initiator of this flawed "survey", (and if they're reading the thread), I think the only way they can mitigate the error of their way is to donate a router to Ellis to put up in a benefit auction.

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#27

I Am Still A Volunteer..For The Router..

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#28

Well, there is one additional way

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>They could give a router to everyone who took the survey...

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#29

Bummer! I had it WON!!!

Joe Pack

>The router was MINE until I got to question #2...my youngest son works for an ad agency in NYC placing 'recruitment advertising' ads promoting specific companies as great places to work. I considered that when I got to this question and got kicked out. Bummer. If my kid had been unemployed, maybe I could have won something! :-)

Really, I know better than to expect a 'free' anything. I knew the survey was a marketing ploy, for lack of a better term, and that the manufacturer was doing market research. The 'free' router is just an incentive to get us to tell them what we think, which I don't mind doing.

Whether or not they offer a prize, I have no problem answering marketing surveys that are not invasive of my privacy. I will tell them what I use or don't use, what I like or don't like, etc., knowing they will use the information to possibly improve the product that I might someday buy. No big deal. I do refuse to give any kind of personal information when I think it might be traced back to me...income, race, etc. If it is completely annonymous, I don't mind giving this since it allows manufacturers to target their products to people who might want them/be able to pay for them. It makes no sense for a company selling high end $500 widgets to design them to the interests of people who buy only 50 cent whatchamacallits. Not being politically correct, I know, but it is realistic...a 'one of a kind' woodworker doesn't often solicit opinions of those of us who buy KD shelving from Value City Furniture.

Oh well, I could have used the router. Maybe my advertising/marketing employed son will buy me one for my birthday.

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#30

CURIOUS!

Nick Tuzzolino

>Of all the blades mentioned, why was Forrest omitted? Certainly better than most mentioned.

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#31

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router!

mdclor

>I think that it is great that a company actually is going to the trouble of conducting market research before making a marketing blunder which ultimately costs all purchasers of their products money. I also am happy that Ellis is able to get a little site support for posting this "Ad". I see this as an opportunity to help provide better products for consumers (us).

Regarding getting kicked out of the survey at any particular point, my thought is that this is more cost effective (from the user's time perspective) than having the participant go through the entire process and throwing out 90% of their responses. This is no problem from the surveyor's perspective-they are being respectful of your time. The way the ad was worded, any participant is eligible to win the router whether they complete the survey or not.

I think it would be beneficial if more manufacturers did this.

My 2 cents,

Merle

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#32

I don't need a sixth router...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>And of the five I have, the Bosch is the least favorite.

Of course, it is one of the trimmers. But the Porter Cables all do much better at their tasks, having each been upgraded with Pat Warner bases. The Freud brute lives in the table, never to come out free hand again.

So I'll pass on the survey...

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#33

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router!

Barry Irby

>I took the survey and made it through.

I assume that if you were dropped early you have no shot at the router because the next to last thing you do is give them your name and info if you are interested in the router.

I have to admit that I was a little cagey with my answers because of the responses here. I thought through my answers based on what It thought they were looking for. Did not lie, just edited a bit.

They might get better answers if you were free to say any thing and still have a shot at the router. They could delete you from consideration of your replies on their end without you realizing you had been dropped.

I don't remember the second question, but who's opinion are they not interested in? Perhaps if you said "I never use such a blade and don't know anything about them, and will never buy one....."

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#34

Hey Ellis...Why not ask why?

Barry Irby

>I made it through the survey. I found it curious that they showed all those "brands" and logos and asked which appealed to you, but not why it attracted your attention.

Also, as I recall, all the graphics were the same. Very similar general layout and they must have had a lot of paint in those colors. Clearly they thought they had the color scheme down pat.

They did not ask WHY I picked the one I did. Do they not care? Is it just that I picked it and if everyone else agrees that's it?

I addressed this to you Ellis becasue you said you had been on the other side of this.

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#35

No accountin' for taste

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I guess the only thing that is important to the marketing group is whether buyers will prefer one over the other. (Brilliant deduction, eh? :-) This is objective proof of concept to them. Back when I worked for Rodale Press, the book division ran surveys all the time testing titles for prospective books "(Which of the following books would you buy if you could choose only one?..."), most of which hadn't even been written yet. The title that tested highest became the title of the book, and then the book was written to that title. It's just a simple way to gain a low-hanging advantage.

That's my guess.

Ellis

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#36

Re: Hey Ellis...Why not ask why?

Mark Nowicki

>Well, I made it to the finals.

For the purpose of this survey I am a female cabinetmaker, between 20-25 years of age, annual income over $150K, and I spend over $44K on tools and accessories.

Just reading the above I feel like a winner.

Mark

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#37

Re: Marketing realities

Jonathan in Minneapolis

>Ellis,

I made it through the survey, but I still think a better solution for the advertiser would have been to take those who don't fit the profile right to the last screen where they enter for the prize. Those people took their time to fill out the survey, too and they should be entered.

If they are worried about someone who doesn't fit the profile winning the router, then give away two, making sure at least one goes to someone who fits the profile. Surely the cost a router is miniscule compared to the market budget for launching a new product line.

Jonathan

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#38

You always win, Bill...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>... if you approach things calmly and remember that we're all here because we have something very powerful and important in common. I have no problem with people expressing their opinions; it's what we're all about here. I'm as anxious as anyone to get things straightened out to everyone's satisfaction, and that will only happen with good feedback and positive energy working toward a solution. The survey sponsor has gotten back to me since we began investigating the grievances here. They have not modified the survey (yet) to qualify everyone to win, but we've hashed out some language that will spare some of our would-be respondents the trouble of starting to fill out the survey and then being rejected.

I see this sort of manufacturer/customer feedback loop as something WoodCentral can facilitate pretty well, and I hope to do more of these surveys. You guys get a chance to win something cool and the manufacturer gets valuable information regarding their products or strategic planning. Win win. We like that.

Ellis

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#39

And here was my suggestion...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I think they should get the respondents' names and contact information up front and automatically qualify everyone who completes the survey for a chance at the prize. They can easily throw out the responses of anyone whose profile isn't useful to their marketing decisions.

Ellis

Re: [AD] Take a Survey -- Win a Router! *LINK*

#40

Re: You always win, Bill...

Frank Orfanello

>Ellis,

I agree. This site is a great resource for manufacturers and marketers to learn and test. It is also benefical to us to get input into new products, so a win-win.

The bad part, I thought a number of teh survey questions were very poorly worded, and the sponsor may not get the results they think they are getting.

But I took the survey and will happily accept thier router.